NationStates Jolt Archive


How well was the Afghan hunger strike in Dublin reported internationally?

Francis Street
21-05-2006, 16:13
And what do you think of the outcome?

Background: One week ago 41 Afghan asylum seekers entered St. Patrick's Cathedral (a major Dublin cathedral) and refused to leave, announcing that they were going on a hunger strike to force a review of their cases to prevent deportation.

Supporters of the group, mainly classmates of the minors among them, stood outside to show support. During the course of the protests, some had to be removed for medical treatment.

The Church of Ireland (which operates the Cathedral) came up with a compromise with the asylum seekers, but the government did not agree, refusing any compromise.

Late last night, the gardaĆ­ (police) removed the protestors.


Although I don't think that these guys should be deported (assuming none are criminal), I think that the government was right not to negotiate with them. That would result in more hunger strikes. This action was itself a copycat of similar events in Belgium. One group occupied a church there and pulled a hunger strike. The Belgian government conceded to their demands. Now there are twenty such groups occupying churches in Belgium.
Lazy Otakus
21-05-2006, 16:14
Never heard of it.
Ashmoria
21-05-2006, 16:20
i havent heard of it until now

i agree with you that the government shouldnt negotiate with these kinds of cases. if the press wants to look into it, fine, but, as you suggest, the government only encourages more of it by giving them anything for doing it.
German Nightmare
21-05-2006, 16:20
Never heard of it.
Me neither.
Yossarian Lives
21-05-2006, 16:23
I heard about it.
Edit: Has this really stopped them hunger striking? Can't they just carry on elswhere?
Thriceaddict
21-05-2006, 16:26
I heard about it.
Edit: Has this really stopped them hunger striking? Can't they just carry on elswhere?
Me too.
Francis Street
21-05-2006, 16:44
I heard about it.
Edit: Has this really stopped them hunger striking? Can't they just carry on elswhere?
The government has already made it clear that they won't compromise so I doubt it.
Ifreann
21-05-2006, 16:51
There were a few suicide attempts too, I believe. I think one man tried to hang himself on Thursday night.
Nadkor
21-05-2006, 16:53
It was on the news here, but that's not really much of a surprise.
Szanth
21-05-2006, 17:25
Never heard about it.