NationStates Jolt Archive


Terrible issue

Masked Cucumbers
03-12-2004, 17:14
A surprise raid conducted on ISPs over the last week in Masked Cucumbers shows that more than 30% of all Internet data transfer in Masked Cucumbers at one time or another is used by illegal file-shares to illegally distribute files, most notably songs.
The Debate

1. "What we need to do is hack their computers and format their hard drives," says Gregory Licorish, recording industry representative. "People need to be taught to not mess with the law. This is theft pure and simple. And they're not only halving our revenue to tune of billions of liquid bretzels, but you are also stealing a few hundredths of a liquid bretzel from the artist for every song they steal. THINK OF THE STARVING ARTISTS!"
[Accept]

2. "Yo, dude, like, don't be hatin' man," says teenager Calvin Broadside. "We're like, going to change the whole structure of our society. Everything should be like, publicly available to, like, everybody, dude. Copyrights are so, like, uncool man and we need to get rid of them. That'd be totally radical, and cool as well."
[Accept]

3. "Yo, dang, blizzity blang, yo, this ain't, right, yo," says Akira Gutenberg, famous rapper with three platinum albums. "Dang, yo, we dang need to copy-protect my dang CDs, yo. That dang playability life dang decreases, yo, but it's the only way to stop this, dang, yo."
[Accept]

2 of the solution are almost the same (except that the solution of the famous rapper is almost unreadable). We have the choice between:
1) Formatting hard drives that can have important files in it, which is clearly stupid (it is like: someone stole something? We'll take everything he has).
2) a solution that isn't bad in my opinion, except the artists gain absolutely nothing and therefore either die or stop playing
3) the solution to decrease the quality so CDs are even less bought.

While the only solution that could work, and it is the solution that is currently happening in real life, is a better offer of music by the corporations, throught the internet as well.

This is a common problem with issues: we always have the choice between extreme right and extreme left :/
Tuesday Heights
03-12-2004, 18:10
This is a common problem with issues: we always have the choice between extreme right and extreme left :/

That's because the entire idea of this game is extremes. It's based on a book that discusses the extreme form of Capitalism, Capitalizm, and as such, the game revolves around making extreme issue choices with unintended consequences.
Kylestania
03-12-2004, 21:00
I have yet to have an issue with a "perfect! thats just what I would do" choice, just pick the one that is closest. In this case I picked #2,
Rasputin the Thief
04-12-2004, 12:05
I have yet to have an issue with a "perfect! thats just what I would do" choice, just pick the one that is closest. In this case I picked #2,

with the consequence of losing all culture in the country except for a very small group of freaks, that is going smaller everyday because their poverty marginalize them.

I had to dismiss the issue :'(
Tuesday Heights
04-12-2004, 17:54
I have yet to have an issue with a "perfect! thats just what I would do" choice,

And that's where the "fun" of issue choosing comes into play. If you found the "perfect" solution to every problem, then, you'd be God of your nation, not leader of it.

I had to dismiss the issue :'(

A fair number of people do that, too. ;)
Chessieland
04-12-2004, 17:55
The only issue I have dismissed twice now is the one where that talks about pirivatizing prisons. Your options are like

A) Privitaze all prisons

b) Close down all prisons

c) Execute all criminals

I can't believe this issue got accepted without a "Spend more moeny to improve the prisons we have" option. So in cases like this where none of the choices even come close to what I would do I have to dismiss it.

That's the only one thats come up multiple times though.
Tuesday Heights
04-12-2004, 18:37
That's the only one thats come up multiple times though.

Ah, well, you haven't been here long enough to know better! ;)
Procco
04-12-2004, 18:41
something

Three options are usually what's necessary to give the game its edge. There's be no point if every issue had a perfect answer.

Just dismiss the ones that you really cant agree with.

As for those that I have found a perfect answer to:


>Option 4 or whatever the last option was on the malpractice insurance issue

>The option that allows the harry potter books to continue on the harry potter issue.