NationStates Jolt Archive


Death Comes for The American Captain.

Pyotr
10-03-2007, 22:10
http://slashdot.org/articles/07/03/07/1939247.shtml

"It ends a long run for the stars-and-stripes-wearing character, created in 1941 to incarnate patriotic feeling during World War II. Over the years, an estimated 210 million copies of "Captain America" comic books, published by New York-based Marvel Entertainment Inc., have been sold in a total of 75 countries. But resurrections are not unknown in the world of comics, and Marvel Entertainment editor in chief Joe Quesada said a Captain America comeback wasn't impossible."

There's a lot of debate over what message the writers are trying to convey with this. I have two theories: Either they're commenting on the state of American civil rights in regards to the patriot act, wiretapping, and Guantanamo et al, or this is a ploy to get more people to buy the comic.
Drunk commies deleted
10-03-2007, 22:12
http://slashdot.org/articles/07/03/07/1939247.shtml



There's a lot of debate over what message the writers are trying to convey with this. I have two theories: Either they're commenting on the state of American civil rights in regards to the patriot act, wiretapping, and Guantanamo et al, or this is a ploy to get more people to buy the comic.

Why can't it be both?
Pyotr
10-03-2007, 22:15
Why can't it be both?

good point, I definitely believe they are commenting on the state of America's civil rights. Capt. America was created in 1941 when we declared war on the Axis powers, he was a symbol for America as a nation killing Capt. America can really mean only one thing: the death of America.
JuNii
10-03-2007, 22:38
http://slashdot.org/articles/07/03/07/1939247.shtml



There's a lot of debate over what message the writers are trying to convey with this. I have two theories: Either they're commenting on the state of American civil rights in regards to the patriot act, wiretapping, and Guantanamo et al, or this is a ploy to get more people to buy the comic.

if he is dead. for all we know, Cap could be playing possum (he's done it before)

this is all during the Civil War timeline. where super powered beings are being forced to Reveal their identities and register with the Government.

so it's more of a commentary of Civil Rights than anything else. Not Guantanimo, not Wiretapping, just the right to privacy and responsiblity. (the situation started out when a Group of Heroes are killed during a "reality show" taping of them taking out some super-powered villians. The collateral damage included the neighborhood and a nearby Elementary school.)
Minaris
10-03-2007, 22:47
if he is dead. for all we know, Cap could be playing possum (he's done it before)

this is all during the Civil War timeline. where super powered beings are being forced to Reveal their identities and register with the Government.

so it's more of a commentary of Civil Rights than anything else. Not Guantanimo, not Wiretapping, just the right to privacy and responsiblity. (the situation started out when a Group of Heroes are killed during a "reality show" taping of them taking out some super-powered villians. The collateral damage included the neighborhood and a nearby Elementary school.)

And then IronMan's all like "Dude, we need to register to keep people safe."

And then Captain's like,"No way. We deserve privacy."

"Realisticism!"

"Idealism!"

"Screw you!"

"WAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"


:D
IL Ruffino
10-03-2007, 22:51
Well the guy who owns the publishing company is obviously Muslim.

Killing an American like that.
Minaris
10-03-2007, 22:54
Well the guy who owns the publishing company is obviously Muslim.

Killing an American like that.

Typical. :rolleyes:
JuNii
10-03-2007, 23:11
Well the guy who owns the publishing company is obviously Muslim.

Killing an American like that.

sorry ruffy, but if it was a muslim, it would've been either a suicide bomber or an IED. Sniped is how a Disgruntled Marine does it. [/jking] :p
Gauthier
10-03-2007, 23:32
They're just prepping for Cap's replacement.

Captain Jesusland.
Kinda Sensible people
10-03-2007, 23:44
They're just prepping for Cap's replacement.

Captain Jesusland.

Exactly! Three days after Captain America dies, he will rise again as Captain Jesusland, to save us all from sinners.
Minaris
10-03-2007, 23:51
sorry ruffy, but if it was a muslim, it would've been either a suicide bomber or an IED. Sniped is how THE MAFIA does it. [/jking] :p

Fixed.
JuNii
11-03-2007, 00:11
Fixed.

Wrong! they employ bombs under cars, or up close with the baseball bat and cement shoes :rolleyes: :p
Andaluciae
11-03-2007, 00:17
Probably both.
Minaris
11-03-2007, 00:27
Wrong! they employ bombs under cars, or up close with the baseball bat and cement shoes :rolleyes: :p

Don't forget the posionings. :p
Johnny B Goode
11-03-2007, 00:29
good point, I definitely believe they are commenting on the state of America's civil rights. Capt. America was created in 1941 when we declared war on the Axis powers, he was a symbol for America as a nation killing Capt. America can really mean only one thing: the death of America.

Gotta agree with ya there.
Deep World
11-03-2007, 00:30
good point, I definitely believe they are commenting on the state of America's civil rights. Capt. America was created in 1941 when we declared war on the Axis powers, he was a symbol for America as a nation killing Capt. America can really mean only one thing: the death of America.

Except that Captain America did die. He was sucked into a space rift or some such and transported into an alternate dimension, never to be seen again. I think he was killed off more because his particular brand of patriotism didn't make much sense after Vietnam and the JFK assassination. Although he did end up confronting some surprisingly human issues toward the end of WWII, such as conditions in POW camps.
JuNii
11-03-2007, 00:38
Don't forget the posionings. :p

:headbang: posionings are done by assassins, jilted lovers/spouses and amatures... man doesn't anyone watch regular tv anymore?!? :p
Minaris
11-03-2007, 00:45
:headbang: posionings are done by assassins, jilted lovers/spouses and amatures... man doesn't anyone watch regular tv anymore?!? :p

Foolish white boy!

The Mafia does all! (except suicide bombings...) :D
UN Protectorates
11-03-2007, 00:54
Don't forget the posionings. :p

Don't be silly. That is the domain of the former KGB and present FSB.
Kologk
11-03-2007, 03:23
Poor Cap.

The Punisher shall take the mantle!

Wolverine shall take the mantle!

Iron Man shall steal the mantle!

Jack Ruby shall take the mantle!

USAgent shall take the mantle! (Despite that he's working for the Canadians!!!!
Utracia
11-03-2007, 03:32
http://slashdot.org/articles/07/03/07/1939247.shtml



There's a lot of debate over what message the writers are trying to convey with this. I have two theories: Either they're commenting on the state of American civil rights in regards to the patriot act, wiretapping, and Guantanamo et al, or this is a ploy to get more people to buy the comic.

I haven't read the comic but as I understand it in the civil war going on between the superheroes, Captain America was on the side fighting the government and iits attack on civil rights. Sounds like his death was a plus for the government and its aims so I suppose it could be saying that the attacks on our rights are succeeding.
Ghost Tigers Rise
11-03-2007, 03:34
sorry ruffy, but if it was a muslim, it would've been either a suicide bomber or an IED. Sniped is how a Disgruntled Marine does it. [/jking] :p

Actually, no.

Sniped is how Natalie Portman (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_The_Professional) does it.

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h297/Aenimus/Natalie-Portman-Photograph-C1214985.jpg