NationStates Jolt Archive

This is largely in response to this...



OOC: And not that good of an RP'er either - I'm suprised at the small amount of ignore cannons fired.

So I wanted to gauge opinion of my RPing abilities.

Afrika, I thought my spelling was essentially beyond reproach. I am hurt. I really am. :(

I remember scanning over some threads in which you posted, but could you post links of some of your RP ability in this thread?

http://forums2.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=340939

http://forums2.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=335848

http://forums2.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=341353

Thank you, CM! *reading*

And no, that was not a terribly poor-disgused attempt at a bump.

Thank you, CM! *reading*

And no, that was not a terribly poor-disgused attempt at a bump.

The Operation Purification RP is nearly done, but it is still quite long. :)

I'm not for white supremacy, but youre a wonderful RPer...

Well, you definitely know your military stuff. I didn't see any major grammatical or spelling errors. I did not like that ALL 50 million people (if I remember correctly) going from Cummunist Mississippi to Libya would be in the Libyan army, as well as the native Libyans would have to support their white colonists in their own army. If my nation were taken over, my people would never serve in an army that would protect those foreign oppressors.

At least you give numbers of people and military craft. You don't report casualties of your enemies for them. Suna Kaya has a BIG beef against godmodding. Overall, pretty good job, CM! I don't like what your nation is doing in that "purification" plan, but that is besides the point.

I'm not certain if I should vote for myself or abstain due to an obvious and blatant conflict of interest.

Inner turmoil, decisions, decisions. Turmoil...

Well, you definitely know your military stuff. I didn't see any major grammatical or spelling errors. I did not like that ALL 50 million people (if I remember correctly) going from Cummunist Mississippi to Libya would be in the Libyan army, as well as the native Libyans would have to support their white colonists in their own army. If my nation were taken over, my people would never serve in an army that would protect those foreign oppressors.

At least you give numbers of people and military craft. You don't report casualties of your enemies for them. Suna Kaya has a BIG beef against godmodding. Overall, pretty good job, CM! I don't like what your nation is doing in that "purification" plan, but that is besides the point.


The Colonial Army is an army made of White Colonists.

Also the Libyan Army was smashed in other RPs, so the way for settlement was open.

Well your writing is pretty decent, but your unrealistic in a lot of respects. On a side note I completely ignored your "take-over" of those African nations.

You border on godmodding in some parts, but your writing style is fine.

Since you forgot to include an option dealing with technicallites as opposed to writng i better explain myself: you write rahter well but soem of your stuff just goes past my own personal bench mark of what i would judge the GM word being applied to.

your roleplaying is better than most, but it usually takes two good rpers to make a good rp

your roleplaying is better than most, but it usually takes two good rpers to make a good rp


Agreed. Which is why I especially enjoy Rping with nations such as UWA, DPUO, Parthia, Dimmimar, ANL, and a few others, (Sorry if I forgot to name you specifically, but what the heck, I've just gotten out of the shower and I'm not even dried off yet. So I'm out of here to go dry off)

Well, you certainly seem to have a good bit of spare time to devote to your RPing. I concur with some of the others in that your writing (and storytelling) is done very well. However, it does appear that at times your scenarios border on the unrealistic. But, hey, that just one man's opinion . . . Keep on posting, Dude!

OOC: CM, you should try and make anunbiased poll, it's probably your subconscious but you prod people into voting optimistically. :) Everyone knows you can spell well but that doesn't mean you can RP well. My spelling has been sound (I think) but my RPing skills have been dead lately. I voted "Decent, nothing special, but nothing bad." This is not because you're a bad RPer, not at all, but I don't think you write better than most, should you have said "Good, on a par with the RPing community" I would voted on that. Just a tip.

Unless of course....the prodding was intentional :P

LOL, I know the real purpose of this thread...so you know who doesn't like you oocly, otherwise you wouldn't have made it a public poll :p

Well it seems a healthy percentage of people think I RP better than avg. A large number think I'm decent.

The vast majority think I'm decent if not better.

A few don't like my RPing style, and a good number don't like me OCC.


I expected results along those lines.

By the way, i would like to change my decision in light of current events to: I HATE YOU OOCly AND ICly.....