NationStates Jolt Archive


Ruling requested on 'At Vote' resolution.

Rubina
23-05-2007, 14:36
The resolution currently at vote contains the following "sunshine clause"IN LIEU OF direct UN funding:

-PERMITS the World Bank to assess minimal fees on exchanges, but limits those fees to the minimum needed to maintain the World Bank;

-ELIMINATES these fees should alternative funding be passed by the UN;

Not having examined previous resolutions with a fine-tooth comb I can't say for certain, but this seems like the first attempt to use such an animal. I like it; I like it a lot and if it's legal plan to use it frequently. But... even as a clause that only affects a portion of the resolution, it seems a little close to both self-repeal and controlling future action of the UN.

It was only added just before submission, so the author's assumption that y'all have seen it and approved may be in error, and a ruling would be appreciated.

Thank you kindly.
Frisbeeteria
23-05-2007, 18:16
I don't see any immediate problem with it. The game doesn't manage events down to the transaction level, as this does. As far as the sunset provision goes, I don't think it's necessary, but I don't think it's illegal either.

Don't start using this until we've had a chance to cogitate on it a bit longer. We're stuck with it as a precedent if it passes, since once it goes to the floor we can't delete it ... but we may file a delayed ruling if some of the other game mods catch something I missed.
Rubina
23-05-2007, 19:09
Will do. Thanks again.