NationStates Jolt Archive


A little excercise could help smokers quit...

Sel Appa
14-03-2007, 02:59
Apparently, just a few minutes of excercise reduces the symptoms of withdrawl. This will be good in the fight against tobacco, which is complex and faces too much opposition.

Link (http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070313/ap_on_he_me/fitness_smoking)

LONDON - As little as five minutes of exercise could help smokers quit, says a new study. Research published in the international medical journal Addiction showed that moderate exercise, such as walking, significantly reduced the intensity of smokers' nicotine withdrawal symptoms.

"If we found the same effects in a drug, it would immediately be sold as an aid to help people quit smoking," said Dr. Adrian Taylor, the study's lead author and professor of exercise and health psychology at the University of Exeter.

Taylor and colleagues reviewed 12 papers looking at the connection between exercise and nicotine deprivation. They focused on exercises that could be done outside a gym, such as walking and isometrics, or the flexing and tensing of muscles. According to their research, just five-minutes of exercise was often enough to help smokers overcome their immediate need for a nicotine fix.

After various types of moderate physical exertion, researchers asked people to rate their need for a cigarette. People who had exercised reported reduced a desire.

"What's surprising is the strength of the effect," said Dr. Robert West, professor of health psychology at University College London. West was not involved in the review. "They found that the acute effects of exercise were as effective as a nicotine patch," he said.

West cautioned that it was unknown how long the effects of exercise would last. "You could in theory use exercise to deal with short bouts of nicotine cravings, but we don't know if it would help in the longer term," he said. It is likely that exercise would have to be combined with a larger strategy of other anti-smoking techniques to be successful in helping people quit.

Nearly anything that distracts people from smoking is thought to help, but scientists have long suspected that exercise might have a more potent effect. Taylor theorized that exercise could produce the mood-enhancing hormone dopamine, which could, in turn, reduce smokers' nicotine dependence.

Still, experts were not convinced about the study's practical applications. "Doctors can tell patients to do things until they're blue in the face, but the limiting factor may be getting people to actually take up exercise," said Dr. Peter Hajek, professor of clinical psychology at Queen Mary University Hospital in London. Hajek was not involved in the study.

Hajek said that if people were taught simple exercises, including isometric exercises they could do at their desk, they could potentially stave off their need for a cigarette break. "When you are dying for a cigarette, you can try to exercise instead," he said.
Mikesburg
14-03-2007, 03:03
Do you suppose this has anything to do with the supposed 'runner's high' that gym teachers used to go on about in the late 70's and early 80's? I always took that as the state's response to youth being more concerned with smoking dope than exercising.

Because really, if all it took was a jog around the block to get stoned, we probably wouldn't be debating a war on drugs, since nobody would bother with them.
MrMopar
14-03-2007, 03:13
The best way to get someone else to stop smoking is to punch them in the crotch every time they light up. Eventually they'll get the picture and stop, just like dogs and taser collars.
Teh_pantless_hero
14-03-2007, 03:18
I sure know a little exercise helped me quit.. exercising.
Todsboro
14-03-2007, 03:19
Whatever.

I spent 13 weeks involuntarily enrolled in the 'smoking cessastion program' offered by the US Army (i.e., Boot Camp). I exercised like a motherfucker; I couldn't smoke.

The first thing I did after graduating? You guessed it, I lit up.

All this typing has raised the blood level of my nicotine content. I need a smoke.
Sel Appa
14-03-2007, 03:31
Whatever.

I spent 13 weeks involuntarily enrolled in the 'smoking cessastion program' offered by the US Army (i.e., Boot Camp). I exercised like a motherfucker; I couldn't smoke.

The first thing I did after graduating? You guessed it, I lit up.

All this typing has raised the blood level of my nicotine content. I need a smoke.

Weak.
[NS:]The HURD
14-03-2007, 04:31
Not starting is a better way not to smoke!
Todsboro
14-03-2007, 04:51
Weak.

Care to elaborate on that?
Deus Malum
14-03-2007, 04:58
Do you suppose this has anything to do with the supposed 'runner's high' that gym teachers used to go on about in the late 70's and early 80's? I always took that as the state's response to youth being more concerned with smoking dope than exercising.

Because really, if all it took was a jog around the block to get stoned, we probably wouldn't be debating a war on drugs, since nobody would bother with them.

There really is a runner's high. Your body releases endorphins during exercise.
Delator
14-03-2007, 06:27
My friend quit smoking cigarettes by smoking a LOT more weed.

It worked... :p
Demented Hamsters
14-03-2007, 06:32
There really is a runner's high. Your body releases endorphins during exercise.
I've had it really strong a couple of times. Felt like I was floating for hours afterwards. Everything was cool, couldn't focus on anything, just sat there sipping coffee and smiling.

Honestly, it was better than any drug I've ever tried.
Greater Trostia
14-03-2007, 06:59
Tobacco withdrawals, if they exist, are nothing. Caffeine withdrawals are much more severe.

As a smoker who has quit several times (I smoke not because I am addicted, but because I like it an it is my choice as an adult), I can say that you will not get someone to quit smoking unless THEY really want to. And, once they really want to, nothing should stand in their way.

But instead, non-smokers like to demonize "addiction," by making people feel disempowered. After all, if I am a helpless addict, then I needn't even TRY quitting, yes? We must emphasize that people DO have control over their own actions. No inanimate object forces someone to go to the store and purchase and open a pack and light up. That is a conscious decision. The sooner anti-smokers realize that the more effective you'll be at making people quit.

Also, scare tactics are bullshit, as is guilt tripping. I am not a murderer simply because I smoke, and yes I know lung cancer is nasty. But you know, there are other causes of lung cancer, and everything has some risk above 0% and less than 100%.

I know I'll get shit for this post. Caffeine is the cool drug everyone can be on, tobacco is the evil.
Todsboro
14-03-2007, 07:31
Caffeine is the cool drug everyone can be on, tobacco is the evil.

But they're two great tastes that taste great together...how can I have my hazlenut without a menthol ?!? :confused:

In all seriousness, I do agree with what you say about 'wanting' to quit. 'Tis more than half the battle...
Greater Trostia
14-03-2007, 07:39
But they're two great tastes that taste great together...how can I have my hazlenut without a menthol ?!? :confused:

In all seriousness, I do agree with what you say about 'wanting' to quit. 'Tis more than half the battle...

ZOMG MENTHOL!

I'm one of the few people I know who likes menthols. But I can't have them too often, same with cloves.

And I do drink caffeine occasionally, but I'm not addicted like I once was. It was actually frightening to discover firsthand physical withdrawal symptoms and I had a tiny bit of insight into what one of my friends went through with heroin. (One reason I absolutely hate the "tobacco is more addictive than heroin" myth. Ugh.)
CthulhuFhtagn
14-03-2007, 12:34
As a smoker who has quit several times (I smoke not because I am addicted, but because I like it an it is my choice as an adult),

That, my friends, is known as addiction.
Eve Online
14-03-2007, 14:57
The best way to get someone else to stop smoking is to punch them in the crotch every time they light up. Eventually they'll get the picture and stop, just like dogs and taser collars.

I exercise, and I smoke. Looks like it's not working.

I can run further and faster than most non-smokers my age.

Tasers, on the other hand, might work. Especially if the police tase you without warning if they see you with a lit cigarette in your hand.

Tasing Works! ('http://www.break.com/index/drunk_chick_gets_tazed.html')