NationStates Jolt Archive


Robots Leaving Workers Jobless

The Faraoh
12-05-2007, 01:12
I'm currently an "Iron Fist Consumerits" and I want to be a "Psychotic Dictatorship", meaning I want a more controlled economy. I can't see the difference between options 1 and 4...

What should I choose?

Here's the issue:

Robots Leaving Workers Jobless

Amidst a growing level of unemployment, thousands of workers have been fired and then replaced by automatic systems. They have petitioned you to intervene.
The Debate

1. "It's just sickening! Do you know how long it took most of us to get a decent, 'stable' job?" shouts Bill Winters, president of the The Faraoh Labour Alliance, before dramatically sweeping your personal belongings off your desk. "And now we're losing our livelihoods to robots so that while our families starve, the corporations get even richer! Don't let the capitalist pigs blind you! This practice must be banned!"
[Accept]

2. "Hey, I've got a job to keep up too, you know," says Elizabeth Licorish, a factory manager. "If I don't think of new ways of keeping costs down, the investors will go elsewhere. It's my neck on the line as much as anyone else's, even if I do have much more money. Besides, it's business, and no-one ought to be able to say who - or what - I can hire."
[Accept]

3. "This could be resolved if instead of replacing workers with machines, we added machines to workers!" enthuses Dave McAlpin, CEO of Mondas Ltd. "By replacing the body parts with stronger, better, metal prostheses, we can make the best industrial workers - literally - in the world! Imagine a shelver who can shift whole crates with just one arm! One finger! So let's hear no more of this deplorable 'replacing workers with machines' idea and look to the future!"
[Accept]

4. "You can't allow that!" gasps Beth Jong-Il, a manual labourer. "If that happens, only the people with cyber limbs will get jobs! And the corporations will contract you into having the surgery if you want to have one! No thank you! We should go back to the grass roots of industry when all the machines weren't computerised and workers were the salt of the earth! Then maybe we'd see a bit more appreciation! And cash!"
[Accept]
Markeliopia
12-05-2007, 07:36
Thats interesting, despite the stats I think choice 3 is the most awsome :D

err edit: I think it sounds like 1 is more anti capitalist while 4 is more focoused on anti machines, so I think 1 would be the best for lowering economic freedom

thats just what it looks like to me but they are both pretty similar
I V Stalin
12-05-2007, 10:37
Option 4 is advising getting rid of all machines in industry - the Luddite choice, I guess. Option 1 is just saying that the proposal that's the basis of the issue shouldn't be allowed.
Angels World
12-05-2007, 17:46
Is that a new issue? I've never seen it before.

Whoever wrote that did a great job. That issue opens up the possibility of giving the economy of the nations that choose option 1 a major boost.
I V Stalin
12-05-2007, 19:00
It's #193. Not particularly new (it's around 9 months old, maybe), but not really old either.