NationStates Jolt Archive


Moral Dilemma #9

Begoned
26-03-2006, 17:46
Your plane has crash-landed in the desert, and only you and four other people are alive. You have managed to call for a rescue team, but they do not know your exact location, and it will take them anywhere from 1-10 days to reach you. In total, you have 12 days worth of water. Without water, you will die in less than a day. You also happen to have a gun. What do you do (poll coming)?
Defiantland
26-03-2006, 17:57
Uh, I have 12 days water when I need 10 days at the maximum... I'll get along fine. No suicides here.
Kellarly
26-03-2006, 17:57
Wait safely in the knowledge you have enough water to last until the rescue team get to you?
Begoned
26-03-2006, 17:58
Uh, I have 12 days water when I need 10 days at the maximum... I'll get along fine. No suicides here.

You have that water, but the other people don't. It's 12 days worth of water in total, not for each person. Everybody could only survive a bit more than 2 days on the water.
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 17:58
Uh, I have 12 days water when I need 10 days at the maximum... I'll get along fine. No suicides here.

I think he meant 12 days worth of water for one person. There are a total of 5 survivors. You do the math ;) .
I V Stalin
26-03-2006, 18:00
Your plane has crash-landed in the desert, and only you and four other people are alive. You have managed to call for a rescue team, but they do not know your exact location, and it will take them anywhere from 1-10 days to reach you. In total, you have 12 days worth of water. Without water, you will die in less than a day. You also happen to have a gun. What do you do (poll coming)?
Shelter in the plane. Hope that there's enough meat on the other survivors to last me long enough so I don't have to start eating the airline meals.
/Not the 9 o'clock news
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:00
Your plane has crash-landed in the desert, and only you and four other people are alive. You have managed to call for a rescue team, but they do not know your exact location, and it will take them anywhere from 1-10 days to reach you. In total, you have 12 days worth of water. Without water, you will die in less than a day. You also happen to have a gun. What do you do (poll coming)?

Shoot all 4 of them, claim their possesions, use their bodies as food and wait for the rescue team in all relaxation.
HC Eredivisie
26-03-2006, 18:00
I think he meant 12 days worth of water for one person. There are a total of 5 survivors. You do the math ;) .
12/5 = 7 so we'll wait.
Franberry
26-03-2006, 18:01
You have that water, but the other people don't. It's 12 days worth of water in total, not for each person. Everybody could only survive a bit more than 2 days on the water.
shoot everyone but the hot girl.
Kellarly
26-03-2006, 18:01
I think he meant 12 days worth of water for one person. There are a total of 5 survivors. You do the math ;) .

Fair enough, do what one guy did when he crashed in the desert.

Bottle your own urine, boil it and drink it to reuse the water available.


Tasty
Super-power
26-03-2006, 18:01
Shoot a nearby cactus with a gun and drink the water which comes from it :D
Begoned
26-03-2006, 18:04
shoot everyone but the hot girl.

Ah, a true Hollywood ending.
I V Stalin
26-03-2006, 18:04
12/5 = 7 so we'll wait.
Don't know what sort of calculator you're using (one with the divide and subtract buttons the wrong way round probably), but I've always expected 12/5 to equal 2.4.
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:05
I'd start a fire from the burning wreckage of the plane to get things started and then start tending to any injuries. Then the standard RTS fair: explore the area and search for resources, gather necessary resources, build defense, et cetera.
HC Eredivisie
26-03-2006, 18:06
Don't know what sort of calculator you're using (one with the divide and subtract buttons the wrong way round probably), but I've always expected 12/5 to equal 2.4.
Who says I'm using your reality:p
Franberry
26-03-2006, 18:06
Ah, a true Hollywood ending.
thank you, I'll eventually shoot her too(I cant leave witness), then tell the rescue crew they commited sucide
I V Stalin
26-03-2006, 18:06
What do you do (poll coming)?
This poll is taking a long time...
It'd better have a 'Make sandcastles' option on it.
Begoned
26-03-2006, 18:09
explore the area and search for resources, gather necessary resources, build defense, et cetera.

It's a desert, and it's not one of those deserts where stuff grows. It's a stereotypical "sand everywhere" desert:

http://www.meridianphotographicgallery.com/FW-GOBIDESERT/GOBIDESERTPHOTOS/G02%20Gobi%20Desert%20Sand%20Dunes.jpg
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:09
I'd start a fire from the burning wreckage of the plane to get things started and then start tending to any injuries. Then the standard RTS fair: explore the area and search for resources, gather necessary resources, build defense, et cetera.

What recourses are you using to build your homes? I cannot seem to build proper housing to support my population with these 'carrots'.
Kanabia
26-03-2006, 18:11
Drink peepee. Dilute it with whatever water can be spared.
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:13
It's a desert, and it's not one of those deserts where stuff grows. It's a stereotypical "sand everywhere" desert...
Animal Planet tells me there's life everywhere. I can gather rats, snakes, scorpions, and learn me how to say, "Crimony!" That, or ask the local Bedouin tribe where the nearest oasis is.
What recourses are you using to build your homes? I cannot seem to build proper housing to support my population with these 'carrots'.
Bones and animal skins is what you need.
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:25
Bones and animal skins is what you need.

I will ponder upon this.
The Alma Mater
26-03-2006, 18:26
It's a desert, and it's not one of those deserts where stuff grows. It's a stereotypical "sand everywhere" desert:

http://www.meridianphotographicgallery.com/FW-GOBIDESERT/GOBIDESERTPHOTOS/G02%20Gobi%20Desert%20Sand%20Dunes.jpg

Make a fire. In such a desert that can easily be seen - and will lead the rescue team to us in a matter of hours.
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:28
I will ponder upon this.
While humans may be animals, I wasn't suggesting that.
The New Diabolicals
26-03-2006, 18:34
Shoot a nearby cactus with a gun and drink the water which comes from it :D

Good point, find a few cactae and there will be enough water for everyone. Although, I was imagining this to be in the Sahara Desert and I'm not sure if there are many there.

Another question is: why do you have the gun?
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:36
Another question is: why do you have the gun?

To shoot the other survivors. Duh :p
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:37
While humans may be animals, I wasn't suggesting that.

Well, I already shot all four of them anyway. Might as well use their natural resources.
Franberry
26-03-2006, 18:41
weres the poll?
Begoned
26-03-2006, 18:42
weres the poll?

I forgot to add one. :(

Is there any way to edit it to have a poll after you have submitted the topic?
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:43
Well, I already shot all four of them anyway. Might as well use their natural resources.
Now I know how Jesus feels. :(
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:44
Now I know how Jesus feels. :(

Screwed, because he could've easily beaten Bush in the elections?
Heavenly Sex
26-03-2006, 18:45
Suck out the blood of the other passengers.
Being a vampire has its advantages! :D
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:49
Screwed, because he could've easily beaten Bush in the elections?
No, Jesus would not be receiving some strangers penis. He also would not run for political office. He'd listen to Bodies Without Organs.
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 18:50
No, Jesus would not be receiving some strangers penis. He also would not run for political office. He'd listen to Bodies Without Organs.

He would?
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 18:55
He would?
No, more likely He'd listen to Psalms.
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 19:03
No, more likely He'd listen to Psalms.

How disappointing.
Notaxia
26-03-2006, 19:06
It's a desert, and it's not one of those deserts where stuff grows. It's a stereotypical "sand everywhere" desert:

http://www.meridianphotographicgallery.com/FW-GOBIDESERT/GOBIDESERTPHOTOS/G02%20Gobi%20Desert%20Sand%20Dunes.jpg

Gasp! Where did you get the picture of the inside of my head? Give it back!
Notaxia
26-03-2006, 19:07
I'd take the water and plant water seeds. With all that sunlight, they'd grow fast! But then again, I'd need to use some of the water to water the seeds... hmm...
Upper Botswavia
26-03-2006, 19:13
Use pieces of the plane to build a simple still to purify urine. Recycle religiously, while also conserving the 12 day supply as long as possible. Stay in the shade of the plane as much as possible during the day, and/or dig down under the sand where it will be cooler. Avoid strenous activity.

And hope for the best. If all that doesn't work and someone dies... recycle them.
Snow Eaters
26-03-2006, 19:29
First thing I do is become confused as to why I suddenly die after only 1 day without water.
Mariehamn
26-03-2006, 19:32
First thing I do is become confused as to why I suddenly die after only 1 day without water.
Its over our heads.
Ilie
26-03-2006, 19:41
What's the problem? Also, how do you know exactly how much water you have? Did you crashland with several bottles of water in the cargo hold?
The Nuke Testgrounds
26-03-2006, 19:44
Did you crashland with several bottles of water in the cargo hold?

Well .... yeah.
German Nightmare
26-03-2006, 19:54
You also happen to have a gun.
Begs the question - how did you get the gun aboard the plane in the first place?
Snow Eaters
26-03-2006, 20:02
Begs the question - how did you get the gun aboard the plane in the first place?


It does NOT beg the question, it RAISES the question.
Begoned
26-03-2006, 20:06
First thing I do is become confused as to why I suddenly die after only 1 day without water.

Because it's a hypothetic scenario, that's why. That's the way you got the gun on the plane, too.
German Nightmare
26-03-2006, 20:26
It does NOT beg the question, it RAISES the question.
Well, I raise to differ. http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-beg1.htm

Anyway, how the hell did the gun get aboard?