NationStates Jolt Archive


The People of the Book

Anti-Social Darwinism
20-02-2006, 21:53
I would like to postulate this for debate: The people of the book (Jews, Christians and Moslems) are collectively responsible for 99% of the problems in the world today. Because each group thinks that they own the truth and are justified in shoving that "truth" down the throats of others, we will never know peace.
Kzord
20-02-2006, 21:54
What about the dictatorial governments in places like North Korea or China?
Deep Kimchi
20-02-2006, 21:56
Don't forget Communism. It is essentially a religion without a God.
Sarkhaan
20-02-2006, 21:57
Don't forget Communism. It is essentially a religion without a God.
nah, there is a god...its just called "the state" instead (okay, yes, I know actual communism doesnt, but the totalitarian communist states we have do)
H N Fiddlebottoms VIII
20-02-2006, 21:58
What about the dictatorial governments in places like North Korea or China?
Ruled by a Jewish conspiracy. All Asians are Communists, and all Communists are Jews, remember?
*bombs Asia*
ALLAH ACKBUSH!!
Deep Kimchi
20-02-2006, 21:59
nah, there is a god...its just called "the state" instead (okay, yes, I know actual communism doesnt, but the totalitarian communist states we have do)
Sometimes you get a "Dear Leader" like the North Koreans...
Stone Bridges
20-02-2006, 22:00
We'll know peace when we all get our own planets!
Solarea
20-02-2006, 22:01
Sometimes you get a "Dear Leader" like the North Koreans...

A lot of people got trampled in the crowd that gathered to see Comrade Stalin when he died. I think one or two hundred.
Anti-Social Darwinism
20-02-2006, 22:02
We'll know peace when we all get our own planets!


They'll have to be unpopulated. It'll be lonely. Peaceful, but lonely.
Snow Eaters
20-02-2006, 22:04
I would like to postulate this for debate: The people of the book (Jews, Christians and Moslems) are collectively responsible for 99% of the problems in the world today. Because each group thinks that they own the truth and are justified in shoving that "truth" down the throats of others, we will never know peace.


What is that you wish to debate?
Whether it is true or why it is true?

It's a ridiculous statement to begin with, since there are places in the world without any of those religions, yet, oddly enough they don't seem to have 1% of the problems.

Also, even if it were true, your why needs work. I've never known a Jew that tried to shove any Jewish truths on me or anyone else.
Stone Bridges
20-02-2006, 22:04
They'll have to be unpopulated. It'll be lonely. Peaceful, but lonely.

Eh we'll just export them all to a planet thats about to be swallowed by an exploding sun.
Deep Kimchi
20-02-2006, 22:05
They'll have to be unpopulated. It'll be lonely. Peaceful, but lonely.
Look, buster. There ain't enough room on this planet for both of us, so off you go...

I now claim this planet, in the name of ...
Kzord
20-02-2006, 22:08
There should be three planets: one for people I deem worthy of my presence, one for arseholes, and one for ordinary people.
Ifreann
20-02-2006, 22:11
Look, buster. There ain't enough room on this planet for both of us, so off you go...

I now claim this planet, in the name of Ifreann
:fluffle:
ShuHan
20-02-2006, 22:13
christianity is just a cult of judaism which in turn could be argued as a cult of islam. you all worship the same god just with slight variations ( islam names him allah the other two name him j'ah) oh plus the whole jesus thing
Anti-Social Darwinism
20-02-2006, 22:15
We'll know peace when we all get our own planets!

I think the Mormons already had this idea. In the celestial kingdomn all good Mormon men will become gods of their own planets. (I don't know what goes on in the other kingdoms)
Snow Eaters
20-02-2006, 22:24
christianity is just a cult of judaism which in turn could be argued as a cult of islam.

That's an odd perspective given that Islam is the youngest of the 3.
Why?
Luna-Tick
20-02-2006, 22:26
What is that you wish to debate?
Whether it is true or why it is true?

It's a ridiculous statement to begin with, since there are places in the world without any of those religions, yet, oddly enough they don't seem to have 1% of the problems.

Also, even if it were true, your why needs work. I've never known a Jew that tried to shove any Jewish truths on me or anyone else.

Stangely, those places in the world who don't have those religions still have to deal with the fallout from those religions - like imperialism, pollution, etc.

As for the Jews. The really did start the whole ball rolling. Or what do you call a religion that destroys a whol Canaanite city, men, women, children, dogs, because Jehovah told them to. Read the Old Testament - it's a testament to the future values of the People of the Book.
Snow Eaters
20-02-2006, 22:41
Stangely, those places in the world who don't have those religions still have to deal with the fallout from those religions - like imperialism, pollution, etc.


You actually believe that imperialism and pollution are unique to people that follow those 3 religions?

As for the Jews. The really did start the whole ball rolling. Or what do you call a religion that destroys a whol Canaanite city, men, women, children, dogs, because Jehovah told them to. Read the Old Testament - it's a testament to the future values of the People of the Book.

I've read it, thanks for the tip.
They didn't invent the concept though. I'm not even attempting to absolve any of those 3 religions for their participation in problems, but that's what they were/are, participants, with others participating right along. So, why would we lay problems that seem to be intrinsic to humans at the feet of these 3 religions?
Seosavists
20-02-2006, 23:05
here I thought poverty, war, pollution and disease where the causes of most of the worlds problems!


What a fool I've been! :p

*Goes back to shoving the "truth" down other people throats and causing the worlds problems*


WARNING THE ABOVE MAY CONATIN TRACES OF SARCASM!
ShuHan
20-02-2006, 23:06
oh well spotted snow meant it otyher way round but you get the picture they are all fundamentaly the same