NationStates Jolt Archive


"How could they do such a thing"?

Zarakon
16-12-2006, 07:32
What always pisses me off, is like after columbine, for example, people were wondering "How could they do this? Why would they do this?"

It's so obvious.

When you treat someone like shit, eventually they're going to fight back. It's happened throughout history. America rebelled from Britain, India rebelled from britain, France overthrew it's kings, Russia overthrew it's Czars. The woman's rights movement, the abolitionists. Martin Luther King. Malcolm X. NAACP. The Black Panthers.

See what I'm getting at? It's so obvious. These kids were treated like shit every day of there lives.

I'm not justifying there actions, I'm merely saying you should be able to see why they did it.
Kanabia
16-12-2006, 07:39
Plenty of other people are treated like shit and they don't go and shoot a bunch of defenceless schoolkids in the face.
UnHoly Smite
16-12-2006, 07:41
Plenty of other people are treated like shit and they don't go and shoot a bunch of defenceless schoolkids in the face.

I can back you up on that.:(
Ravea
16-12-2006, 07:43
Most people are treated like shit by at least a few others. That's no reason to kill them.
UnHoly Smite
16-12-2006, 07:44
Most people are treated like shit by at least a few others. That's no reason to kill them.


Says you. I can name about 5 people I would shoot dead if I had the chance....
Maraque
16-12-2006, 07:49
Says you. I can name about 5 people I would shoot dead if I had the chance....That's... great. :eek:
Ravea
16-12-2006, 07:49
Says you. I can name about 5 people I would shoot dead if I had the chance....

And I assume you're aware of the severe consequences of killing somebody. Usually it ends with either life in prision or death. Not a very enjoyable way to end your life, I'd say.
UnHoly Smite
16-12-2006, 07:52
And I assume you're aware of the severe consequences of killing somebody. Usually it ends with either life in prision or death. Not a very enjoyable way to end your life, I'd say.



Ever heard of justifiable homicide?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justifiable_homicide
Siap
16-12-2006, 07:54
What always pisses me off, is like after columbine, for example, people were wondering "How could they do this? Why would they do this?"

It's so obvious.

When you treat someone like shit, eventually they're going to fight back. It's happened throughout history. America rebelled from Britain, India rebelled from britain, France overthrew it's kings, Russia overthrew it's Czars. The woman's rights movement, the abolitionists. Martin Luther King. Malcolm X. NAACP. The Black Panthers.

See what I'm getting at? It's so obvious. These kids were treated like shit every day of there lives.

I'm not justifying there actions, I'm merely saying you should be able to see why they did it.

Book Recommendation: Going Postal by Mark Ames
Ravea
16-12-2006, 07:59
Ever heard of justifiable homicide?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justifiable_homicide

Erm.

If you are forced to kill someone-as in someone is coming at you with a loaded pistol or a knife or is obviously going to do extreme physical harm to you or those around you-by all means, kill away.

Nowhere in your link is mentioned the words, "Go ahead and kill whoever you don't like."
UnHoly Smite
16-12-2006, 08:01
Erm.

If you are forced to kill someone-as in someone is coming at you with a loaded pistol or a knife or is obviously going to do extreme physical harm to you or those around you-by all means, kill away.

Nowhere in your link is mentioned the words, "Go ahead and kill whoever you don't like."

If I killed anybody I didn't like ther would be about 4 people left in earth as I pretty much hate everybody...But I never said who and why.
Seangoli
16-12-2006, 08:01
Plenty of other people are treated like shit and they don't go and shoot a bunch of defenceless schoolkids in the face.

It is apparent you have never been treated like shit every day of your life, by countless people, never letting up? Every waking moment it seems like your life is just a just pile shit, with other people just making the entire situation worse?

I do. I was "unpopular", I was a "social outcast", I hated everybody. And quite frankly, I was quite near the point of shooting up the school.

It's not that they were treated like shit once or twice, or even a dozen of times. It's the fact that almost everybody treated them like shit practically all the time.

Add to this any number of social/mental disorders(Such as depression, which I also have, and have intimate knowledge of what it actually does to people), and quite frankly I'm not surprised that they actually did what they did.

But hey. Nobody wants to do a retrospective on their own lives, and how they may have contributed to the monsters of society, now do they? Of course not, it would mean be responsible and respectful towards others, but that just gets in the way of a "good time".
Ravea
16-12-2006, 08:03
Book Recommendation: Going Postal by Mark Ames

Great book. I read it last summer; it's one of my favorites.
Ravea
16-12-2006, 08:04
If I killed anybody I didn't like ther would be about 4 people left in earth as I pretty much hate everybody...But I never said who and why.

It must be quite an achivement to meet all 6.5 billion people on Earth. I wonder how you did it.
Siap
16-12-2006, 08:06
Frankly, had I had the chemical background I have now in middle school, I would've probably blown it off the face of the Earth.
Vetalia
16-12-2006, 08:07
Generally, if you keep pushing mentally deranged people there's a pretty damn good chance that they're going to lose it and lash out somehow. It's happened before, and it will damn well likely happen again. Not to mention there were plenty of warning signs that they were going to do something violent; the Columbine murderers had been unstable for a while.

Two easy to remember tips: Don't treat others like shit, and if you hear someone is going to commit an act of violence, report it immediately.
Vetalia
16-12-2006, 08:09
It must be quite an achivement to meet all 6.5 billion people on Earth. I wonder how you did it.

Well, if you met one person per second, every day, for 100 years you'd meet about 1/2 the current population of the Earth.
Ravea
16-12-2006, 08:12
Well, if you met one person per second, every day, for 100 years you'd meet about 1/2 the current population of the Earth.

That's a pretty impressive calculation.

Guess I should meet every single person on Myspace, the Jolt forums, and Connecticut to begin with.
Seangoli
16-12-2006, 08:15
That's a pretty impressive calculation.

Guess I should meet every single person on Myspace, the Jolt forums, and Connecticut to begin with.

Please, oh please, start with Kansas. Somehow, I doubt their destruction will be missed.
Vetalia
16-12-2006, 08:19
Please, oh please, start with Kansas. Somehow, I doubt their destruction will be missed.

The state, not the band.
Seangoli
16-12-2006, 08:19
The state, not the band.

Fine, if you want to get specific, I suppose the State would be preferable. Why not both, just to be safe?
ShadowMark
16-12-2006, 08:21
since ur going to kansas can u tell me if its black n white like in the wizard of oz?
Vetalia
16-12-2006, 08:21
Fine, if you want to get specific, I suppose the State would be preferable. Why not both, just to be safe?

Well, if we didn't have the band we would lose a classic 1970's rock staple...and we can't afford to lose that.

I mean, imagine what would happen if we applied that to the bands America or Europe?
The Fleeing Oppressed
16-12-2006, 08:28
Most people are treated like shit by at least a few others. That's no reason to kill them.
The OP is not saying it was right. He's saying he gets pissed of when people say "How could they do such a thing?" when it's obvious why they did it.

They were pushed too far. Every day for years they were treated like shit. They were not strong enough to deal with it without using extreme measures. Nothing would balance the pwer dynamic between them and the bullies, except guns. These people had made their lives not worth living, sol they'd finish their lives. I'm not a trained psych, and I've never talked to the school students involved, but that bullying story gets played out in schools everywhere. Every now and then, the bullied gets pushed over the edge.
Poliwanacraca
16-12-2006, 08:35
Please, oh please, start with Kansas. Somehow, I doubt their destruction will be missed.

Aw, I'd miss it. Several members of my family live on that side of the state line. Plus, a bunch of my favorite restaurants and stores are over there, too. I'd have to drive twice as far to get to the good ones in my own state. They even have the only Ben & Jerry's in the area!

Of course, if you just wiped out western Kansas, that would be okay. :D
UnHoly Smite
16-12-2006, 09:48
It must be quite an achivement to meet all 6.5 billion people on Earth. I wonder how you did it.


I am a telemarketer.:p
Proggresica
16-12-2006, 11:01
What always pisses me off, is like after columbine, for example, people were wondering "How could they do this? Why would they do this?"

It's so obvious.

When you treat someone like shit, eventually they're going to fight back. It's happened throughout history. America rebelled from Britain, India rebelled from britain, France overthrew it's kings, Russia overthrew it's Czars. The woman's rights movement, the abolitionists. Martin Luther King. Malcolm X. NAACP. The Black Panthers.

See what I'm getting at? It's so obvious. These kids were treated like shit every day of there lives.

I'm not justifying there actions, I'm merely saying you should be able to see why they did it.

I'm sure some sort of mental illness would play a part in a lot of these cases.
Lydania
16-12-2006, 14:48
Frankly, had I had the chemical background I have now in middle school, I would've probably blown it off the face of the Earth.

Avian flu or ebola, here, while I took a nice, long vacation to the U.K. and France.
Darknovae
16-12-2006, 14:58
Avian flu or ebola, here, while I took a nice, long vacation to the U.K. and France.

Coming from somebody who was an outcast in middle school, you have no idea how many daydreams I have of setting my old middle school in fire.

My county was only meant to have one middle school, and th second is the most retarded in the whole country- students and some teachers (I had some good teachers!)
Bodies Without Organs
16-12-2006, 15:06
I mean, imagine what would happen if we applied that to the bands America or Europe?

Let us not forget the band called Asia.
Bodies Without Organs
16-12-2006, 15:10
See what I'm getting at? It's so obvious. These kids were treated like shit every day of there lives.

For what it's worth, Wiki sez... "Later investigation showed, however, that the notion they were unpopular and outsiders was largely a myth, although the idea had become ingrained in popular accounts."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Harris_and_Dylan_Klebold
Kryozerkia
16-12-2006, 15:11
I never had the need to kill, when I could just threat the assholes who made my life miserable with bodily harm, and no one ever did jack shit about it and the assholes who made my life miserable kissed my ass through high school. Power trip FTW.
Kanabia
16-12-2006, 15:13
It is apparent you have never been treated like shit every day of your life, by countless people, never letting up? Every waking moment it seems like your life is just a just pile shit, with other people just making the entire situation worse?

I do. I was "unpopular", I was a "social outcast", I hated everybody. And quite frankly, I was quite near the point of shooting up the school.

It's not that they were treated like shit once or twice, or even a dozen of times. It's the fact that almost everybody treated them like shit practically all the time.

Add to this any number of social/mental disorders(Such as depression, which I also have, and have intimate knowledge of what it actually does to people), and quite frankly I'm not surprised that they actually did what they did.

But hey. Nobody wants to do a retrospective on their own lives, and how they may have contributed to the monsters of society, now do they? Of course not, it would mean be responsible and respectful towards others, but that just gets in the way of a "good time".

Oh, really now? Do not presume that you can read anything into me. You don't know me, and you don't know anything about my life.

I will say this much - I spent the majority of my teenage life battling on my own terms with depression as a result of social ostracisation. I have on several occasions on this forum explained some of my experiences more in-depth, but I do not wish to repeat them in this thread.

On several instances I contemplated a violent solution to problems - hitting back, since I had been taking karate lessons for some time - but I never stooped to that level.

There is no justification or appropriate reasoning for what the Columbine kids did. They may have felt that their problems were the cause of their actions, but that does not explain the countless others in similar situations around the world that do not resort to physical violence. I'm not saying that bullying isn't a problem. Far from it. But I hardly think the Columbine kids are an appropriate example of the impacts of bullying, since i'm willing to bet they were more than a little unstable anyway, even in comparison to others suffering the brunt of schoolyard prejudice. We should focus on preventing bullying for its own sake rather than holding these two psychopaths up as some sort of bizarrely twisted role model. They were not forced to kill or injure anyone and don't deserve the least bit of sympathy.
Hobos That Read
16-12-2006, 15:17
Kanabia said it, but its a double-edged sword (as are most things), as the examples given (Russians overthrowing the Czars, French the monarchy) they are/were considered good things.

It all depends on how you do it, I mean its very unlikely but one of these kids could've become President and totally changed America in a good way, but he choose the easy way out.
The Plutonian Empire
16-12-2006, 15:19
Coming from somebody who was an outcast in middle school, you have no idea how many daydreams I have of setting my old middle school in fire.
I used nukes and god-powers in my daydreams. ;)

Yeah, I was outcast in high school too :(

Sent me over the edge too. except my edge was a suicide attempt, not a gun, thankfully.
Darknovae
16-12-2006, 15:19
Kanabia said it, but its a double-edged sword (as are most things), as the examples given (Russians overthrowing the Czars, French the monarchy) they are/were considered good things.

It all depends on how you do it, I mean its very unlikely but one of these kids could've become President and totally changed America.

I wonder what the reunions at Columbine must be like now....
Lydania
16-12-2006, 15:21
I wonder what the reunions at Columbine must be like now....

Probably fairly respectful, at least on the surface. Surprising what the deaths of a few people can do, huh?
Darknovae
16-12-2006, 15:21
I used nukes and god-powers in my daydreams. ;)

Yeah, I was outcast in high school too :(
It's strange, I was a complete loser in middle school but in high school everyone seems to know who I am and who I'm going out with. :eek:

I guess it's because I'm in teh marchin band! :D

Middle schools should have marching bands! :mad:
Darknovae
16-12-2006, 15:23
Probably fairly respectful, at least on the surface. Surprising what the deaths of a few people can do, huh?

Yeah. I'm guessing they're weird.

It would suck if 15 people at my school died in a school shooting and that would be the biggest topic at each reunion. :eek:
The Plutonian Empire
16-12-2006, 15:23
It's strange, I was a complete loser in middle school but in high school everyone seems to know who I am and who I'm going out with. :eek:

I guess it's because I'm in teh marchin band! :D

Middle schools should have marching bands! :mad:
Cool. Good luck with the band :)

I used to be known by everyone. Then we moved out of the city to the middle of nowhere in '98, and that's when it all started going downhill. :headbang:
Yeah. I'm guessing they're weird.

It would suck if 15 people at my school died in a school shooting and that would be the biggest topic at each reunion. :eek:
Try our place. We've been getting huge rashes of deadly car crashes involving high schoolers in recent years :(

Lost someone I've been in a class or two with too. :(
Lydania
16-12-2006, 15:26
It would suck if 15 people at my school died in a school shooting and that would be the biggest topic at each reunion. :eek:

You've probably never heard of Kevin Vermette, have you? That smartened people up in my hometown quite a bit, I tell you.

AMW profile - http://www.amw.com/fugitives/brief.cfm?id=24125
What happened - http://www.amw.com/fugitives/case.cfm?id=24125
Jenrak
16-12-2006, 15:30
There's always a suicide or death at my school every year. Oh, joy.
Bodies Without Organs
16-12-2006, 15:38
There's always a suicide or death at my school every year. Oh, joy.

Is it always the same person?
Hobos That Read
16-12-2006, 15:40
I feel really lucky now:(
Jenrak
16-12-2006, 15:48
Is it always the same person?

No.
The Fleeing Oppressed
16-12-2006, 16:01
I never had the need to kill, when I could just threat the assholes who made my life miserable with bodily harm, and no one ever did jack shit about it and the assholes who made my life miserable kissed my ass through high school. Power trip FTW.
Here's the tip. For most people in your high school, you were the Bullying prick that makes things like Columbine happen. Atleast your post puts that message across.
Lydania
16-12-2006, 16:04
That sort of behaviour would have gotten him expelled from my high school and escorted from the town by police.