NationStates Jolt Archive


Did Bush lie in the Plame investigation?

Unabashed Greed
07-04-2006, 18:37
I found this in the wake of hearing that "Scooter" put the finger on Bush and Cheney for personaly authorizing him to leak Valerie Plame's name to the press...

On June 24, 2004, President George W. Bush was interviewed by Special Counsel Patrick Fitzgerald. For 70 minutes, Fitzgerald asked the President about the circumstances surrounding the leak of classified information.

What transpired during those 70 minutes, we don't know. But I presume that "did you leak the identity of Valerie Plame" wasn't the only question Fitzgerald asked of the President. Rather, for 70 minutes, the President was likely questioned about many facets of the scandal, including the NIE. Was he questioned about whether he authorized selective leaks? Was he questioned about whether he authorized leaks of the highly sensitive NIE? Given Fitzgerald's reputation for meticulous questioning, and given the length of the interview, whether the President authorized such disclosures was likely covered.

Even though the President was not under oath during those 70 minutes, he sill had an obligation not to make false statements. All of this, of course, presupposes that Libby is telling the truth when he claims Cheney said Bush authorized the leaks. But the latest revelation, coupled with the President's brazen insistence in public that leaks of classified information are anathema to his national security philosophy, makes such a question a legitimate one: what did the President represent to Fitzgerald, and is that consistent with the truth?...

My only real question here is. What reason does Libby have to lie now? Why would a die hard supporter turn on a dime and lie about the president's involvment in this breach?
Ashmoria
07-04-2006, 18:43
welcome to yesterday

i recall mr bush saying that if anyone in his administration is discovered to have participated in the outing of valerie plame he will be dismissed

i am now looking foward to both mr bush and mr cheney resigning.
PsychoticDan
07-04-2006, 18:46
Of course he didn't. He did not have sexual relations with that woman. :mad:
Sumamba Buwhan
07-04-2006, 18:52
don't we expect our politicians to lie?

Whenever we point out that something a Republican said was a lie, thats what their supporters usually spout.
Unabashed Greed
07-04-2006, 19:05
don't we expect our politicians to lie?

Whenever we point out that something a Republican said was a lie, thats what their supporters usually spout.

The problem is that the "well they do it too," isn't, nor should it be an adiquate defence for it. Just because we "expect" politicians to lie doesn't mean we need to excuse it.
Refused Party Program
07-04-2006, 19:07
The problem is that the "well they do it too," isn't, nor should it be an adiquate defence for it. Just because we "expect" politicians to lie doesn't mean we need to excuse it.

Yeah, I keep reading this but I have yet to see an angry mob tie him up and pelt him with eggs.
Sumamba Buwhan
07-04-2006, 19:10
The problem is that the "well they do it too," isn't, nor should it be an adiquate defence for it. Just because we "expect" politicians to lie doesn't mean we need to excuse it.


exactly!