NationStates Jolt Archive


CCs

Wilgrove
25-11-2008, 04:41
I use Close Captioning on my television since I am considered hard of hearing, and I'm just wondering if anyone else uses it. If you do, is your CC keeping up with what's going on in the show? For some reason for the past two days, it either doesn't work or is five seconds to thirty seconds behind the dialogue.

Anyone else who uses CC have this problem?
Neesika
25-11-2008, 04:51
I hate CC for tv because it's usually poorly done and behind, but I always use captions for movies when available...I started doing it so I could occasionally watch tv/movies when the kids were awake. They make so much noise that it would be silly to turn the volume up enough to overpower them, so I'd just 'read'. Then I got used to it, and I now get annoyed if there are no captions.
Sarkhaan
25-11-2008, 04:57
it's always on at the gym, and tends to lag by about 5 seconds. Spelling is horrible too.
Neesika
25-11-2008, 05:00
it's always on at the gym, and tends to lag by about 5 seconds. Spelling is horrible too.

That's because it's done by deaf people with carpal tunnel syndrome.

Also, you should post pics of you all sweaty at the gym.
Sarkhaan
25-11-2008, 05:07
That's because it's done by deaf people with carpal tunnel syndrome.

Also, you should post pics of you all sweaty at the gym.

That would explain it.

And we'll see. I usually smell pretty gross after the gym, so I can imagine sight is much better...though I usually shower before I ever look at myself.
New Manvir
25-11-2008, 06:05
only at night when everyone else is sleeping
Myrmecobius
25-11-2008, 06:17
Close Captioning is often lagging and has a lot of spelling mistakes if the show is going out live. Therefore when watching the new it is particularly bad. The use of set top box captioning is often better than television captions...
SaintB
25-11-2008, 06:22
I don't really like CC's. I read everything, and I miss the program.
AHSCA
25-11-2008, 06:24
I watch CC once in a while, I'm not hard of hearing or anything but I do sometimes like it when I can't understand a character who is rushing in their lines. It usually doesn't lag too bad but there are occasions when it's full of gaps and typos and other stuff. I used to watch them all the time when I was younger and we got a CC capable TV but now if I turn them on, I tend to read them instead of watching the show.
Klaus Devestatorie
25-11-2008, 06:25
oh... I thought this was the corn chips :(
Wilgrove
25-11-2008, 06:42
Close Captioning is often lagging and has a lot of spelling mistakes if the show is going out live. Therefore when watching the new it is particularly bad. The use of set top box captioning is often better than television captions...

What is top box captioning?
Redwulf
25-11-2008, 07:41
An interesting side effect of watching with the CC on is that sometimes you get to see lines in the captioning that were cut from the broadcast.
Tapao
25-11-2008, 10:41
subtitles, especially live, always suck. Half the time they are completely unintelligible. I'm not deaf but I used to live with a couple of people who were and I always admired their ability to stare at these lines of drivel and not hurl a brick through our tv in frustration!

Movie subtitles are usually okay but don't always differentiate between different characters lines when two people are on the screen at the same time.

Sign Zone programming is always much better - I really prefer them.
New Wallonochia
25-11-2008, 10:57
I rarely watch TV so I rarely see closed captioning. Occasionally they have it on at the chow hall, which annoys me because if I see it I have to read it (I'm weird like that) and it's usually fully of misspellings and horrible grammatical errors.

I do put subtitles on movies when I'm watching them by myself because my hearing isn't quite what it was before I joined the military. One interesting effect of subtitling is that when I set an English language movie to French audio and subtitles the audio and subtitles are often slightly different, due to different translations or screen space requirements.
Laerod
25-11-2008, 10:59
German TVs don't have close captioning. Occasionally, a show will have subtitles for the hard of hearing on TV text (which many North Americans may never have heard of).
Sudova
25-11-2008, 11:25
I use Close Captioning on my television since I am considered hard of hearing, and I'm just wondering if anyone else uses it. If you do, is your CC keeping up with what's going on in the show? For some reason for the past two days, it either doesn't work or is five seconds to thirty seconds behind the dialogue.

Anyone else who uses CC have this problem?

Mine goes a little haywire at the commercials (we use it mainly in conjunction with the "Mute" button-My wife and I live on different shifts.)
Khadgar
25-11-2008, 16:35
I watch tv with captions on all the time, 'cept news channels where the captioning runs behind. Generally any really wordy program has the captions run behind. I also use English subtitles on DVDs. Kind of irks me if they don't have 'em.
Motokata
25-11-2008, 17:29
German TVs don't have close captioning. Occasionally, a show will have subtitles for the hard of hearing on TV text (which many North Americans may never have heard of).

We have TEXT options in the CC menue but it never seems to do anything
Western Mercenary Unio
25-11-2008, 17:37
All shows that are in other languages in Finland have subtitles. Here, they are quite good.