NationStates Jolt Archive


E20 Alternate History Roleplay Version 3.0 - Page 12

Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [12]
Warta Endor
26-08-2006, 17:44
Italy is taken, Holland however is free.

Aha, I misread GB's claimlist. Can I take the Netherlands then?
Canadstein
26-08-2006, 19:08
Yes you can, but you have to wait until monday.
Amestria
26-08-2006, 23:36
As no final decision has as yet been made I have decided to arbitrarily settle the matter of who gets Austria-Hungry along the lines of GB's Recommendations and the views of the majority of players.

Updated List

I. Europe:
The United Kingdom of Great Britain ~
[NS]Parthini GB Recommend
The German Empire ~
Safehaven2 GB Recommend
The Third Republic of France ~
Amestria GB Recommend
The Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary ~
Kordo GB Recommend
The Russian Empire ~
Kilani GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Belgium ~
The Kingdom of Netherlands ~
The Kingdom of Italy ~
Artitsa GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Sweden ~
Kirstina GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Rumania ~
Rodenka GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Greece ~
Whittlesfield GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Spain ~
Sukiaida GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Portugal ~
The Kingdom of Serbia ~
Elephantum GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Norway ~
World Zionist Organization ~


II. South America:
- The Republic of Brazil ~
Koryan
- The Republic of Argentina ~
Malkyer GB Recommend
- The Republic of Chile ~
Sharina

III. North America:
- The United States of America
Cylea GB Recommend
- The Dominion of Canada
Lachenburg GB Recommend
- The United States of Mexico ~

IV. Asia:
- The Kingdom of Siam ~
Middle Snu
- The Empire of Japan ~
Haneastic
- The Sublime Ottoman State ~
Ottoman Khaif GB Recommend
- The Qajar Persian Empire ~
- The KMT party in China ~
New Dornalia GB Recommend

V. Africa:
- The Union of South Africa ~
The Lightning Star GB Recommend
- The Kingdom of Morocco ~
Abbassia GB Recommend
- The Kingdom of Ethiopia ~
Canadstein GB Recommend

VI. Oceania:
- The Dominion of Austrialia

Key:
Green ~ Potential Claim
Red ~ Confirmed Claim
Kirstiriera
27-08-2006, 00:28
Note: I believe Nicaragua should also listed as a Non-Player Nation...
Galveston Bay
27-08-2006, 00:31
As no final decision has as yet been made I have decided to arbitrarily settle the matter of who gets Austria-Hungry along the lines of GB's Recommendations and the views of the majority of players.

Updated List

I. Europe:
The United Kingdom of Great Britain ~
[NS]Parthini GB Recommend
The German Empire ~
Safehaven2 GB Recommend
The Third Republic of France ~
Amestria GB Recommend
The Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary ~
Kordo GB Recommend
The Russian Empire ~
Kilani GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Belgium ~
The Kingdom of Netherlands ~
The Kingdom of Italy ~
Artitsa GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Sweden ~
Kirstina GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Rumania ~
Rodenka GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Greece ~
Whittlesfield GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Spain ~
Sukiaida GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Portugal ~
The Kingdom of Serbia ~
Elephantum GB Recommend
The Kingdom of Norway ~
World Zionist Organization ~


II. South America:
- The Republic of Brazil ~
Koryan
- The Republic of Argentina ~
Malkyer GB Recommend
- The Republic of Chile ~
Sharina

III. North America:
- The United States of America
Cylea GB Recommend
- The Dominion of Canada
Lachenburg GB Recommend
- The United States of Mexico ~

IV. Asia:
- The Kingdom of Siam ~
Middle Snu
- The Empire of Japan ~
Haneastic
- The Sublime Ottoman State ~
Ottoman Khaif GB Recommend
- The Qajar Persian Empire ~
- The KMT party in China ~
New Dornalia GB Recommend

V. Africa:
- The Union of South Africa ~
The Lightning Star GB Recommend
- The Kingdom of Morocco ~
Abbassia GB Recommend
- The Kingdom of Ethiopia ~
Canadstein GB Recommend

VI. Oceania:
- The Dominion of Austrialia

Key:
Green ~ Potential Claim
Red ~ Confirmed Claim



I can live with this... any complaints, TG me
Galveston Bay
27-08-2006, 00:34
Note: I believe Nicaragua should also listed as a Non-Player Nation...

it will be added... hope to create the new thread tomorrow, along with posting rules etc to website
Malkyer
27-08-2006, 01:24
Lesser Ribena, I was looking at the Argentine Navy on wikipedia, and there's a pretty big discrepancy between what's listed there and what you have as the Armada Republica in 1906.

According to your list, Argentina has in service 8 cruisers and 26 torpedo boats.

However, the wiki article says that the ARA maintains 3 battleships, 4 armored cruisers, 2 monitors, 5 cruisers, 6 gunboats, and a sailing frigate.

I'm not sure what a monitor is (possibly the Argentine classification for a protected cruiser), and I don't know how gunboats would be represented in game terms, but it seems that my navy is a good bit larger and more powerful than I originally thought.
Amestria
27-08-2006, 01:50
According to your list, Argentina has in service 8 cruisers and 26 torpedo boats.

However, the wiki article says that the ARA maintains 3 battleships, 4 armored cruisers, 2 monitors, 5 cruisers, 6 gunboats, and a sailing frigate.

This has already been covered, those "battleships" are glorified cruisers that are being called battleships and monitors are civil war era gun ships.
Malkyer
27-08-2006, 02:02
Hmm...now that you mention it, "monitors" being American Civil War-type ironclads is pretty obvious. The monitors and gunboats are all old (1875ish), and two of the battleships are classified as "river battleships." It seems I got carried away at first, though as far as I can tell the French-built ARA Almirante Brown (entered service 1881) is an actual battleship, albeit an old one.
Haneastic
27-08-2006, 16:43
Might be able to get on tommorrow, if not then a factbook for Japan will be posted, eventually
Lesser Ribena
27-08-2006, 18:10
I have double (in some cases triple or quadrouple) checked everyone's navy so they should be correct. Amestria has recalled correctly, a lot of the smaller navies maintained cruisers with large guns and called them battleships, most of these had very weak (often wooden) armour and were useless in blue water situations so I have neglected to list them. The same goes for monitors which I has omitted or classed as torpedo boats as they were little more than floating platforms for guns (and in some cases torpedoes) for use on rivers or coasts.

Though built as a battleship in 1880, the Almirante Brown was highly obsolete by 1906 and just used as a coastal battleship. Take a look at the pictures at:

http://www.battleships-cruisers.co.uk/argentine_navy.htm

Though the vessel was kept in service until 1932, it really is quite useless against any other navy vessels around in 1906. It was steam powered and still had some sails, with poor armour and obsolete gun positioning (no turrets, below decks). To be honest your navy is better off without it, using the freed up man power to man other vessels rather than a ship that would be a death trap in any naval engagement.
Ato-Sara
27-08-2006, 18:12
Damn you people for having a restart while I was away!...

Now all three nations that I would consider playing are taken...... bugger


I don't have a clue what to do know.
Canadstein
27-08-2006, 18:20
You could play as the Netherlands.
Malkyer
27-08-2006, 18:22
<snip>

Okay, thanks for clearing that up.
Lachenburg
27-08-2006, 18:51
You could play as the Netherlands.

I think Warta is taking the Netherlands, actually.

Nonetheless, there are still several European nations (one of which is Belgium) that are open for claiming (although claiming, it seems, doesn't begin until Monday). Also Mexico and Persia are both open for claiming.
Middle Snu
27-08-2006, 18:54
Australia's open and interesting.
Ato-Sara
27-08-2006, 18:59
Australia's open and interesting.

*Glares evilly at Middle Snu for stealing Siam*
:p

Nah Austrialias's not for me.
I might try Indochinese sepratists (Viet Minh again... *sigh*) or something similar...
Middle Snu
27-08-2006, 19:03
I never thought that someone would get mad at me for stealing Siam. Besides Morocco, it's the most useless player country around.
Ato-Sara
27-08-2006, 19:04
I never thought that someone would get mad at me for stealing Siam. Besides Morocco, it's the most useless player country around.

Nope, hehe I've said I wanted Siam from the beggining of talks about restarting. But if you got it first I can live with it.
Warta Endor
27-08-2006, 19:43
I'm working on my factbook for the netherlands. I understand that claims will become official tomorrow, so I'll wait with posting till then ;)

BTW, Siam was a pretty decent country. It had a fairly strong army being a bufferstate between the French (Indochina) and the British (Malaya, Burma/British India).
[NS]Parthini
27-08-2006, 19:50
How are we going to work out the maintainence for our militaries? I know I have a lot of Battleships, but I don't know how much they will cost, etc.
Lesser Ribena
27-08-2006, 20:42
GB will post new economics and military threads with all the required details on them soon.
Elephantum
27-08-2006, 23:29
Ato-Sara: If you want Serbia (which actually can do quite a bit in the opening years), feel free to take it. I was going to take it as a temporary measure until the WZO or another movement became stronger, but it would be better off with a full time player, although you could take it as a temporary nation if you wanted.
[NS]Parthini
28-08-2006, 00:18
BTW, I would vouch for New Dracora. He's in my Region and a very good roleplayer.
Ato-Sara
28-08-2006, 00:25
Ato-Sara: If you want Serbia (which actually can do quite a bit in the opening years), feel free to take it. I was going to take it as a temporary measure until the WZO or another movement became stronger, but it would be better off with a full time player, although you could take it as a temporary nation if you wanted.


Thanks, but I prefer Asian nations and there is always something I can do there even if I can't have my beloved Siam.
Canadstein
28-08-2006, 00:48
I would have to say Persia.
Galveston Bay
28-08-2006, 01:02
and we are off
http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showpost.php?p=11605137&postcount=1

by the way, let this thread die

I will be keep track of it for getting the rules etc
Vietnamexico
24-11-2006, 20:38
May I join as a Basque nationalist group? I will not be able to be the most active RPer(due to commitments with the off-site Earth 7 RP), however, I will make up for that with quality posts, that is, if you allow me to join
Koryan
24-11-2006, 21:43
Did you not notice that the last post on this thread was August? Try the new thread.