NationStates Jolt Archive

Having just eaten some leftover pumpkin pie, I felt compelled to make a poll: What is your favorite kind of pie?

Pumpkin at Thanksgiving, of course.

In summertime, apple and blueberry. Sometimes pecan.

Luckily for you, all four are included in the poll. ;)

Pumpkin at Thanksgiving, of course.

In summertime, apple and blueberry. Sometimes pecan.

Not a bad list, and you remembered key lime. :p

Just barely. I was having troubling thinking of a ninth pie, and had to look at the list on Wikipedia's "Pie" article. :D

Luckily for you, all four are included in the poll. ;)

Not a bad list, and you remembered key lime. :p

Just barely. I was having troubling thinking of a ninth pie, and had to look at the list on Wikipedia's "Pie" article. :D

Ah, but you still voted "other." :p So... what's your favorite pie then?

Mint cream pie. Basically it's Oreo crust, lots of Cream de mint mixed in with marshmallow, and a mint on top. Anything less is for failures.

Lemon meringue.

With pumpkin a close second

3.14159 26535 89793 23846 26433 83279 50288 41971 69399 37510

Krispy-Kreme chocolate-covered Boton-Kreme

I think I just died and went to heaven

Ah, but you still voted "other." :p So... what's your favorite pie then?

Don't have one. ;)

3.14159 26535 89793 23846 26433 83279 50288 41971 69399 37510

Awww, posted it before I could. :(

Awww, posted it before I could. :(

Phear my Ninja skillz.

Having just eaten some leftover pumpkin pie, I felt compelled to make a poll: What is your favorite kind of pie?
whats pie?

whats pie?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi

Pizza pie is my favorite pie, although it is technically no longer regarded as pie.

That's what's called pierony.

Minced meat pie. :D

Mmm pie...

I voted key lime, but also love strawberry rhubarb :fluffle:
And now, something old school (http://www.weebl.jolt.co.uk/pie.htm)

Cottage Pie.

For throwing or eating?

For throwing: Blueberry(wonderfully staining)

For eating: Key Lime(Too yummy to throw)

For throwing OR eating: Chocolate cream(Wonderful throwing pie and yummy enough to regret when it's gone. :( )

Cottage Pie.

Even better. Dear lord do I love the taste of creamed potato and minced meat...

So, does "pie" in American English only refer to sweet/dessert pies? What do you call savoury pies?

So, does "pie" in American English only refer to sweet/desert pies? What do you call savoury pies?

gross.

Some people call them casseroles but they are not, they are more like crap.

*pukes at the mere thought of shepherds pie*

So, does "pie" in American English only refer to sweet/desert pies? What do you call savoury pies?

Pot Pies.

Pot Pies is actually a specific kind of savory pie that consists of meat(turkey, chicken or beef), in a thick stew-like gravy with vegetables either inside or topped with a pie crust. There are a few variants, but the name 'pot pie' has been stuck to them even though they're not technically pot pies.

In the U.S.A., 'Pie' refers to dessert pies. Except maybe in New York where it can also mean pizza. :p

i don't go in for sweet pies. i like chicken and gravy the best

gross.

Some people call them casseroles but they are not, they are more like crap.

*pukes at the mere thought of shepherds pie*

first of all shepherds pie is delicious, as is cumberland pie (its variant)... and secondly neither of them are actually pies. as in they don't have crust or a pie top


"Pot Pies" FTW!

Steak and ale pie < 3

Having just eaten some leftover pumpkin pie, I felt compelled to make a poll: What is your favorite kind of pie?

I do not eat any kind of pie.

Steak and ale pie < 3

QFT

*pukes at the mere thought of shepherds pie*

I don't understand what people find disgusting about it.

Any particular reasons?

I've never tried any kind of pie other than apple...so apple

Pumpkin is my favorite, followed by key lime.

Pie is disgusting.

I love blueberry pie. If I can't get it, I'll take either pecan or apple.

I am on the quest for the perfect key lime pie. I haven't found it yet. I suspect my quest will carry me beyond the borders of North Dakota. Anyone know where I can get decent key lime pie?

I don't understand what people find disgusting about it.

Any particular reasons?

my particular reason is that I don't mix my food. I eat one thing at a time all the way and then another. If my corn touches my mashed potatoes, I don't eat the piece of corn or the small bit of mashed potatoes that has been contaminated.

dishes that mix things.....well, I don't eat most of them. Lasagna is okay, some soups are okay,and I will eat chili on occasion but mostly I am disgusted by the "lets put everything in a bowl and call it food" thing.

I am on the quest for the perfect key lime pie. I haven't found it yet. I suspect my quest will carry me beyond the borders of North Dakota. Anyone know where I can get decent key lime pie?

Try the gulf coast of Florida. There was a restaurant there that had the best key lime pie I ever had(can't remember the name of the restaurant). It is so good, I got the recipe and I use it to make my own. :)

my particular reason is that I don't mix my food. I eat one thing at a time all the way and then another. If my corn touches my mashed potatoes, I don't eat the piece of corn or the small bit of mashed potatoes that has been contaminated.

dishes that mix things.....well, I don't eat most of them. Lasagna is okay, some soups are okay,and I will eat chili on occasion but mostly I am disgusted by the "lets put everything in a bowl and call it food" thing.

You know I love you, Smunkee. But you are out of your mind. :)

You know I love you, Smunkee. But you are out of your mind. :)

so I have been told. If you think, the sane people really aren't having any fun... so maybe out of my mind is a good place to be. :D

I voted for the Lemon meringue, and would have done anyway, but I'm surprised there's a lack of
a) the more savory option. Cottage pie, anyone?
b) mince pies.

Pecan, I like Rhubarb pie too.

BLUEBERRY!!! A little messy, but is so tasty it more then makes up for the gooey stuff all over my keyboard.(looks at keyboard)I really gotta stop eating at the computer.

Try the gulf coast of Florida. There was a restaurant there that had the best key lime pie I ever had(can't remember the name of the restaurant). It is so good, I got the recipe and I use it to make my own. :)

Thanks, LG. If I ever escape North Dakota and find myself on the Gulf coast of Florida, I will look up restaurants with key lime pie. :)

Having spent a large portion of my childhood in the South, I can say with certainty that pecan pie is the best.

so I have been told. If you think, the sane people really aren't having any fun... so maybe out of my mind is a good place to be. :D

I'm enjoying it. :)

Thanks, LG. If I ever escape North Dakota and find myself on the Gulf coast of Florida, I will look up restaurants with key lime pie. :)

Or I could give you mine.

my particular reason is that I don't mix my food. I eat one thing at a time all the way and then another. If my corn touches my mashed potatoes, I don't eat the piece of corn or the small bit of mashed potatoes that has been contaminated.

dishes that mix things.....well, I don't eat most of them. Lasagna is okay, some soups are okay,and I will eat chili on occasion but mostly I am disgusted by the "lets put everything in a bowl and call it food" thing.

i'd say mixing things is where you get the best flavours from. but then i'm the total opposite, especially with things like roast chicken/turkey. i have to have on my fork a bit of chicken, a bit of stuffing, a bit of potato, some peas/sweetcorn, and some gravy... if i don't have all that mix of stuff on my fork then its just somehow not good. i can't explain it :P

Pumpkin and blackberry/rasberry/boysenberry

All are delicious.

hair

Long Live Pumpkin Pie!!!

Meat pie.

my favorite kind of pie is Pi, which goes a little bit like this:

3.14159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510 to 50 decimal places.

It's hard to eat though, because it is irrational.

Pecan, with pumpkin in second place.

Or I could give you mine.

Haha. Requesting your recipe would require me to show some intelligence. If you feel inclined, tg me. Thanks!

I've become exceedingly fond of the oriental variety lately.

As the old saying goes, they love you long time.

Having just eaten some leftover pumpkin pie, I felt compelled to make a poll: What is your favorite kind of pie?

Straw. Berry. Rhubarb. Anything else is but a shadow of this good stuff. How can you not like pink celery? :D

I am guessing only 9 Americans voted in this poll.
Because that is the extent of the apple pie fanbase/patriotism cult.

Rhubarb pie > all.

I voted other, mine is strawberry

There is not one on there that I do not like

Apple is up there but so is pumpkin... and bakers square has this seasonal pumpkin pecan pie that is delicious