NationStates Jolt Archive


New York City Bans Metal Bats

IDF
14-03-2007, 15:26
http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=ap-jimlitke-031307&prov=ap&type=lgns

I love this. As a true fan of baseball, I hate the ping made when an aluminum bat strikes the ball. I need to hear the crack of a bat that can only come from a Louisville Slugger. I wish the NCAA would follow suit here.
Drunk commies deleted
14-03-2007, 15:30
Can you still use metal bats to straighten out people who accidentally broke into the wrong car?
Smunkeeville
14-03-2007, 15:32
I hate metal bats as well.....this makes me happy. :)
Jerusalem Light
14-03-2007, 15:34
Finally. That metal Batman has caused enough damage.
Ban betal Bats!
Ifreann
14-03-2007, 15:45
If everybody hates these metal bats then why do any of the players actually use them?
Eve Online
14-03-2007, 15:46
If everybody hates these metal bats then why do any of the players actually use them?

Because you usually hit further with an aluminum bat.
Lunatic Goofballs
14-03-2007, 16:33
"Yes, I know the statistics say I'm wrong. So they must be unreliable. What? No, I don't have any other statistics. What? No, I don't have any other reason to believe those statistics are unreliable other than they say I'm wrong. What exactly are you getting at?"

:rolleyes:
Compulsive Depression
14-03-2007, 16:38
I clicked on this thread expecting a wonderfully loopy story about robotic chiroptera.

I am disappointed :(
Kiryu-shi
14-03-2007, 16:53
I don't think that it's the city's place to regulate it. The PSAL (Public School Atheletic League) could make a rule banning metal bats, but I don't see why creating a law banning them is necessary. That being said, baseball is better with wooden bats, if you have the money to replace them every time they break.
IDF
14-03-2007, 17:09
I don't think that it's the city's place to regulate it. The PSAL (Public School Atheletic League) could make a rule banning metal bats, but I don't see why creating a law banning them is necessary. That being said, baseball is better with wooden bats, if you have the money to replace them every time they break.

In my experience of playing baseball, replacing wooden bats was cheaper than buying the $300 cheap (cheap in terms of unfair advantage) graphite bats.
Egg and Chips II
14-03-2007, 17:14
I read that as "bans metal BANDS" and was going to go on a tirade.

Now I have lots of pent up anger and no release...

I need a baseball bat.
Kiryu-shi
14-03-2007, 17:24
In my experience of playing baseball, replacing wooden bats was cheaper than buying the $300 cheap (cheap in terms of unfair advantage) graphite bats.

The most expensive bat I ever used was around a hundred dollars, and my whole Little League team chipped in to buy it, and we all used it. I think that keeping up a stock of wooden bats would be more expensive.
And from your article: Technically, he's right, although MLB approved the use of some composite materials in bats in some Class-A leagues five years ago for the same reason colleges and high schools began allowing them in the mid-1970s: to save money.
Rambhutan
14-03-2007, 17:39
This sounds like it could be a problem for Goths
Cluichstan
14-03-2007, 17:47
http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=ap-jimlitke-031307&prov=ap&type=lgns

I love this. As a true fan of baseball, I hate the ping made when an aluminum bat strikes the ball. I need to hear the crack of a bat that can only come from a Louisville Slugger. I wish the NCAA would follow suit here.

That ping is the sound of pure evil.
Eve Online
14-03-2007, 17:49
I don't think that it's the city's place to regulate it. The PSAL (Public School Atheletic League) could make a rule banning metal bats, but I don't see why creating a law banning them is necessary. That being said, baseball is better with wooden bats, if you have the money to replace them every time they break.

And if you hit someone hard enough with a wooden bat to break it, you can use what's left as a sort of pointy thing to stab the next person.
Zarakon
14-03-2007, 19:18
When metal bats are outlawed, only outlaws will have metal bats.
Utracia
14-03-2007, 19:37
Wow, is baseball being overrun by traditionalists or something?
Kyronea
14-03-2007, 20:22
http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=ap-jimlitke-031307&prov=ap&type=lgns

I love this. As a true fan of baseball, I hate the ping made when an aluminum bat strikes the ball. I need to hear the crack of a bat that can only come from a Louisville Slugger. I wish the NCAA would follow suit here.

Evil! The metal ping is wonderful! Or at least it was when I played baseball, ages ago.

As for the bats, what's wrong with them? They're a good self-defense weapon. Of course I prefer my quarterstaff, but that's just me.
Greyenivol Colony
14-03-2007, 21:10
Girls' Sport! (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rounders)
IDF
14-03-2007, 21:32
As for the costs, Louisville Slugger has a composite/wood bat that has every characteristic of a normal wood bat except that it doesn't break.
Christmahanikwanzikah
14-03-2007, 21:34
"But when the protection of student-athletes is left to people who are in bed with the metal bat companies," Oddo resumed, "someone has to do something."

this isnt actually about the game itself, its about "protecting" student athletes from baseballs hit "too hard"

the composite of the bat has less to do with ball speed than the actual force of swinging the bat well. so i dont see how this actually does anything to help...
New Burmesia
14-03-2007, 21:40
Doesn't the City have anything better to do than fiddle with baseball?