Quick Opinion - Attn
http://img50.photobucket.com/albums/v152/doujincorp/saviour1.png
or
http://img50.photobucket.com/albums/v152/doujincorp/saviour.png
((Note, medical ships are generally white))
http://www.vnh.org/GMO/Admin/Image/ship.jpg
I like the 2nd one better.
Isselmere
12-04-2004, 16:14
The second. Otherwise, people can always argue, "It looked like a legitimate target."
Jordaxia
12-04-2004, 16:19
The second, although, Americans may still argue it's a legitimate target, what with the red crosses on it and all that. (Joke. Don't kill me!)
Complete visibility with a battle group is not always a good thing, red crosses should be adequate markers.....
Jeruselem
12-04-2004, 16:36
2nd one, because it's looks like our flag ... 8)
Isselmere
13-04-2004, 04:53
Complete visibility with a battle group is not always a good thing, red crosses should be adequate markers.....
In a perfect world, maybe. Still, as hospital ships (as serious case treatment centres) are generally kept well away from battlefronts and are often adequately protected, something big and white shouldn't be a problem.
Autonomous City-states
13-04-2004, 05:03
I second following maritime convention and going with the all-white scheme. Leave no ambiguity.
Great Mateo
13-04-2004, 05:07
I'd prefer the big white one, though it kind of is a lose lose situation. The grey leaves it open to being confused for part of a battlegroup, the white one is a giant sign saying "BLOW THIS UP!" for total sadists.
Autonomous City-states
13-04-2004, 05:09
I'd big white one, though it kind of is a lose lose situation. The grey leaves it open to being confused for part of a battlegroup, the white one is a giant sign saying "BLOW THIS UP!" for total sadists.
And if your enemy is a total sadist that would attack hospital ships... there isn't much they can do to protect themselves anyways.
Great Mateo
13-04-2004, 05:18
I'd big white one, though it kind of is a lose lose situation. The grey leaves it open to being confused for part of a battlegroup, the white one is a giant sign saying "BLOW THIS UP!" for total sadists.
And if your enemy is a total sadist that would attack hospital ships... there isn't much they can do to protect themselves anyways.
Submarine hospital ships, my friend- available soon from Great Matean Industries. :D
:roll:
One thing, though.. Doujin's ships.. are white.. lol..
http://img50.photobucket.com/albums/v152/doujincorp/leviathon.png
Callisdrun
13-04-2004, 05:24
third one... it looks nothing like a combat vessal, so it would be harder to justify sinking it.
erm, the third one wasn't an option :P Just showing what hospital ships normally look like.
But Callisdrun does make a point, you should make the ship a little more boxy. IMHO - the two ships look like battleships with a red cross painted on the side.
Colorwise, take the one that's different from your normal color. You need to distinguish it from all of the other ships in your navy.
Callisdrun
13-04-2004, 05:57
hmmm, I'd say paint giant red crosses all over it, make it less sleek looking, more like a merchant vessal.
by the way, what do you use to make your line drawings?
Autonomous City-states
13-04-2004, 13:31
I'd big white one, though it kind of is a lose lose situation. The grey leaves it open to being confused for part of a battlegroup, the white one is a giant sign saying "BLOW THIS UP!" for total sadists.
And if your enemy is a total sadist that would attack hospital ships... there isn't much they can do to protect themselves anyways.
Submarine hospital ships, my friend- available soon from Great Matean Industries. :D
So, what do you do when there needs to be an emergency evac of someone off or onto the ship and it is submerged?
Jordaxia
13-04-2004, 13:34
Well then it would rise surely? It makes no difference whether it is 1km to the east, or that distance straight down, surely.
2nd, not looking like a battleship is a plus. Speaking of which, remind me to paint crosses one my Battelships.
Kihameria
13-04-2004, 13:53
the bottom one, or it will look like a frigate or something, SONAR doesnt work on the sides of ships, which is where the medical symbols are, so SONAR would pick up a frigate or destroyer or something.
kinda same thing with RADAR, it just shows something, not a medical ship or anything.
id say the 4th pic you put up :P [/lame joke]
anyway, id say make a design from scratch for it that doesnt loook so much like a battleship. perhaps a multihull ship. i can sell you catamarans if you want :P
Callisdrun
17-04-2004, 02:07
Make it look a bit like a freighter or an ocean liner. Try to make it look as little like a warship as possible
Crossroads Inc
17-04-2004, 02:09
A quick note, If all Doujin Naval 'War'ships ARE white, it may be good to make your medship Not white, tradtionally you want medships to stick out so peopple, well, know there Medships.
The Zoogie People
17-04-2004, 02:09
I personally think the second one is the one you should go with, although it should be put against a lightwer, more cerulean backdrop.
[Post 2222? Interesting...]