NationStates Jolt Archive


Summer Movie Review...thus far.

Holy Paradise
11-07-2008, 23:25
Alright, first of all, a disclaimer.

I'm no professional movie critic. I'm a 16-year-old guy from Nebraska.

However, I do know what I like and what I don't like.

So, here it is, my summer movie review...thus far...

I'll do two for now, but I'll add more later.


Warning, there may be spoilers.


Ok, let's begin.

Movie: Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
Starring: Harrison Ford, Shia Labeouf, Cate Blanchett
Average Critic Rating: B to B-
Release Date: May 26, 2008

Story/Setting: C+
Okay, so, I am a big fan of the Indiana Jones series. I always liked the story of each film. I loved the story in Indy 4 as well.

That is, until the aliens came up. When I realized that the crystal skulls were alien skulls, I really was disappointed. I had hoped the skulls would have just been some part of magic or Mayan religious ritual, but, no, they had to throw aliens into the mix.

Other than that, I thought the story was very good. I liked the switch of antagonists from Nazis to Soviets. I also really liked how the gap between the Last Crusade and Crystal Skull was reflected in the film. Each setting was accurate to its timeframe, for the most part.

Characters/Acting: A+
The best part about Indy 4 was the characters/acting. Harrison Ford lived up to my expectations and delivered an excellent performance as Indiana. He still has that combination of wit and fitness that really fits Indy. Shia Labeouf surprised me. I was worried that his character, Mutt Williams, would be an annoyance, but, he did very well. Cate Blanchett did a decent job of portraying the main villain, Irina Spalko, it was kind of cliche, but it wasn't too bad.

Sound/Special Effects/Music: A-
I liked how they stuck with good old fisticuffs and pistols for Indy 4. There wasn't a lot of CGI, as I had feared. Still, I expected at least some CGI, and what CGI there was, was pleasing to the eye. Sound was spot on. And who can dislike the Indiana Jones theme song?

Overall Grade: B
I really liked Indy 4. It was an enjoyable movie, and definately worth the money. However, I don't think it was of the same caliber as the original trilogy, but it's hard to live up to those films after 19 years of nothing. So, go see Indy 4. It's not mind-blowing, but it is a fun ride.

Movie: Iron Man
Starring: Robert Downey Jr., Gwyneth Paltrow, Jeff Bridges
Average Critic Rating: A
Release Date: May 2, 2008

Story/Setting: A
The story of a time-tested comic book is usually a good one, but Iron Man did a good job of making the story applicable to current events. Still, the movie follows the basic plot of the first few issues of Iron Man. Arms dealers and terrorists serve as the antagonists, an easy group to dislike. The movie takes it one step further. The fight scenes with the terrorists were so intense that I found it very easy to hate them and took particular relish when Iron Man arrived to pummel them. The settings of each scene are very good, especially in the Middle Eastern areas. The only reason this doesn't get an A+ is because the superhero concept isn't too original.

Characters/Acting: A+
Robert Downey Jr., an actor that for a while directors would avoid like the plague, was spectacular as Tony Stark/Iron Man. Throughout the movie, Downey Jr. is constantly delivering hilarious one-liners, and his emotions are very believable. Gwyneth Paltrow also does very well, playing Pepper Potts, Stark's assistant and budding love interest. Throughout the film, her character is likeable and innocent seeming. Jeff Bridges is Obadiah Stane, the film's lead antagonist. He does very well as a bad guy, and plays the part of "corrupt business man" very nicely.

Sound/Special Effects/Music: A+
The special effects were futuristic yet realistic, especially the suit. The special effects and sound give the entire movie a feeling of not just a superhero movie, but a military thriller as well. The explosion effects are, for lack of a better word, awesome, especially when Stark test fires his multiple-burst ground-based artillery unit, Jericho.

And the music? Well, they started off the film with AC/DC's Back In Black, and, as a huge AC/DC fan, this made the film perfect for me. The entire soundtrack is based around heavy metal/classic rock, with Black Sabbath's Iron Man played in the credits. I would have been disappointed if that song had not made an appearance in the movie at any point.

Overall Grade: A+
Iron Man is easily the best superhero movie I've ever seen. The entire movie is action-packed, intense, and witty. This film is the definition of an excellent movie. Everything fit together perfectly, there were only a few extremely minor flaws. You must see this movie.

Alright, now I'm going to do WALL-E. With movies that have a much more comedic intent, they're going to have another grading section: Humor. Here it goes.

Movie: WALL-E
Starring: Ben Burtt, Elissa Knight, Jeff Garlin
Average Critic Rating: A
Release Date: June 27, 2008

Story/Setting: A+
Basically, the premise of WALL-E is this: The entire Earth has been polluted by garbage, forcing the human population to leave while "Waste Allocation Load Lifter-Earth-Class" units clean-up our mess. Unfortunately, all but one has failed. The remaining WALL-E diligently continues in his work, yet, he is very lonely. Eventually, he is interrupted by an encounter with robot named EVE, sent by the humans to search for signs of hospitabilty. Eventually, WALL-E follows EVE to the Axiom, where the humans are located.

The humans have been waiting for 700 years, and have become fat and lazy. Their captain, B. McCrea, tries to get them back, but is prevented by the ship's HAL-like computer, AUTO. Eventually, WALL-E, EVE, and Captain McCrea succeed and lead humanity back to Earth.

Again, Pixar delivers an incredibly imaginative and intriguing story, making it 9 in a row for them. I have always liked Pixar, and consider them to be the most creative studio out there. With WALL-E, they have proved themselves yet again to be creative, modern, and intelligent. Two thumbs up.

Characters/Acting: A+
WALL-E, whose voice was engineered by Ben Burtt, is one of the most lovable and innocent characters I have ever seen, including other Pixar movies. WALL-E's compassion and child-like qualities make him an incredibly easy character to love. EVE, voiced by Elissa Knight, is also a very likeable character, and is obviously influenced by modern minimalist devices such as the iPod. At first stand-offish, EVE begins to acquire some of WALL-E's compassion and sweetness as the movie progresses. Captain McCrea, voiced by Jeff Garlin, is humorous and likeable. At first a lazy oaf, McCrea soon becomes determined and energetic. Props to Pixar for its loveable characters.

Humor: A+
Pixar has established a tradition of making movies that are humorous for both children and adults. WALL-E is no exception. Immediately, the social satire begins when we see that the entire plant is dominated by "Buy 'n Large" a Wal-Mart-esque mega-conglomerate that runs and owns everything. Also, Earth has been rendered pretty much inhabitable by trash and pollution, so it has a sort of dark humor to it. Obesity is also looked at in a funny way. Although many conservatives have attacked WALL-E for these satires, as a religious, capitalist conservative myself, I thought that the satire was funny, appropriate, and accurate. The message that we shouldn't pollute our planet with trash is a perfectly good one, and should be heeded.

But before I get into politics, I'm going to switch to the children's humor. WALL-E is the main provider of laughs for the kiddies, with his child-like innocence and curiosity. For example, when he finds a brassiere, WALL-E immediately puts it on his eyes, unsure of what its purpose is. WALL-E thankfully does not rely on dumb bathroom jokes and other such crude humor like many family films. The jokes are refined yet still very witty. The film is very rich with humor.

Sound/Special Effects/Music: A+
Pixar is synonymous with top-of-the-line computer animation and sound. They are one of the few animation studios that can animate humans without making them creepy. Every single detail of the film seems to have a lot of care and love put into it, from the dirt and rust on WALL-E's body to the sleek, futuristic, technologically advanced look of the human residency ship, the Axiom. Everything is very smooth, very detailed, and very well made.

Overall Grade: A+
WALL-E is probably the best film of the year. I gave Iron Man my vote for favorite film of the summer, but they are two different genres, so I couldn't really compare the two. I love WALL-E. It is an excellent film for all ages and all backgrounds. You must see WALL-E in theaters, then buy it on DVD. It is a classic, and will be treasured by everyone in your family.

Movie: Hancock
Starring: Will Smith, Jason Bateman, Charlize Theron
Average Critic Rating: C to C-
Release Date: July 2, 2008

Story/Setting: First Half: A+/Second Half: C
The movie starts off great: Hancock is a bum, a loser, with superhero abilities. It's imaginative, witty, and smart. The plot is amazing for the first hour or so.
Then, Hancock gets in a fight with his ex-wife/current wife/???. And the movie's story becomes the standard superhero plot from there on. It's not that the story is horrendous at that point, it's just that, after the first half of creativity and wit, it is really disappointing when the plot reverts to cliche stuff.

Characters/Acting: A-
Will Smith is one of my favorite actors, and he does very well in the role of John Hancock, a bum/superhero. He is humorous and mysterious at the same time. His performance really brightened up the movie. Jason Bateman does a good job as Ray Embray, a good-natured peace advocate that helps to improve Hancock's public image. Charlize Theron delivers a good job as Mary Embray (or Mary Hancock, depending on how you see it.) However, her character hurt the plot, so that's where the A- comes from.

Humor: A+
The movie is very funny, with a lot of satire and one-liners to keep me laughing, along with a few very funny visual gags. The part where Hancock actually shoves one of his attackers' heads into another attacker's ass, was hysterical. Will Smith continues to deliver well-placed humor, and in some cases, the cussing actually helped make the movie more humorous.

Sound/Special Effects/Music: A
The sound and music is pretty good, and the special effects are pretty good overall.

Overall Grade: B+
Hancock is an enjoyable movie, one I would recommend you see. However, it fails to achieve the caliber of Iron Man and Wall-E due to a strange plot twist and lack of direction in the second half of the movie.
Yootopia
11-07-2008, 23:30
Sorry, but no. Indy 4 was not a 'B'. It pissed all over the previous titles by involving aliens. That's just not Indy in the slightest- also Harrison Ford wasn't a very convincing action hero.

"Aiee, communists, what should we do?"
"Well I'm going to take a nap, you think of something"

*edits*

And Hancock was better than Iron Man, despite the odd completely pointless and/or irritating segment, see the fight between Hancock and his ex-wife, which I'm absolutely bewildered as to the reason for.
Holy Paradise
11-07-2008, 23:31
I mentioned that in my review.

Yes, I thought the aliens did really hurt the movie, but I'm not going to allow one major flaw to completely ruin the movie.

I'm planning on seeing Hancock tonight. I've heard a lot of good things about it.
Yootopia
11-07-2008, 23:33
I mentioned that in my review.

Yes, I thought the aliens did really hurt the movie, but I'm not going to allow one major flaw to completely ruin the movie.
As flaws go, it was very major indeed.
Yootopia
11-07-2008, 23:34
I'm planning on seeing Hancock tonight. I've heard a lot of good things about it.
It's pretty damned fine, especially in comparison to the utter pish that's been out lately. Although Teeth was quite good, in a kind of 'oh Jesus Christ, NO!' kind of way.
Holy Paradise
11-07-2008, 23:35
As flaws go, it was very major indeed.

However, I didn't see much else that really hurt the movie. That's why I gave it a B.

If it weren't for the aliens, it would have been a good A-.
JuNii
11-07-2008, 23:35
may I suggest a spoiler tag? use and the usual end tag to block out the spoilers.

like this.

[spoiler] spoilers here
Holy Paradise
11-07-2008, 23:35
It's pretty damned fine, especially in comparison to the utter pish that's been out lately. Although Teeth was quite good, in a kind of 'oh Jesus Christ, NO!' kind of way.

Have you seen WALL-E? I thought it was very enjoyable.
Sirmomo1
12-07-2008, 03:30
I thought Hancock was pretty sweet for the first hour or so. Then when the whole wife thing came up it just gave up and fell limply to the floor.

I thought Indiana Jones was a complete let down. I might not have been as much of a fan of the others as most people but you could actually sense the disappointment of everyone in the movie theatre.

Iron Man delivered what you'd ask of it but I always find it hard to get completely behind a film which doesn't really come up with enough in the way of brains or heart.

And I still can't believe I went to see The Love Guru.

But just in case anyone is starting to believe that I just don't like movies, I thought WALL-E was great.
Megaloria
12-07-2008, 03:43
Wall-E was the first movie in a long time that felt truly complete to me. It's my favourite of the Summer, likely the year, and possibly the last decade.
Ashmoria
12-07-2008, 03:45
I thought Hancock was pretty sweet for the first hour or so. Then when the whole wife thing came up it just gave up and fell limply to the floor.

I thought Indiana Jones was a complete let down. I might not have been as much of a fan of the others as most people but you could actually sense the disappointment of everyone in the movie theatre.

Iron Man delivered what you'd ask of it but I always find it hard to get completely behind a film which doesn't really come up with enough in the way of brains or heart.

And I still can't believe I went to see The Love Guru.

But just in case anyone is starting to believe that I just don't like movies, I thought WALL-E was great.


WHY did you go see the love guru? it seemed pretty awful from the trailer alone.


i havent seen many movies this summer. my fav so far is the one i saw today HELLBOY 2. i didnt see the original but i very much enjoyed the inventiveness of the story.
Conserative Morality
12-07-2008, 03:46
WHY did you go see the love guru? it seemed pretty awful from the trailer alone.


i havent seen many movies this summer. my fav so far is the one i saw today HELLBOY 2. i didnt see the original but i very much enjoyed the inventiveness of the story.

I saw the original last night. If it's anything like the first one, It's gonna be great!
Ashmoria
12-07-2008, 03:49
I saw the original last night. If it's anything like the first one, It's gonna be great!

i dunno, i didnt see the first one. but i did put it on my netflix list when i got home.
Sirmomo1
12-07-2008, 03:50
WHY did you go see the love guru? it seemed pretty awful from the trailer alone.


I go and see most movies - I'm one of ten sadists who went to see the Hottie and the Nottie. I really should have tried to make an exception for this one though.
Conserative Morality
12-07-2008, 03:51
i dunno, i didnt see the first one. but i did put it on my netflix list when i got home.

It's good. Lots of action, and a surprising lack of gore (Good thing IMO). Good actors, good story, good special effects... The list goes on and on.
Ashmoria
12-07-2008, 03:52
I go and see most movies - I'm one of ten sadists who went to see the Hottie and the Nottie. I really should have tried to make an exception for this one though.

ohyoupoorthing.

id go to more if it didnt involve a 90-150 mile round trip. i have to be a bit more selective.

can you write it off on your taxes as research?
The ripper valance
12-07-2008, 05:06
Sorry, but no. Indy 4 was not a 'B'. It pissed all over the previous titles by involving aliens.

really? is it any more far fetched than the ark of the covanent killing a group of nazies? or a priest that can rip your heart out while keeping you alive? or a 700 year old knight that gaurds the cup of christ? Indy 4 is way better then temple of doom ever was.
Markreich
12-07-2008, 05:14
Where's the love for Get Smart?
**MUCH** better movie than I'd dared hoped.
Conserative Morality
12-07-2008, 05:15
Where's the love for Get Smart?
**MUCH** better movie than I'd dared hoped.

Missed it by THAT much!
Anti-Social Darwinism
12-07-2008, 06:04
Did anyone see Wanted?

It was pretty violent, certainly not something for under 13. But, while it was only vaguely related to the comic book, the movie could stand on it's own.

I'm not a huge Angelina Jolie fan, but she was pretty decent in this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4pWuFv48Zk
Bullitt Point
12-07-2008, 07:17
Wall-E was the first movie in a long time that felt truly complete to me. It's my favourite of the Summer, likely the year, and possibly the last decade.

For being geared towards the kiddies, I thought Wall-E was one of the best movies for a while. The plot didn't seem rushed or forced, there wasn't too much kiddie-crap-wub scenes, there was humor aplenty, and a few good references for those of the adult age.

But, y'know, this is Pixar we're talking about. They just crank out these movies a couple of years at a time and they end up being brilliant.

After watching Wall-E, I went and sat in the last 30 minutes of Wanted and, I must say, I made the right choice. :D
I V Stalin
12-07-2008, 12:24
Did anyone see Wanted?

It was pretty violent, certainly not something for under 13. But, while it was only vaguely related to the comic book, the movie could stand on it's own.

I'm not a huge Angelina Jolie fan, but she was pretty decent in this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4pWuFv48Zk
It was ridiculous, unsubtle and crap. And also quite enjoyable, in a totally braindead way.
Melphi
12-07-2008, 14:25
It was ridiculous, unsubtle and crap. And also quite enjoyable, in a totally braindead way.

I wonder when mythbusters will try to recreate the stunts...
Katganistan
12-07-2008, 14:32
I've seen Iron Man, Wall-E, Indiana Jones and Hellboy II so far.

Iron Man was the best of the lot. I was going in thinking, "Oh boy, this is going to suck," because I've read so many comics with Iron Man in them and thought they'd never do it justice.

I was completely wrong. If you haven't seen it, SEE IT.
***

Wall-E was great, honestly. There's a lot more there than a kiddie movie, and yet it isn't too preachy either. It's a visual feast. Go, you won't be disappointed.
***

"It's not the years, it's the mileage." This was never so true as with Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skulls. He's older and tired. They tried to tie up too many "loose ends" that needed no tying. Aliens?! a son? Please.

They should have left it at Last Crusade -- and I really, really WANTED to like this movie, being a HUGE fan of Jones.
***

Hellboy II - not on your list. Saw it last night and it was a visual stunner, and an entertaining adventure and fight-fest. If you're into analyzing the fairy tales and myths behind the story you might be less enchanted with it, and I thought the gag at the very end was a bit silly. Still, a great movie.
Yootopia
12-07-2008, 14:53
really? is it any more far fetched than the ark of the covanent killing a group of nazies? or a priest that can rip your heart out while keeping you alive? or a 700 year old knight that gaurds the cup of christ?
Yes. *nods*
Indy 4 is way better then temple of doom ever was.
Eh no.
Chandelier
12-07-2008, 15:35
I've seen Indiana Jones, Wall-E, and Get Smart so far. Wall-E was my favorite of the three. I really liked Wall-E.

Today I'm going to see Kung Fu Panda with my family.
Yootopia
12-07-2008, 16:50
I've seen Indiana Jones, Wall-E, and Get Smart so far. Wall-E was my favorite of the three. I really liked Wall-E.

Today I'm going to see Kung Fu Panda with my family.
Heh, you're back. Hullo etc.
Anti-Social Darwinism
12-07-2008, 16:56
It was ridiculous, unsubtle and crap. And also quite enjoyable, in a totally braindead way.

Yes, and I was being totally, unashamedly braindead that day. I did leave the theater wondering if it were intended as parody.
Cookiton
12-07-2008, 17:52
Indiana Jones was a great movie! I think it was great and the movie of the Summer
[NS]Rolling squid
12-07-2008, 18:20
Iron man was a great movie, probably the best superhero movie so far. Indy? well, not so great. A decent movie in its own regard, but no where near the same level of the first three.
JuNii
12-07-2008, 18:24
Where's the love for Get Smart?
**MUCH** better movie than I'd dared hoped.

Don't go to movies in the theatres... too expensive.

but this DVD (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1018723/) came out and it was pretty good.
Holy Paradise
12-07-2008, 19:22
Yeah, I should have added more movies to the poll.

One movie I wouldn't add is Meet Dave. I'm sorry, but that just looks like crap.
Anti-Social Darwinism
12-07-2008, 19:54
I've seen Iron Man, Wall-E, Indiana Jones and Hellboy II so far.

Iron Man was the best of the lot. I was going in thinking, "Oh boy, this is going to suck," because I've read so many comics with Iron Man in them and thought they'd never do it justice.

I was completely wrong. If you haven't seen it, SEE IT.
***

Wall-E was great, honestly. There's a lot more there than a kiddie movie, and yet it isn't too preachy either. It's a visual feast. Go, you won't be disappointed.
***

"It's not the years, it's the mileage." This was never so true as with Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skulls. He's older and tired. They tried to tie up too many "loose ends" that needed no tying. Aliens?! a son? Please.

They should have left it at Last Crusade -- and I really, really WANTED to like this movie, being a HUGE fan of Jones.
***

Hellboy II - not on your list. Saw it last night and it was a visual stunner, and an entertaining adventure and fight-fest. If you're into analyzing the fairy tales and myths behind the story you might be less enchanted with it, and I thought the gag at the very end was a bit silly. Still, a great movie.

I really kinda liked the Indy movie. The only thing I really objected to was the implication that Shia LaBoef was going to be groomed as the second generation Indy. An Indy for the '50s and '60s? Really, just too much.
Motokata
12-07-2008, 20:10
I loved Iron Man and Indy 4. I'm thinking WallE will be good, I'm seeing it next week. The only thing that really bothered me about Indy4 was the ants. [spoiler]when the ants cralwing into the soviet soldier's mouth was really exesive, I would have just rather them do a pull away and show the reaction[/spolier]
Holy Paradise
12-07-2008, 23:54
I've added another movie to the review list: WALL-E.
Sirmomo1
13-07-2008, 12:56
ohyoupoorthing.

id go to more if it didnt involve a 90-150 mile round trip. i have to be a bit more selective.

You live here (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hundred_mile_wilderness)? Move into civilisation already!

can you write it off on your taxes as research?

Unfortunately not. It can be an expensive habit.
Katganistan
13-07-2008, 21:33
I loved Iron Man and Indy 4. I'm thinking WallE will be good, I'm seeing it next week. The only thing that really bothered me about Indy4 was the ants. [spoiler]when the ants cralwing into the soviet soldier's mouth was really exesive, I would have just rather them do a pull away and show the reaction[/spolier]

Er...

the ants, believe it or not, were actually based on something real.... driver ants.
Cannot think of a name
13-07-2008, 21:37
Er...

the ants, believe it or not, were actually based on something real.... driver ants.

I don't think believability was his objection.
Ashmoria
13-07-2008, 21:39
You live here (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hundred_mile_wilderness)? Move into civilisation already!



Unfortunately not. It can be an expensive habit.

noooo i live in the middle rio grande valley. there is a movie theater in town that shows one movie at a time. if i want to see something other than wall-e this week (and i did) i have to go either 50 miles up the highway to see hellboy2 (which i did) or 75 miles (all the way to albuquerque) to see mongol (which im hoping to see on monday)
Neu Leonstein
14-07-2008, 01:14
One vote for "Mongol". The only movie I've watched this season, but so worth it.
Holy Paradise
14-07-2008, 03:07
Review for Hancock has been added.
Dinaverg
14-07-2008, 03:22
I really kinda liked the Indy movie. The only thing I really objected to was the implication that Shia LaBoef was going to be groomed as the second generation Indy. An Indy for the '50s and '60s? Really, just too much.

I think the fact he took the hat back before Shia put it on was a direct denial of that implication.

All these grips people have with aliens, the only thing that actually bothered me when I saw it was the magnetism bit in the beginning. That actually made my brain hurt, but I got over it pretty quickly.
Barringtonia
14-07-2008, 04:52
By the time Indy escaped a nuclear bomb by climbing into a refrigerator and being blown half a mile away with nary a scratch, my belief had not only been suspended, it had also been hung, drawn and quartered.
Delator
14-07-2008, 07:20
I'll just throw some ratings out there, since I don't feel like going into lots of details.

Iron Man: 9.5/10
Hellboy 2: 8/10
The Incredible Hulk: 7.5/10
Indiana Jones: 6.5/10

I'd recommend any of them except Indy...wait for DVD for that one.

Hellboy II - not on your list. Saw it last night and it was a visual stunner, and an entertaining adventure and fight-fest. If you're into analyzing the fairy tales and myths behind the story you might be less enchanted with it, and I thought the gag at the very end was a bit silly. Still, a great movie.

Wait...which gag??
Katganistan
14-07-2008, 07:34
Wait...which gag??

One was world-changing, so TWO must be better.
Remote Guppies
14-07-2008, 14:33
Have you seen WALL-E? I thought it was very enjoyable.

Yes, I have.

HEIL WALL-E! WALL-E IS THE FUCKIN' K1NG!
Chandelier
19-07-2008, 01:10
I saw Journey to the Center of the Earth today. It was pretty good.
3D and all.

Mom is having us all see Mamma Mia tomorrow, I'll see how that goes.

Heh, you're back. Hullo etc.

Oh, hi! Didn't know anyone knew I was gone...http://generalitemafia.ipbfree.com/html/emoticons/smile.gif (using a different smile because the new one looks creepy to me...)