NationStates Jolt Archive


Debate is futile.

Blanco Azul
03-03-2006, 18:31
When it comes to forming opinions and making judgments on hot political issues, partisans of both parties don't let facts get in the way of their decision-making, according to a new Emory University study. The research sheds light on why staunch Democrats and Republicans can hear the same information, but walk away with opposite conclusions.

The investigators used functional neuroimaging (fMRI) to study a sample of committed Democrats and Republicans during the three months prior to the U.S. Presidential election of 2004. The Democrats and Republicans were given a reasoning task in which they had to evaluate threatening information about their own candidate. During the task, the subjects underwent fMRI to see what parts of their brain were active. What the researchers found was striking.

"We did not see any increased activation of the parts of the brain normally engaged during reasoning," says Drew Westen, director of clinical psychology at Emory who led the study. "What we saw instead was a network of emotion circuits lighting up, including circuits hypothesized to be involved in regulating emotion, and circuits known to be involved in resolving conflicts." Westen and his colleagues will present their findings at the Annual Conference of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology Jan. 28.

Once partisans had come to completely biased conclusions -- essentially finding ways to ignore information that could not be rationally discounted -- not only did circuits that mediate negative emotions like sadness and disgust turn off, but subjects got a blast of activation in circuits involved in reward -- similar to what addicts receive when they get their fix, Westen explains.

"None of the circuits involved in conscious reasoning were particularly engaged," says Westen. "Essentially, it appears as if partisans twirl the cognitive kaleidoscope until they get the conclusions they want, and then they get massively reinforced for it, with the elimination of negative emotional states and activation of positive ones."

Behavioral data showed a pattern of emotionally biased reasoning: partisans denied obvious contradictions for their own candidate that they had no difficulty detecting in the opposing candidate. Importantly, in both their behavioral and neural responses, Republicans and Democrats did not differ in the way they responded to contradictions for the neutral control targets, such as Hanks, but Democrats responded to Kerry as Republicans responded to Bush.

While reasoning about apparent contradictions for their own candidate, partisans showed activations throughout the orbital frontal cortex, indicating emotional processing and presumably emotion regulation strategies. There also were activations in areas of the brain associated with the experience of unpleasant emotions, the processing of emotion and conflict, and judgments of forgiveness and moral accountability.

Notably absent were any increases in activation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain most associated with reasoning (as well as conscious efforts to suppress emotion) The finding suggests that the emotion-driven processes that lead to biased judgments likely occur outside of awareness, and are distinct from normal reasoning processes when emotion is not so heavily engaged, says Westen.
Full Story:
http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2006-01/euhs-esl012406.php

So, in essence rational debate is futile. Instead we should just argue and make emotional appeals.
Eutrusca
03-03-2006, 18:33
... debate is futile ...
You will be assimilated.
Blanco Azul
03-03-2006, 18:34
You will be assimilated.
Yup, bandwagoning is more effective than reason.
Kzord
03-03-2006, 18:34
<a href="http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2006-01/euhs-esl012406.php">Full Story</a>

So, in essence rational debate is futile. Instead we should just argue and make emotional appeals.

Posting HTML is futile.
Blanco Azul
03-03-2006, 18:35
Posting HTML is futile.
How would I do the VB code?
Eutrusca
03-03-2006, 18:36
Yup, bandwagoning is more effective than reason.
We are Borg. We will do your thinking for you. Resistance is futile.
Tactical Grace
03-03-2006, 18:37
How would I do the VB code?
You don't. Type out a URL and it gets auto-linkified.
Tactical Grace
03-03-2006, 18:37
We are Borg. We will do your thinking for you. Resistance is futile.
We are diselxia of Borg. Futility is resistant. Your ass will be laminated.
Eutrusca
03-03-2006, 18:38
We are diselxia of Borg. Futility is resistant. Your ass will be laminated.
LOL! :D
Billus
03-03-2006, 18:39
I say political debates take place when the opponents are high. Worked for me.