NationStates Jolt Archive

Which of these two "Murrays" - Rothbard (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Rothbard) or Bookchin (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Bookchin) - has views closest to your own?

We can settle this.... in Thunderdome! :D

We can settle this.... in Thunderdome! :D

lol

Which do you agree with more, though? Rothbard (anarcho-capitalist) or Bookchin (anarcho-communist)? Or do you disagree with both equally?

Ugh. Neither, thank you.

Ugh. Neither, thank you.

But is there one you disagree with even slightly less than the other? :p

We can settle this.... in Thunderdome! :D

Aunty Entity: Remember where you are - this is Thunderdome, and death is listening, and will take the first man that gets hit by a pie, a mud pie!.

That's an exact quote.

Bookchin.

*glances at your sig*

Why am I not surprised? :p

Bookchin.

Hmm... If I had to rate them, I would probably kick Rothbard in the groin three times and kick Bookchin in the groin twice.

Interpret that as you will. *nod*

Aunty Entity: Remember where you are - this is Thunderdome, and death is listening, and will take the first man that gets hit by a pie, a mud pie!.

That's an exact quote.

From the difficult to find 'Goofball Cut'. *nod*

Not a huge fan of Rothbeard, but that Bookchin fellow is just plain insane. I mean, caring for the environment is all nice and stuff, but "social econology" is just ruining it. It's like when you tell a double entendre and then someone ruins it by spelling out the joke.

Hmm... If I had to rate them, I would probably kick Rothbard in the groin three times and kick Bookchin in the groin twice.

Interpret that as you will. *nod*

You hate Bookchin slightly less?

You hate Bookchin slightly less?
LG would never admit it, but out there in real life he's got a family of goofballs to care for and has to pretend being sensible sometimes. :p

Andy Murray because hes going to win Wimbledon :p

LG would never admit it, but out there in real life he's got a family of goofballs to care for and has to pretend being sensible sometimes. :p

:eek:

Lies! I merely act sensible sometimes to keep you all off your guard. :)

LG simply thinks Bookchin is a sillier name than Rothbard, and would therefore kick him less - it's got nothing to do with politics and everything to do with silly names.

Bookchin...honestly :confused:

That one that doesn't like groundhogs or gophers.

LG simply thinks Bookchin is a sillier name than Rothbard, and would therefore kick him less - it's got nothing to do with politics and everything to do with silly names.

Bookchin...honestly :confused:

:)

Rothbard, by a mile.

I cannot, for the life of me, figure out what makes Bookchin important. An ecological anarchist, the two don't belong.

Reading Rothbard generally tends to make me sick... so Bookchin.

Reading Rothbard generally tends to make me sick... so Bookchin.

I would like to know what strikes you as sickening.

lol

Which do you agree with more, though? Rothbard (anarcho-capitalist) or Bookchin (anarcho-communist)? Or do you disagree with both equally?

Well considering I am a state guy I think I would choose neither...

I would like to know what strikes you as sickening.

Specifics don't come to mind. Just a general impression.

Rothbard, by a mile.

Seconded.