NationStates Jolt Archive


Follow-up on Idiot PC Canadian Students

Hotwife
03-12-2008, 01:56
You may remember this one:

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=992946

where some idiots, in the name of political correctness ("it only affects white males") decided to boot their support of cystic fibrosis research.

Apparently, they were informed that it affects more than white males, and that they were not only wrong, but inanely stupid to boot, having embarassed their school.

http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2008/12/02/ot-shinerama-081202.html



The student council at an Ottawa university has reversed its controversial decision to pull out of an annual fundraiser for the Canadian Cystic Fibrosis Foundation.

Following vocal protests from students, the Carleton University Students Association voted unanimously Monday night to:

* Support next year's cystic fibrosis fundraiser, called Shinerama.
* Donate at least $1,000 to the organization.
* Issue a formal apology.

In addition, the student councillor who crafted the controversial motion to drop the fundraiser resigned.

Donnie Northrup received hate mail and death threats after he suggested the council find a new charity to support during Orientation Week instead of participating in the same fundraiser as other universities across the country.

His motion incorrectly claimed the disease affects "only white people, and primarily men" and said students should feel their fundraising efforts "will serve their diverse communities."

One other councillor, Sean Maguire, also resigned.

"I love this university," he said, sniffling, his voice choked with emotion. "And it pains me to no end to know that we have damaged its reputation."

Ariel Kimmel, a second-year political science student at Carleton, said the student council embarrassed the whole university.

"I really hope there's lessons learned — that they do need to start representing their students better," she said.

Meanwhile, a group on campus has submitted a petition signed by 1,000 students calling for the student association president, Brittany Smyth, to be impeached over the incident, which they are calling "Shinerama-gate."

As part of Shinerama, students across the country shine shoes, wash cars and hold other activities in September that have raised $18.5 million for the foundation since 1964. The money goes toward research on cystic fibrosis and services for people who have the fatal, genetic disease.

The disease affects mainly the lungs and digestive system, causing a buildup of thick mucus that leads to infection and inflammation. The incidence of the disease is roughly equal among men and women, and it primarily affects Caucasians, including people of Middle Eastern and Indian descent.


If Brittany Smyth has any decency, she should resign before being impeached.
Neesika
03-12-2008, 01:57
Carleton is a laughing stock right now. No really. We were laughing at them all day, in addition to fighting about the coalition. Good times.
Hotwife
03-12-2008, 01:59
Carleton is a laughing stock right now. No really. We were laughing at them all day, in addition to fighting about the coalition. Good times.

Any photos of the look on Harper's face when he found out the rug was being pulled out from under him?
The Cat-Tribe
03-12-2008, 03:23
If you remember correctly, when you raised this issue originally, I noted (http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showpost.php?p=14249356&postcount=12):


this was a small obscure group of college students, not some PC police
the story was not quite what you protrayed it as
the student group was already planning to reconsider -- which they obviously did
the "white man's disease" thing was just one student's opinion and not part of the official record -- let alone the official reason for the decision


I am entirely unsure as to why Ms. Smyth should resign -- let alone be impeached. Isn't a reversal of the earlier foolish decision exactly what was called for?
New Mitanni
03-12-2008, 04:13
You may remember this one:

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=992946

where some idiots, in the name of political correctness ("it only affects white males") decided to boot their support of cystic fibrosis research.

Apparently, they were informed that it affects more than white males, and that they were not only wrong, but inanely stupid to boot, having embarassed their school.

http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2008/12/02/ot-shinerama-081202.html



If Brittany Smyth has any decency, she should resign before being impeached.


And if pigs have wings, they'll be pigeons.

There are few things more enjoyable that watching PC idiots exposed to the public ridicule and contempt they so richly deserve. :D
Knights of Liberty
03-12-2008, 04:13
And if pigs have wings, they'll be pigeons.

There are few things more enjoyable that watching PC idiots exposed to the public ridicule and contempt they so richly deserve. :D

One of those few things is when it happens to right wingers.
Sparkelle
03-12-2008, 05:11
Student governments at unis are always embarassingly stupid
Rathanan
03-12-2008, 05:23
Student governments at unis are always embarassingly stupid

Normally, yes... I went to an extremely small University for my undergrad and I was in the Student Government there (and was President my Senior year)... Things are a lot less stupid when your school is small because there aren't as many things to deal with.

But this story earns a sincere and hardy rofl.
Cannot think of a name
03-12-2008, 06:50
If you remember correctly, when you raised this issue originally, I noted (http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showpost.php?p=14249356&postcount=12):


this was a small obscure group of college students, not some PC police
the story was not quite what you protrayed it as
the student group was already planning to reconsider -- which they obviously did
the "white man's disease" thing was just one student's opinion and not part of the official record -- let alone the official reason for the decision


I am entirely unsure as to why Ms. Smyth should resign -- let alone be impeached. Isn't a reversal of the earlier foolish decision exactly what was called for?
The OP has misrepresented a story? I am shocked, shocked I say!


Who has my winnings?
Knights of Liberty
03-12-2008, 07:24
Who has my winnings?

No one, we all bet on the same side you did.
Cannot think of a name
03-12-2008, 07:29
No one, we all bet on the same side you did.

http://home.earthlink.net/~8-h-haggis/ImShocked.jpg
Anti-Social Darwinism
03-12-2008, 09:53
Student governments at unis are always embarassingly stupid

Have you looked at Boards of Regents and Academic Senates lately? I know of nothing more embarassing than University governing bodies. Amazing how many presumably intelligent people can be so resoundingly dumb.
Cameroi
03-12-2008, 10:03
the real idiots are the coiners of the phraise 'political correctness', to trivialize real morality. of course since then, now, it has gotten a whole lot more muddied even then that, but i still see the use of the term as a kind of brainwashing doublespeak.
Ferrous Oxide
03-12-2008, 10:09
Good. PC scum.
Newer Burmecia
03-12-2008, 10:16
Perhaps I've missed something, but who cares?
Callisdrun
03-12-2008, 10:20
It's a giant conspiracy to persecute white males!
Newer Burmecia
03-12-2008, 10:21
Have you looked at Boards of Regents and Academic Senates lately? I know of nothing more embarassing than University governing bodies. Amazing how many presumably intelligent people can be so resoundingly dumb.
If the 'zomg PC liberals' crowd (which is what this whole thing is about) wants me to post whenever my Union or the NUS does something embarassingly silly and gets caught out we could have a thread every week. At the moment, they're trying to ban the Officer's Training Corps, but they'll get nowhere after the referendum, I hope.
Tagmatium
03-12-2008, 12:33
If the 'zomg PC liberals' crowd (which is what this whole thing is about) wants me to post whenever my Union or the NUS does something embarassingly silly and gets caught out we could have a thread every week. At the moment, they're trying to ban the Officer's Training Corps, but they'll get nowhere after the referendum, I hope.
Sometimes you wonder where they get their ideas from.
Newer Burmecia
03-12-2008, 12:39
Sometimes you wonder where they get their ideas from.
Socialist Students.
Laerod
03-12-2008, 13:19
There are few things more enjoyable that watching PC idiots exposed to the public ridicule and contempt they so richly deserve. :DUnfortunately, no one's been hung, drawn, or quartered for the outrage that was the outrage over "nipple-gate"... =(
East Canuck
03-12-2008, 14:24
Perhaps I've missed something, but who cares?

Kimchi, apparently.