NationStates Jolt Archive


It's the damn internet dammit!

Wilgrove
30-11-2006, 06:32
Wow, the RIAA is really desperate now.

RIAA wants the Internet shut down

Interesting argument of the day

By Nick Farrell: Wednesday 29 November 2006, 08:38
ONE OF THE lawyers involved in defending cases bought against people by the RIAA claims that if the music industry wins a crucial case, the Internet will have to be switched off.

Speaking on the DefectiveByDesign anti-DRM campaign site, Ray Beckerman said the case of Electro vs. Barker has become very important for the web's future.

Barker was being defended by Beckerman who made a motion to dismiss the case because the RIAA had forgot to provide any acts or dates or times of copyright infringement as the law normally requires.

The RIAA argued that by merely making files available on the Internet Barker was making a copyright infringement.

Beckerman said that it was a shocking argument because if it were accepted by the court it would probably shut down the entire Internet. If you send any file on the Net the RIAA will be allowed to suspect that you are in breach of copyright.

What was more disturbing is that the RIAA called up its mates in Washington to back it up. Apparently the United States Government has put in motions supporting the RIAA.

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=36027

Of course with this being The Inquirer, I doubt this is legit, but it can still be good for a laugh.
The Nazz
30-11-2006, 06:38
The courts will probably find a way to split the difference here, i.e. rule against the defendant but not give the RIAA the ruling they seek. That seems to be the way they've done this in the past.
Zilam
30-11-2006, 06:41
No intraw3bs?!!!11uno!!!

I will like....shrivel up and die...like a penis being kicked in an ice storm.
The Nazz
30-11-2006, 06:55
The court can't make the ruling that sweeping. The defendant's lawyer is taking the potential to the logical extreme because that's his job, and were the law a consistent beast, I'd be worried, but the courts, especially when it comes to copyright law, have become masters of sucking RIAA cock just enough to give them their power but without threatening the internet as a whole.
Notaxia
30-11-2006, 07:00
ppft. There is more money for the net that there is against copyright issues. The RIAA doesnt have the pull to kll the net, and really? It doesnt have any powers outside the USA.
Big Jim P
30-11-2006, 08:45
No intraw3bs?!!!11uno!!!

I will like....shrivel up and die...like a penis being kicked in an ice storm.

Sig'd
Wilgrove
30-11-2006, 08:46
Man just imagine what would happen if the internet really was shut down.

:eek:

CHAOS!
Zilam
30-11-2006, 08:47
Sig'd

And my goal in life is now complet :D
Big Jim P
30-11-2006, 08:51
And my goal in life is now complet :D

You're welcome. I believe that makes you the second person I've quoted in my sig.

Edit: No the third.
Zilam
30-11-2006, 08:55
You're welcome. I believe that makes you the second person I've quoted in my sig.

Edit: No the third.


-feels humbled and special like- :fluffle:
Big Jim P
30-11-2006, 09:00
-feels humbled and special like- :fluffle:

You should. Not everyone posts things amusing enough for me to waste time sigging. You, Eut, and Hotrodia so far.