NationStates Jolt Archive


Ni-Vanuatu reject capitalism and consumerism

Ariddia
12-12-2007, 12:39
Content islanders reject capitalism for traditional trade

As much of the world embarks on a frenzy of Christmas consumerism, Vanuatu is stubbornly heading in the opposite direction.

It is spurning the cash economy and instead reviving ancient currencies such as pigs, pig tusks, woven grass mats and sea shells.

The Government of Prime Minister Ham Lini declared 2007 the Year of the Traditional Economy and has now extended the campaign into next year.

The initiative has been fuelled by fears that the harsh imperatives of capitalism could destroy Vanuatu's traditional way of life, based on subsistence farming and complicated cultural exchanges.

There is grave concern that the emphasis on acquiring material wealth will lure islanders to shanty towns on the outskirts of the capital, Port Vila, where most will encounter unemployment, poverty and frustration. In rural areas, by contrast, hunger and homelessness are unheard of.

"The mantra of the World Bank and similar organisations is to make as much cash as you can, as fast as you can," said Ralph Regenvanu, an anthropologist from the Vanuatu Cultural Centre and a driving force behind the campaign. "The traditional economy has served us well for thousands of years. We're trying to preserve our cultural heritage in the face of development."

As part of the renaissance, schools and clinics are allowing villagers to pay fees with vegetables and kava roots.

[...] With the help of Unesco, authorities are setting up banks for traditional forms of wealth such as pig tusks and shell necklaces, and studying ways of setting informal exchange rates with the national currency, the vatu.

[...] Nearly 80 per cent of Vanuatu's 210,000 people are farmers, growing their own food in rich soils blessed with high rainfall and plentiful sunshine.

"It easy to grow taro, sweet potato, banana and manioc," said Toren Bong, a community leader on the island of Ambrym, where lush rainforest sweeps down from the bare ash plains of two live volcanoes. "We use sling shots or bows and arrows to shoot flying foxes [fruit bats] and in the forest we hunt wild pigs and wild cattle."


The reliance on a modest but healthy subsistence diet was one reason why Vanuatu was nominated the world's happiest country in a 2006 Happy Planet Index, compiled by the New Economics Foundation.

[...] Said Regenvanu: "We need to recognise that the traditional economy is the reason why we were voted the world's happiest country."


(link (http://www.nzherald.co.nz/category/story.cfm?c_id=34&objectid=10481808))
Nipeng
12-12-2007, 12:48
In their conditions the technical civilization has little to offer them besides the modern medicine. As long as they can afford it, more power to them.
Oh, and sometimes emergency services, like helicopter to save some fisher or urgently bring an ill child to hospital.
Anything else?
Ariddia
12-12-2007, 13:06
Since they have clinics, I assume the clinics can phone Port Vila or one of the other "modern" towns if there's an emergency.
Rambhutan
12-12-2007, 13:14
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?
Ariddia
12-12-2007, 13:22
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?

Come to think of it, no. :D
Nipeng
12-12-2007, 13:24
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?
A dead pig on a rope might work.
Isisopolis
12-12-2007, 14:04
This is brilliant! Wish all banks accepted traditional forms of wealth! Presumably no strong room but a very large 'fridge.
Vittos the City Sacker
12-12-2007, 14:30
Good for them.

Although, ending relations with the World Bank and government allowance of traditional moneys would be a capitalist's way of doing things, but the misunderstanding and slandering of concepts is perfectly fine if those doing so are actually getting it right.

That is assuming they are getting it right, and this is not some "us vs. the world" nationalism inducer that really just serves the political hierarchy.
This might be a puppet
12-12-2007, 14:30
In their conditions the technical civilization has little to offer them besides the modern medicine. As long as they can afford it, more power to them.
Oh, and sometimes emergency services, like helicopter to save some fisher or urgently bring an ill child to hospital.
Anything else?
Internet access, of course, so that they too can play Nationstates... ;)
Lunatic Goofballs
12-12-2007, 15:03
They also reject pants. *nod*
Imperio Mexicano
12-12-2007, 15:43
They also reject pants. *nod*

Do you? ;)

*runs*
Umdogsland
12-12-2007, 16:02
Good on them! Hopefully, they'll take it further and more countries will join them.
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?But why get anything from a vending machine when you can get from a field or forest properly?
Trollgaard
12-12-2007, 16:17
Awesome.
Ariddia
12-12-2007, 19:29
That is assuming they are getting it right, and this is not some "us vs. the world" nationalism inducer that really just serves the political hierarchy.

Rural ni-Vanuatu tend to reject nationalism and national politicians, and be focused on local group membership. So I think it's safe to say your fears on that account can be laid to rest.
Llewdor
12-12-2007, 19:32
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?
No, but my experience cutting the tusks off a boar leads me to believe it wouldn't have much trouble getting whatever it wanted out of that machine.
Neu Leonstein
12-12-2007, 23:39
Hope that works out for them. But they better not start preventing youngsters who want to see the city from doing so.

Still, they might want to plan ahead regarding the market prices for pork in, say, 20 years time. They might have to move by then, what with their island potentially disappearing and all. Let's hope they don't have to run to the World Bank for help, it would be rather harsh for them to find out what "making cash" actually means this way.
Yootopia
12-12-2007, 23:43
... Awesome, or something. Why is this important?
Ariddia
12-12-2007, 23:58
Hope that works out for them. But they better not start preventing youngsters who want to see the city from doing so.

Freedom of movement is legally established in Vanuatu. Well, within certain limits. You can't go and settle in a rural village without the consent of the people living there. But you can move to town.


Still, they might want to plan ahead regarding the market prices for pork in, say, 20 years time.

Market prices for pork? I don't think you quite understand how pigs as "currency" works in rural Vanuatu.


They might have to move by then, what with their island potentially disappearing and all.

Vanuatu is not just one island. It's a lot of different Melanesian islands. You should know; it's one of Australia's closest neighbours. Climate change will undoubtedly cause some problems, but the islands are comparatively big, with mountains and volcanoes; we're not talking about the low-lying atolls you find in Tuvalu, Tokelau and Kiribati.

... Awesome, or something. Why is this important?

Define "important".
Neu Leonstein
13-12-2007, 00:03
Market prices for pork? I don't think you quite understand how pigs as "currency" works in rural Vanuatu.
I've seen documentaries, but my point was that they might need various sorts of equipment to help them deal with the future from the outside. So unless they'll go and beg, they're gonna need something to pay for their purchases with.

Pigs seem to be a popular commodity around there, so pork might be an export article they could be looking at.

As for where the place is...I came here long after geography was a topic in class, so I never bothered spending time on it. They're all rather ineffectual as countries and unattractive (to me) as tourist destinations. And besides, they wouldn't want me there anyways, from how you portray them.
Ariddia
13-12-2007, 00:22
I've seen documentaries, but my point was that they might need various sorts of equipment to help them deal with the future from the outside. So unless they'll go and beg, they're gonna need something to pay for their purchases with.

Pigs seem to be a popular commodity around there, so pork might be an export article they could be looking at.

True, although that would require radical rethinking of economic traditions, which would go in the opposite direction to current trends encouraged by PM Lini.

Having said that, I assume the national government would provide assistance in times of crisis, to the best of its abilities. Vanuatu's economy is doing rather well right now.


As for where the place is...I came here long after geography was a topic in class, so I never bothered spending time on it. They're all rather ineffectual as countries and unattractive (to me) as tourist destinations. And besides, they wouldn't want me there anyways, from how you portray them.

They're not xenophobic, you know. There's tourism in Vanuatu. At a guess, I'd say that a significant proportion of the tourists who visit Vanuatu are Australian.
Egg and chips
13-12-2007, 01:37
Have you ever tried using a pig to get something out of a vending machine?

I once put a bacon flavoured crisp in a vending machine to see what would happen (hey, I was drunk!) Does that count?
Kyronea
13-12-2007, 02:01
I once put a bacon flavoured crisp in a vending machine to see what would happen (hey, I was drunk!) Does that count?
What happened?
Whereyouthinkyougoing
13-12-2007, 02:05
(link (http://www.nzherald.co.nz/category/story.cfm?c_id=34&objectid=10481808))

Brilliant.
Sel Appa
13-12-2007, 02:09
I don't see what could be so bad. They should be admired for recognizing the connection between capitalism and poverty.