NationStates Jolt Archive


guess gun control works?

Secret aj man
21-11-2006, 05:55
my heart goes out to all injured,or hopefully not worse.

i may be incorrect,but i would imagine germany has pretty strict gun control?

i know it is a egg/chicken argument...but to say by banning guns,one will prevent these kinds of tragedies is foolish...too me at least.
as obviously,this insane tard seemed to get a gun in a country that i assume is pretty harsh about gun ownership.

now i am not saying that people have the right to not be around guns,or that people may be safer without guns around,but really,as an american in a country awash with guns(lots of illegal ones)
i think it would be foolish of me to hope for the gov to protect me.

germany probably does not have 1/millioneth of the guns in the u.s.let alone the laws to allow carry,and yet this still happens?

i dont even want into get into the whole right to defend self/and family...which i believe everyone has the right too..but merely curious about how this can happen in a country...like canada recently...that is pretty anti gun.
let alone,i am pretty sure that machine guns cannot be owned by the general populace...like in the states.

...i think the crime commited in the u.s. with machine guns is about equal to germanys.
go figure?

anyhow...my deepest symphathy to all concerned...



Gunman dies after German school siege
November 21, 2006
A MASKED gunman with explosives strapped to his body ran into a high school in northern Germany today and opened fire on teachers and students, wounding eight, police said.

A caretaker, a pregnant teacher and six students were reportedly injured as they tried to confront the man.

The assailant, who was later found dead, has been identified in German press reports as an 18-year-old former student at the Scholl secondary school in Emsdetten.

He is reported to have killed himself after briefly negotiating with police and as commandos prepared to storm the building.

The attacker was armed with a machine gun and set off a series of explosions during the brief siege, filling classrooms with smoke. Around 20 people, most of them police officers, suffered from smoke inhalation.

His body, badly disfigured, was discovered on the second floor of the school, where he retreated after the police were called and surrounded the building. Police said several pipe bombs were also found by the corpse and it was unclear whether the man had killed himself or died during an explosion.

Bomb disposal experts were called to defuse the devices attached to the body before it could be properly examined. "He is still lying there because he’s wired up," Hans Volkmann, a police officer investigating the attack, said this afternoon.

A teacher at the school was quoted by German press reports naming the attacker as a former pupil called Bastian. Authorities would not confirm the identity but a spokesman for the state prosecutor's office said he believed that the man was known to the police..

The state prosecutor, Wolfgang Schweer, said police had discovered photographs on the internet showing the attacker in military-style uniforms brandishing weapons. He was facing trial tomorrow on weapons offences and left a suicide note that "indicates something of his motive," said Mr Schweer.

"He seems to have been frustrated by a lack of meaning in his life," Mr Schweer told a news conference. "We have no reason to think he had contact with any extremist groups. It appears that he was a loner who decided on his own to do this."

Witnesses said the attacker climbed out of a car and walked into the school yard at around 9.30am local time, opening fire immediately.

Pupils and teachers streamed out of the high school, near Muenster, near the Dutch border, and fled into the street and nearby fields as he entered the main building.

None of the injuries are thought to be serious. The school secretary telephoned the police and first patrol car arrived six minutes after the alarm was raised.

The rest of the 693 pupils at the school, which is for children aged 11-16, were evacuated safely, police said. German television news showed pupils crying in the streets outside Scholl high school, which is in a prosperous suburb.

Katja Weber, a 17-year-old student at the school, said the assailant was known for always wearing a black hat and coat. "He was an absolute loner," she said. "Guns were his hobby."

School shootings and murders are not without precedent in Germany. In 1999, a 15-year-old student stabbed his teacher 21 times after taking bets from his classmates, who did not believe he would do it. He was imprisoned for seven and a half years. In 2002, a former student killed 17 people, including himself, in a classroom massacre in the eastern city of Erfurt.


here's the link:http://www.theaustralian.news.com.a...30-2703,00.html


i just am curious how gun control works when this happens in a country that is draconion about guns,yet in the u.s. we have the same amount of aberration.
i understand there will always be crazies,and it is fundamentally safer if no guns were around,but as this shows..maybe not.
we have zillions of legally owned guns,and all the laws dont change the loner from making a weapon or going on a rampage,so why deprive me the right to defend myself...honest question.
Red_Letter
21-11-2006, 06:01
I think someone brought up in an earlier thread that there are about 10,000,000 privately owned gun in Germany. Nowhere near the US level, but a large amount nonetheless.

the school, which is for children aged 11-16... Katja Weber, a 17-year-old student...
Kulikovia
21-11-2006, 06:03
http://cinema.concordia.ca/journal/images/pickford-(guns).jpg

Kids these days...
The Nazz
21-11-2006, 06:05
None of the injuries are thought to be serious. The school secretary telephoned the police and first patrol car arrived six minutes after the alarm was raised.
We have less gun control in the US, but in our school shootings, there's considerably more bloodshed. Is that the point you were trying to make?

secret aj man, using individual examples to make a point about a larger issue is a dangerous way to argue because it sets you up for the objection that this could be an exception to the rule.
Neu Leonstein
21-11-2006, 06:36
Here's another article about it.

http://www.spiegel.de/international/0,1518,449492,00.html

A retard, bascially. Let's just hope this isn't gonna turn into another one of those "ban computer games" stories.

It's also interesting to note that at least one of his guns was an air rifle of some sort.
CanuckHeaven
21-11-2006, 07:05
i just am curious how gun control works when this happens in a country that is draconion about guns,yet in the u.s. we have the same amount of aberration.
i understand there will always be crazies,and it is fundamentally safer if no guns were around,but as this shows..maybe not.
we have zillions of legally owned guns,and all the laws dont change the loner from making a weapon or going on a rampage,so why deprive me the right to defend myself...honest question.
INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVES ON GUN CONTROL (http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/Savelsberg1.html)

This article gives many reasons why gun control works in Germany.
CanuckHeaven
21-11-2006, 07:05
We have less gun control in the US, but in our school shootings, there's considerably more bloodshed. Is that the point you were trying to make?

secret aj man, using individual examples to make a point about a larger issue is a dangerous way to argue because it sets you up for the objection that this could be an exception to the rule.
I agree.
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 07:10
If you ban guns, you'll have "knife-wielding madmen," and of course "only outlaws will have guns." The issue isn't the weapon, it's the intelligence (or lack thereof) of the people operating them. Teaching responsibility in handling instruments of death is where efforts should be devoted to.
Congo--Kinshasa
21-11-2006, 07:14
If you ban guns, you'll have "knife-wielding madmen," and of course "only outlaws will have guns." The issue isn't the weapon, it's the intelligence (or lack thereof) of the people operating them. Teaching responsibility in handling instruments of death is where efforts should be devoted to.

Amen.
Soviet Haaregrad
21-11-2006, 07:26
If you ban guns, you'll have "knife-wielding madmen," and of course "only outlaws will have guns." The issue isn't the weapon, it's the intelligence (or lack thereof) of the people operating them. Teaching responsibility in handling instruments of death is where efforts should be devoted to.

When crazy people commit violence isn't not a case of lacking responsibility or intellegence. In a case like this, teaching the person all the gun-ownership responsibility in the world would ensure is that the crazy person safely brings their gun to where they intend on causing violence. It's unlikely as much damage could of been caused by a knife.

That said, I'm all for sane, responsible adults being allowed to own guns if they choose.
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 07:42
blah blah blah crazy people blah blah blah.

It's probably better for crazy people to have guns. It makes for good evening news, and allows America to continue being the life of the world party.

That said, I'm all for sane, responsible adults being allowed to own guns if they choose.

Good for you. But won't someone please think of the children?!
Soviet Haaregrad
21-11-2006, 08:03
It's probably better for crazy people to have guns. It makes for good evening news, and allows America to continue being the life of the world party.

Life of the party; rowdy, redneck, jock neighbour who crashes the party and pukes in the pool... almost the same. :D While crazy people owning guns makes good entertainment for me, it's horrible for the people who's loved ones get killed because the neighbours dog told them to.
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 08:08
Life of the party; rowdy, redneck, jock neighbour who crashes the party and pukes in the pool... almost the same. :D

WOOO!!! USA! USA! USA! *vomits*

While crazy people owning guns makes good entertainment for me, it's horrible for the people who's loved ones get killed because the neighbours dog told them to.

Yeah... *sigh* :(
Demented Hamsters
21-11-2006, 08:44
my heart goes out to all injured,or hopefully not worse.

i may be incorrect,but i would imagine germany has pretty strict gun control?

i know it is a egg/chicken argument...but to say by banning guns,one will prevent these kinds of tragedies is foolish...too me at least.
as obviously,this insane tard seemed to get a gun in a country that i assume is pretty harsh about gun ownership..

Gee...let's see: How many school shootings have there been in Germany in the last 10 years?
How many in the USA?

OMG! Two in Germany! That proves gun control doesn't work!
We have far less gun control in the USA and look, there's been only...wait...more than two in the USA. Lots more...lots and lots more*...wait what was I saying again about gun control not working?


*over 20 if you really want to know.
Betweem 1989 and 2006 there were 30 school shootings in the West. 25 of them in the USA.
http://www.emergency-management.net/school_shoot.htm
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 08:54
Gee...let's see: How many school shootings have there been in Germany in the last 10 years?
How many in the USA?

OMG! Two in Germany! That proves gun control doesn't work!
We have far less gun control in the USA and look, there's been only...wait...more than two in the USA. Lots more...lots and lots more*...wait what was I saying again about gun control not working?


*over 20 if you really want to know.
Betweem 1989 and 2006 there were 30 school shootings in the West. 25 of them in the USA.
http://www.emergency-management.net/school_shoot.htm

*scoffs* Statistics... those numbers don't take into account that America has a higher emo/antisocial/psychopathic kid ratio than Deutschland, and those pesky liberal news networks have to blab every little thing they hear about. Guns are good! I rest my case. *fires a rifle volley in the air, accidentally killing a pigeon*
Demented Hamsters
21-11-2006, 08:58
*scoffs* Statistics... those numbers don't take into account that America has a higher emo/antisocial/psychopathic kid ratio than Deutschland, and those pesky liberal news networks have to blab every little thing they hear about. Guns are good! I rest my case. *fires a rifle volley in the air, accidentally killing a pigeon*Careful where that pigeon lands. Don't want to hurt anyone now.
Congo--Kinshasa
21-11-2006, 09:41
*fires a rifle volley in the air, accidentally killing a pigeon*

Noooo! :(

*cradles pigeon in arms, screaming, "Why, God, why?"*
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 10:08
Noooo! :(

*cradles pigeon in arms, screaming, "Why, God, why?"*

<_< >_> *runs away*
Andaluciae
21-11-2006, 10:22
Noooo! :(

*cradles pigeon in arms, screaming, "Why, God, why?"*

I know a homeless rapping bum who could use your pigeon there.
Planet Tom
21-11-2006, 10:27
*scoffs* Statistics... those numbers don't take into account that America has a higher emo/antisocial/psychopathic kid ratio than Deutschland, and those pesky liberal news networks have to blab every little thing they hear about. Guns are good! I rest my case. *fires a rifle volley in the air, accidentally killing a pigeon*

The United States leads the world's richest nations in gun deaths with 14.24 deaths per 100 000 people. Germany, with its strong gun laws, has only 1.24. Japan has only 0.05 gun deaths per 100,000. The police in Japan actively raid homes of those suspected of having weapons.

Oh, and I did realise that you were being sarcastic (I hope).
Maunids
21-11-2006, 10:35
Take a look at Switzerland...

They have plenty of guns, indeed most adult men have an "evil assault rifle" at home..

----> http://world.guns.ru/assault/sig550_2.jpg * looks evil to me, and is devilishly expensive (3000$)

And not many tragedies (can't remember a Swiss school shooting).
It's not about guns, it's about people. US has far more other crime, atomised society.. etc

In the Czech Republic... people can own .50 cal machineguns (punch through armored cars as if they were butter).
No one uses legal guns for crime. (less than 0.5% of all firearms crime is done by legal weapons.. and
no, there isn't much crime in Czech Republic).
People do have to get a permit, but it's easy for anyone with more than 4 neurons..
Bitchkitten
21-11-2006, 10:46
Gee...let's see: How many school shootings have there been in Germany in the last 10 years?
How many in the USA?

OMG! Two in Germany! That proves gun control doesn't work!
We have far less gun control in the USA and look, there's been only...wait...more than two in the USA. Lots more...lots and lots more*...wait what was I saying again about gun control not working?


*over 20 if you really want to know.
Betweem 1989 and 2006 there were 30 school shootings in the West. 25 of them in the USA.
http://www.emergency-management.net/school_shoot.htm

What's the US population compared to that of the rest of Western Europe?
Bitchkitten
21-11-2006, 10:48
The United States leads the world's richest nations in gun deaths with 14.24 deaths per 100 000 people. Germany, with its strong gun laws, has only 1.24. Japan has only 0.05 gun deaths per 100,000. The police in Japan actively raid homes of those suspected of having weapons.

Oh, and I did realise that you were being sarcastic (I hope).I guess I should have read the rest of the thread.
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 10:49
I guess I should have read the rest of the thread.

S'okay, it happens to the best of us. (Yeah Tom, I was being sarcastic.)
Planet Tom
21-11-2006, 10:54
S'okay, it happens to the best of us. (Yeah Tom, I was being sarcastic.)

Its "Planet Tom", the pre-nominal social title is not optional!
Der Angst
21-11-2006, 10:56
i may be incorrect,but i would imagine germany has pretty strict gun control?You are, idneed, incorrect.

Once you're eighteen, you can acquire them, so long as they're not automatics, shotguns, and sniper rifles (I think). It requires a lot of paperwork, but other than that... no problem.

Oh, and of course, if you're still under eighteen, the presence of someone eligible for weapon-ownership can get around the problem.

It's perfectly possible for nigh-everyone to legally acquire guns. It just takes a 'lil more efford.

germany probably does not have 1/millioneth of the guns in the u.s.let alone the laws to allow carry,and yet this still happens?I'm willing to take the bet. Given the roughly one-million (1/80 of the population) legal gun owners (Organised in shooting clubs - not counting other owners)... (How many weapons actually exist is unknown, due to bureaucratic chaos. And it's hard to count ilegitimate ones).

What's the US population compared to that of the rest of Western Europe?Roughly 1:1?
Cabra West
21-11-2006, 11:00
Take a look at Switzerland...

They have plenty of guns, indeed most adult men have an "evil assault rifle" at home..

----> http://world.guns.ru/assault/sig550_2.jpg * looks evil to me, and is devilishly expensive (3000$)

And not many tragedies (can't remember a Swiss school shooting).
It's not about guns, it's about people. US has far more other crime, atomised society.. etc

God, I love the Switzerland argument.
Yes, there are guns in almost every household in Switzerland.
There are also extremely strict laws virtually prohibiting these guns from ever being used, as they are in fact military property. The whole thing hast ot do with compulsory military service in Switzerland, and every adult man being a reservist who has to participate in regular military trainings for most of his life.

In essence : Yes, there are guns. And yes, they have probably the strictest gun control in the world.
Almighty America
21-11-2006, 11:01
Its "Planet Tom", the pre-nominal social title is not optional!

Fine, "Planet Tom." Christ, do I go around asking people to call me "Almighty America"? Umm... okay, you win.