NationStates Jolt Archive

Let's talk about something really important: whether cake or pie is more popular. Inquiring minds want to know. ;)

Oh God, you fool are you trying to restart the WAR!?






(J/K)

Pie is, liek, omg.

Pie as in apple pie or pie as in steak and kidney?

Let's talk about something really important: whether cake or pie is more popular. Inquiring minds want to know. ;)
PIE! Without doubt! No question!

Oh ... wait. This about food! Damn! Disregard. ;)

cake, pie... can't we just get together in friendship and harmony?

besides.... I like both so I'd eat both... at the same time...

Pike!!

Pike!!
Caie!!

Caie!!

Pike>>Caie :mad:

:p

I will kill anyone who votes cake.

Honest.

Not really.

Good thread though, in spite of no comedy poll option and only being able to vote for one option. :mad:

What type of pie are we talking about? :confused:

Good thread though, in spite of no comedy poll option and only being able to vote for one option. :mad:

Hey this is to decide if people believe cake or pie is superior! Any indecisive jerks out there or people who like neither can take their lousy selves somewhere else!

I should have a seperate thread to figure out why people always need a third option. :rolleyes:

Well why don't you? I bet you'll find that you limp-wristed cake pie-eating neo liberal right wing extremist commie two poll option nazis will be right and/or wrong about something. So there. :gundge: Gundge? Since when has there been a "d" in Gunge? :cries:

Pie ...

A pie can be sweet or savory. You can have a chicken pot pie (savory) or a delicious pecan pie (sweet).

Cake is ... well ... cake. Boooooring.

Pie, in its diversity, pwns all.

Cake, because it often is chocolate, whereas pie isn't usually, and chocolate > everything.

Pie as in apple pie or pie as in steak and kidney?Speaking of British language weirdness... ;)

Pike>>Caie :mad:

:p
:(

Ok we should come up with a compromise how about a mix between the two? We can mix the words to come up with a name for it!

I fuckin hate cake.

Speaking of British language weirdness... ;)
Don't tell me you don't have pies? :eek:

I don't actually like steak and kidney, but chicken, plain steak and so on... surely you have them?

:(

Ok we should come up with a compromise how about a mix between the two? We can mix the words to come up with a name for it!

Cpaikee

(pronounced suh-pay-kee) It's a cake wrapped in pastry.

Don't tell me you don't have pies? :eek:

I don't actually like steak and kidney, but chicken, plain steak and so on... surely you have them?I've never heard of steak or kidney pies here, only in Britain. Of course, I've never heard of anyone actually eating a kidney here, either. :eek:

I've never heard of steak or kidney pies here, only in Britain. Of course, I've never heard of anyone actually eating a kidney here, either. :eek:
I hate organs, I don't understand how anyone could eat them. The one good thing about the BSE crisis is that brain is no longer on the menu here.

I fuckin hate cake.
BURN THE EVIL ONE!


Cpaikee

(pronounced suh-pay-kee) It's a cake wrapped in pastry.

Perfect!

I hate organs, I don't understand how anyone could eat them. The one good thing about the BSE crisis is that brain is no longer on the menu here.

Kindey: good
Liver: ok if cooked properly, a lot of people do it wrong though
Heart: yuck

Cake. I don't care for pie. Some psychological aversion to different types of food mized together, I believe.

I hate organs, I don't understand how anyone could eat them. The one good thing about the BSE crisis is that brain is no longer on the menu here.Brain? :eek: :eek: :eek:

Cake. I don't care for pie. Some psychological aversion to different types of food mized together, I believe.

But cake is eggs and bread mixed together!

Brain? :eek: :eek: :eek:
Yep. You can still get it on the Continent easily enough. It makes choosing a meal when you don't understand the language into a game of dare. :p

I hate organs, I don't understand how anyone could eat them. The one good thing about the BSE crisis is that brain is no longer on the menu here.

Awwwww! But what about the zombies?! Won't somebody please think of the zombies???!!!

*brraaaaaaiiiinnzzz*

chocolate!!

Yep. You can still get it on the Continent easily enough. It makes choosing a meal when you don't understand the language into a game of dare. :pLol. And I thought it was bad enough that liver is sold in supermarkets here, you have that stuff on menus over there.

But cake is eggs and bread mixed together!
Ah, but they've been joined together, creating a new food. You can't tell which part was egg and which part was flour.

Lol. And I thought it was bad enough that liver is sold in supermarkets here, you have that stuff on menus over there.
Well, it would originally have been served so that no part of the animal was wasted, and I guess some people just developed a taste for it. I have no idea why. :rolleyes:

I might just be too squeamish though. Someone once gave me ox's tongue, and although there was nothing wrong with it (it tasted like corned beef), the knowledge of what it was meant I couldn't finish it.

Awwwww! But what about the zombies?! Won't somebody please think of the zombies???!!!

*brraaaaaaiiiinnzzz*
Here you go sir! enjoy your meal.

Well, it would originally have been served so that no part of the animal was wasted, and I guess some people just developed a taste for it. I have no idea why. :rolleyes:

I might just be too squeamish though. Someone once gave me ox's tongue, and although there was nothing wrong with it (it tasted like corned beef), the knowledge of what it was meant I couldn't finish it.Perhaps. I couldn't eat liver, though, it just looks bad, but some other organ might not look that bad.

Perhaps. I couldn't eat liver, though, it just looks bad, but some other organ might not look that bad.
Tastes disgusting as well.

Tastes disgusting as well.Ah, I see. Well, the fact that icky internal organs can be part of pie but not cake proves the superiority of cake! :)

Pie.

While cake is very delicious, it's only good to have once in awhile, or it looses it's charm.

Pie on the other hand... one cannot tire of pie. Pie is mighty and delicious, as well as being healthier than cake. One could survive on a variety of pies. Less so with cake.

Ah, I see. Well, the fact that icky internal organs can be part of pie but not cake proves the superiority of cake! :)
Oh, I don't know, I could probably do you a liver gâteau...

Besides, the glory of the pie is that you put whatever you like in it...

Ahh, but the people who tout meat pies are disregarding meatcake.

Oh, I don't know, I could probably do you a liver gâteau...

Besides, the glory of the pie is that you put whatever you like in it...

And yet it still tastes horrible.

Cake is awesome.

Well why don't
Theres something wrong with you.

I bet you'll find that you limp-wristed cake pie-eating neo liberal right wing extremist commie
Source?


right and/or wrong about something.
Chopping up posts makes you smart

So there. :gundge: Gundge? Since when has there been a "d" in Gunge? :cries:
This is how you ended it. FOOL!

Ahh, but the people who tout meat pies are disregarding meatcake.
You are wrong of course, due to your utter lack of comprehension on the matter of pie. There are at least 2 things wrong with your statement.

1. Nobody said anything about cake

2. Drawing dumb conclusions by starting your statement with "Ahh," shows how little intelligence you really have...

We've come to expect better.

We've come to expect better.

You're just ... angry ...

Maybe you should accept the bunnie jesus into your heart.

You're just ... angry ...

Maybe you should accept the bunnie jesus into your heart.
Typical. Attacking a superior poster with off topic drivel. My original statement stands. I've come to expect better.

You are wrong of course, due to your utter lack of comprehension on the matter of pie. There are at least 2 things wrong with your statement.

1. Nobody said anything about cake

The title of the subject is Cake or Pie. One would assume that both cake and pie would be central to the thread. Furthemore, at least two people has used the argument that you can have meat pies as why pie is better.

Pie ...

A pie can be sweet or savory. You can have a chicken pot pie (savory) or a delicious pecan pie (sweet).

Cake is ... well ... cake. Boooooring.

Pie, in its diversity, pwns all.

Oh, I don't know, I could probably do you a liver gâteau...

Besides, the glory of the pie is that you put whatever you like in it...


2. Drawing dumb conclusions by starting your statement with "Ahh," shows how little intelligence you really have...

We've come to expect better.

I think the fact that I am ready, willing and above all able to defend my posts should put beyond doubt my competence.

Finally, and above all else, the post was joking! There is no meatcake! It's from a comedy sketch entitled Keeper of the Icebox!

This is the hardest question ever.

Shall I go with pie, the staple of Weebl and Bob, and a thing of such wondrous verstility as to be both food and weapon at once, or

shall I vote for cake, the staple of birthday parties everywhere, which goes so well with ice cream and can be creativly misspelled as caek?

my head is bursting with the effort of this descision!

The title of the subject is Cake or Pie. One would assume that both cake and pie would be central to the thread. Furthemore, at least two people has used the argument that you can have meat pies as why pie is better.

I think the fact that I am ready, willing and above all able to defend my posts should put beyond doubt my competence.

Finally, and above all else, the post was joking! There is no meatcake! It's from a comedy sketch entitled Keeper of the Icebox!
Though you have raised some good points with your post, you are still missing the point. The existance of meat pie is questionable at best. I'd like to see some sources and perhaps a sample. Also, the defense of your posts doesn't show competence when you are defending ignorance. Shame on you.

Pie, warm apple pie mmm... oh sorry. I um...like pie:D

Pie all the way...I'm surprised that both options are equally popular.

Though you have raised some good points with your post, you are still missing the point. The existance of meat pie is questionable at best. I'd like to see some sources and perhaps a sample. Also, the defense of your posts doesn't show competence when you are defending ignorance. Shame on you.

If you insist.

Try this (http://www.godecookery.com/goderec/grec11.htm), and this, (http://www.meatpiefestival.com/) and this, (http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2003/3/2/191812/1109) and this (http://oaktreedollshouseminiatures.com/Meat-pie.jpg), and this (http://dictionary.reference.com/search?r=2&q=meat%20pie), and the first paragraph from the wikipedia article on pie.

A pie is a baked dish, with a baked shell usually made of pastry that covers or completely contains a filling of meat, fish, vegetables, fruit, cheeses, creams, chocolate, custards, nuts, or other sweet or savoury ingredient. Pies can be either "one-crust," where the filling is placed in a dish and covered with a pastry/potato mash top before baking, or "two-crust," with the filling completely enclosed in the pastry shell. Some pies have only a bottom crust, generally if they have a sweet filling that does not require cooking. These bottom-crust-only pies may be known as tarts or tartlets. One example of a savoury bottom-crust-only pie is a quiche. Tarte Tatin is a one-crust fruit pie that is served upside-down, with the crust underneath. Blind-baking is used to develop a crust's crispiness, and keep it from becoming soggy under the burden of a very liquid filling. If the crust of the pie requires much more cooking than the chosen filling, it may also be blind-baked before the filling is added and then only briefly cooked or refrigerated.which can be found here (http://dictionary.reference.com/search?r=2&q=meat%20pie).

18 for cake and 18 for pie? I'm disappointed! Here I thought there would be a landslide of pie votes! :(

Pie, warm apple pie mmm... oh sorry. I um...like pie:D

Smothered in whipped cream and Vanilla Ice Cream. mmmmm.....:)

Typical. Attacking a superior poster with off topic drivel. My original statement stands. I've come to expect better.

You make Pie sad, Sir Poster.

18 for cake and 18 for pie? I'm disappointed! Here I thought there would be a landslide of pie votes! :(

Pie ish winning!

Pie ish winning!

I must say, this is one of the closest polls I've ever seen on this forum. First pie is winning, then they're tied, then cake is winning, then they're tied again, now pie pulls ahead...

Theres something wrong with you.


Source?



Chopping up posts makes you smart


This is how you ended it. FOOL!

Splang= Funny.
You= Jerk.

Splang= Funny.
You= Jerk.


No, no, don't sink to his level.

I must say, this is one of the closest polls I've ever seen on this forum. First pie is winning, then they're tied, then cake is winning, then they're tied again, now pie pulls ahead...

Well i should hope pie ish winning. If pie were to lose I would be quite sad. And tackle Any cake i see.

No, no, don't sink to his level.

Jerk.

Jerk.

I was only trying to help. If you feel the need to argue with him, at least provide a barrage of sources proving that there are indeed meat pies.

*ahem* It is clear (http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=Pie&word2=Cake) that the victor is pie.

*ahem* It is clear (http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=Pie&word2=Cake) that the victor is pie.

W00t! Go pie!

I was only trying to help. If you feel the need to argue with him, at least provide a barrage of sources proving that there are indeed meat pies.

Meat pies don't exist. 0-o

is the mince pie just native to england.

if it is a challenge to all others. is the mince pie made of meat or fruit???

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

Meat pies don't exist. 0-o

I can only hope that this post was made for it's comedic value.

Piea are undoubtably better. As evidenced not only by meat pies (Which do exist as all people who have visited England know) but also the existence of Cheese and Onion Pies. the happy Veggy alternative. Also thank you Moantha for the barrage of more info about pies then I ever needed to know. ;) and I think that y're definitly missing out on the whole cheese pie thing. silly allergies.

is the mince pie just native to england.

if it is a challenge to all others. is the mince pie made of meat or fruit???

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

Depends is the mince pie made with fruit or meat? If it's made with fruit then it's made with fruit, if it's made with meat it's made with meat.

is the mince pie just native to england.

if it is a challenge to all others. is the mince pie made of meat or fruit???

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

Both.

Piea are undoubtably better. As evidenced not only by meat pies (Which do exist as all people who have visited England know) but also the existence of Cheese and Onion Pies. the happy Veggy alternative. Also thank you Moantha for the barrage of more info about pies then I ever needed to know. ;) and I think that y're definitly missing out on the whole cheese pie thing. silly allergies.

Lauren!!! *tackles*

is the mince pie just native to england.

if it is a challenge to all others. is the mince pie made of meat or fruit???

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

Mince meat was orginally a product that invovled Meat but, now it no longer does.

(From a book called Great British Cooking, which is comically half the size of the rest of our cookbooks)

Lauren!!! *tackles*

Sam!!! *Molests hair*;)

is the mince pie just native to england.

if it is a challenge to all others. is the mince pie made of meat or fruit???

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

NO!!! Keep cookies out of this! When compared to either cake or pie, those measly crumbly things are nothing!

Mince meat was orginally a product that invovled Meat but, now it no longer does.

(From a book called Great British Cooking, which is comically half the size of the rest of our cookbooks)


half the size twice as good / good things come in small packages.
yeah mince pies are fruit based, though i can assure you the name put me of for years. very tasty with whipped cream.

*a cookie*

gonna ignore the first reply. an insult to the mince pie ... a specific kind of

NO!!! Keep cookies out of this! When compared to either cake or pie, those measly crumbly things are nothing!

I agree Fullheartedly!
They are like mini-cakes and therefore need to be eliminated.

half the size twice as good / good things come in small packages.
yeah mince pies are fruit based, though i can assure you the name put me of for years. very tasty with whipped cream.

*a cookie*

gonna ignore the first reply. an insult to the mince pie ... a specific kind of

*blinks* They can be made with both. >.<

this is such a hard decision


(flips coin)

PIE it is.

this is such a hard decision


(flips coin)

PIE it is.

w00t more pie votes.

a cookie (better then everything) to the winner

Sadly, this is apparently the truth (http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=Pie&word2=Cookie). :(

Bah! It's all the result of cookie propaganda I tell you!

w00t more pie votes.

make it cherry or dutch apple


or, for that matter... lemon meringue, peach, chess (Southern USian custard-type pie), blueberry...

damn, i need to get me a pie on the way home.

Sadly, this is apparently the truth (http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=Pie&word2=Cookie). :(

Bah! It's all the result of cookie propaganda I tell you!

=( This makes me want to frown.

Sadly, this is apparently the truth (http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=Pie&word2=Cookie). :(

Bah! It's all the result of cookie propaganda I tell you!


POWER TO THE COOKIE!! the cookie conquers all

mmmmmmmmmmmmmaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Actually i've got cookies that i'm gonna eat when i go home, so i guess this makes me a traitor... =/.

Actually i've got cookies that i'm gonna eat when i go home, so i guess this makes me a traitor... =/.

well you could crush up your cookies... mix them with some melted butter... and make a pie crust out of the mixture.

Toss in a can of your favorite pie filling and VOILA, you have pie.

Honestly though, I'm all about cake that my mom makes. Other than that, pie is better.

well you could crush up your cookies... mix them with some melted butter... and make a pie crust out of the mixture.

Toss in a can of your favorite pie filling and VOILA, you have pie.

Mwahaha so i can make cookies into pie? Brilliant!

Honestly though, I'm all about cake that my mom makes. Other than that, pie is better.
Well i like cookies that my grandmother makes, but otherwise pie all the way. Then again my grandmother makes awsome pie to. Hmmmm does apple cobbler = pie?

Well i like cookies that my grandmother makes, but otherwise pie all the way. Then again my grandmother makes awsome pie to. Hmmmm does apple cobbler = pie?
No, but I'm pretty sure it trumps both pie and cake in one blow.

No, but I'm pretty sure it trumps both pie and cake in one blow.

I agree. Especially with whip cream, vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce served hot.

Where does apple crisp fall?

Where does apple crisp fall?

It dosn't... =/. I'm including more options in the next poll. *goes and makes now*

here is t3h new and revised poll.

http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=475087

Me tinks tis kould b da new "Post of Death" thread!

Bump

Oh and Cake.

Wharte aboot cheesecake??????

Boooo.

Me tinks tis kould b da new "Post of Death" thread!

Bump

Oh and Cake.

Wharte aboot cheesecake??????

Boooo.

Shhh...don't say that, mods might run a pre-emptive move to spam.

As the majority clearly believes, pie rules! I'm really in the mood for lemon meringue pie at the moment. Delicious! :)

Make the pie higher! Make the pie higher!

Pie!! The sheer variety of pies will boggle your mind. Plus they are more versatile than cake.

Pie!! The sheer variety of pies will boggle your mind. Plus they are more versatile than cake.

Exactly! The very idea that cake could ever be thought of as better then pie... crazy.

What can be better then apple pie?

A triple chocolate cake.

A triple chocolate cake.

How about a chocolate pie?

A chocolate pie needs to be refrigerated. Besides....it is kinda gross.

How about a chocolate pie?
Nope, chocolate cake pwns all :p
Chocolate cake
with chocolate chips
and fudge frosting

Mmmm...

I'm the fat ass so I LOVE cake esp. cheese cake! http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j173/GSR40ADDICT/STUFF/BANANA.gif

I'm the fat ass so I LOVE cake esp. cheese cake! http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j173/GSR40ADDICT/STUFF/BANANA.gif

I'd rather stick with lemon meriange pie. Delicious! :)

Cake is #1 if it is Carrot cake.

Gotta be Pie. Coconut Cream, Blackberry, Cherry, or my favourite Pumpkin (made with a cheesecake filling layer). Cake’s got nothing! Nothing I tell you.

A good Key Lime Pie pwns all...

You crazy kids and your key lime.