NationStates Jolt Archive

That's the excuse of a guy charged with Necrophillia. The woman's boyfriend was concerned when he couldn't reach her on his phone, so he asked a friend to check on her. The friend got a little too friendly with the corpse.

http://breakingnews.ie/2006/04/13/story254086.html

"I swear officer, I didn't know she was dead," is not a good excuse in my opinion. Necrophilla is really, really off, but it doesn't directly hurt anyone, unlike rape. He should be punished more if he didn't realise she was dead than if he did.

LMAO
What a perv. But I don't guess he's hurting anybody.

Why exactly is sex with a dead body illegal? I mean, it's like charging someone after a failed attempted suicide.

Why exactly is sex with a dead body illegal?
it's probably got something to do with health risks of having sex with a decaying body (or being around it anyway)

Why exactly is sex with a dead body illegal? I mean, it's like charging someone after a failed attempted suicide.

I don't think the dead body belonged to him.

Why exactly is sex with a dead body illegal? I mean, it's like charging someone after a failed attempted suicide.

:eek: your kidding? its rape, but of a dead person...

I have always thought the suicide thing was funny. But, they want to deter people from commiting suicide, so they try to keep them from trying again by locking them up. I always thought the people who fail at suicide are funny, it's just one more thing they suck at. :D

your kidding? its rape, but of a dead person...

No, it's not rape. Shooting a dead body is not murder. It's just very very creepy. And disturbing for the family.

No, it's not rape. Shooting a dead body is not murder. It's just very very creepy. And disturbing for the family.
That depends on how kinky the family is.

No, it's not rape. Shooting a dead body is not murder. It's just very very creepy. And disturbing for the family.

well, its has to be rape. did he have permission to violate her body? i dont think so...

well, its has to be rape. did he have permission to violate her body? i dont think so...
He didn't need permission. Do you need permission to jack off into a wad of kleenex? A corpse is no more a human being than a Kleenex.

I must point out how disturbingly dull that their sex life must have been - given that she died and he didn't even notice any change in... activity.

He didn't need permission. Do you need permission to jack off into a wad of kleenex? A corpse is no more a human being than a Kleenex.
... ew! Heh... nice one!

Necrophiles should get very shallow sentences in my opinion, they are disturbing the dead but unless they killed the person, they have harmed nobody physically.

He didn't need permission. Do you need permission to jack off into a wad of kleenex? A corpse is no more a human being than a Kleenex.

theres no comparison, a corpse is still human...

... ew! Heh... nice one!

Personally I wouldn't have quite put it like that. If someone is slow to remove the status of human from a dead body I think that's a good thing. I don't want to wake up from a concusion to find a lonely person obtaining satisfaction. "Oh sorry, mate! Thought you were dead."

theres no comparison, a corpse is still human...
Technically it's a human body, but it's not a person. One can't be guilty of murdering a corpse, or assaulting a corpse, so one cannot be guilty of raping a corpse. I don't think the law recognizes those things as violence when done to a corpse, only "desecration" or mutilation or something.

Personally I wouldn't have quite put it like that. If someone is slow to remove the status of human from a dead body I think that's a good thing. I don't want to wake up from a concusion to find a lonely person obtaining satisfaction. "Oh sorry, mate! Thought you were dead."
That's different; you'd have still been showing signs of life... as faint as they may be.

I'd think touching your genitals to rotting, stinking flesh would be enough a punishment for any person. Oh no, this isn't semen, it's maggots!

That's different; you'd have still been showing signs of life... as faint as they may be.

How often do you think necrophilliacs just happen to come accross bodies? Don't you think he or she might be rather over eager and overlook a faint pulse?

Maybe morals are kind of rare around here, but what about respecting the dead? Even if it is a corpse, it is still a human being in my opinion. It's desecration, and disrespect to the dead.

Technically it's a human body, but it's not a person. One can't be guilty of murdering a corpse, or assaulting a corpse, so one cannot be guilty of raping a corpse. I don't think the law recognizes those things as violence when done to a corpse, only "desecration" or mutilation or something.

i guess i have a different view of it. it is not sex with a dead body? unwanted sex im sure, so i still see it as raping a corpse. but thats just my opinion...

Maybe morals are kind of rare around here, but what about respecting the dead? Even if it is a corpse, it is still a human being in my opinion. It's desecration, and disrespect to the dead.
"Being" tends to imply some state of viability...

If people could get what they deserved instead of what the criminal justice system can manage to dish out, then I would say that if this person honestly didn't know she was dead, then he deserves a severe beating and/or several well placed kicks to the groin.

If he knew she was dead, then after said beating and/or groin kicks, then get the man some psychiatric treatment.

Because having sex with a incapacitated woman is sickening. Having sex with a corpse is just sick. :p

Reminds me of a joke.

There was this ugly guy, he walks into a bar with a big grin on his face. The bartender sees the guy smiling and asks whats up.

The man replies " Yeah i was walking home along the tracks, when i found this woman with an amazing body. So i took her home and i banged the hell outta her."

The bartender looks at him, smiles and asks "Did you get a blow job from her?"

The man replied "Nope, couldn't find the head."


ohhh..awful

Reminds me of a joke.

There was this ugly guy, he walks into a bar with a big grin on his face. The bartender sees the guy smiling and asks whats up.

The man replies " Yeah i was walking home along the tracks, when i found this woman with an amazing body. So i took her home and i banged the hell outta her."

The bartender looks at him, smiles and asks "Did you get a blow job from her?"

The man replied "Nope, couldn't find the head."


ohhh..awful

:eek:

Reminds me of a joke.

There was this ugly guy, he walks into a bar with a big grin on his face. The bartender sees the guy smiling and asks whats up.

The man replies " Yeah i was walking home along the tracks, when i found this woman with an amazing body. So i took her home and i banged the hell outta her."

The bartender looks at him, smiles and asks "Did you get a blow job from her?"

The man replied "Nope, couldn't find the head."


ohhh..awful


ew...

I must point out how disturbingly dull that their sex life must have been - given that she died and he didn't even notice any change in... activity.

According to the story, it wasn't the boyfriend who did it, he asked a friend of his to check on his girlfriend for him, and the friend of the boyfriend did it.

That is a disturbing act. Hasn't anyone been around a corpse? There is nobody there, just a body. Like a wax dummy. It must've been cold and dry, ick!

According to the story, it wasn't the boyfriend who did it, he asked a friend of his to check on his girlfriend for him, and the friend of the boyfriend did it.

That is a disturbing act. Hasn't anyone been around a corpse? There is nobody there, just a body. Like a wax dummy. It must've been cold and dry, ick!
Depending upon a number of factors it might well have been warm. The human body's cooling after death, refered to as algor mortis, can be a slow process especially if the body is fat, wrapped in heavy clothing, or in a warm environment. Death from head trauma can actually cause the body to get warmer before it cools for some reason.

in the guys defense... maybe she was alive when they started and she was just so dull that when she died he didnt notice a difference.

Maybe I'm the crazy one, but while having sex with a corpse is disturbing, I'm angier that he thought he was having sex with an incapacitated woman!

That sht just isn't right! :mad:

Maybe I'm the crazy one, but while having sex with a corpse is disturbing, I'm angier that he thought he was having sex with an incapacitated woman!

That sht just isn't right! :mad:


you are the crazy one, but I agree with you anyway

Why exactly is sex with a dead body illegal? I mean, it's like charging someone after a failed attempted suicide.
Duh. If you're dead, you obviously can't give consent...can you!?

you are the crazy one, but I agree with you anyway

The moral of this story: Don't take advantage of women; Do corpses instead. :D

Duh. If you're dead, you obviously can't give consent...can you!?

Neither can a watermelon. But one time I... um... nevermind. :p

Maybe I'm the crazy one, but while having sex with a corpse is disturbing, I'm angier that he thought he was having sex with an incapacitated woman!

That sht just isn't right! :mad:
I know...he should be charged with rape, not necrophilia.

I know...he should be charged with rape, not necrophilia.

Why? You can no more rape a corpse than you can rape a hole in the wall. And somehow I doubt the dead girl was all that bothered, what with being dead and all.

How often do you think necrophilliacs just happen to come accross bodies?
Where there is a will, there is a way. Depending on what their looking for, working in a funeral parlour or having access to a lonely graveyard could keep one happily engaged for years.
Don't you think he or she might be rather over eager and overlook a faint pulse?
In which case, they've commited rape and should be hit with the full weight of the law.
On the other hand, there is nothing wrong with necrophilia (or cannibalism, for that matter), provided that there is no "hunting" involved, and the lot of you decrying it need to get over the puritan sticks lodged in your asses.
That this man has to make an excuse is a terrible indictment against a society that values the rights of a thing over the (nonharmful) desires of a person. When someone dies, there is nothing more that can be done for them: they're only so much rotting meat, and meat (like any other inanimate object) has no rights.

That must have been some very, very, very boring sex...


Not to repeat what every one here has already said, but EWW...

Technically it's a human body, but it's not a person. One can't be guilty of murdering a corpse, or assaulting a corpse, so one cannot be guilty of raping a corpse. I don't think the law recognizes those things as violence when done to a corpse, only "desecration" or mutilation or something.

damn,aside from being flat out gross,and the guy should check into an institution...rape? i cant see the charge as there is no witness to testify.

Is necrophilia rape? Apparently not...

-"You can't rape the willing"
-"Silence is consent"
-"Dead men tell no tales"

well, its has to be rape. did he have permission to violate her body? i dont think so...
Rape is an act of violence and domination. You can't dominate a corpse.

Maybe I'm the crazy one, but while having sex with a corpse is disturbing, I'm angier that he thought he was having sex with an incapacitated woman!

That sht just isn't right! :mad:
No. You're right. If he was just using the "I didn't know she was dead" thing as an excuse, then he has commited a civil crime in using the property of the dead girl's family without their knowledge or conscent. If he really didn't know she was dead, this is attempted rape. (After all, it's still attempted murder if you go after someone with a rubber knife if you didn't know it was made of rubber.)

It is sad that our sexually repressed culture has resulted in people pleading to objectively more harmful crimes as a way of not being seen as "perverted".

That depends on how kinky the family is.

How many people are that kinky?


It is sad that our sexually repressed culture has resulted in people pleading to objectively more harmful crimes as a way of not being seen as "perverted".

Amen.

Rape is an act of violence and domination. You can't dominate a corpse.

But-cha sure can violate it! :rolleyes: