NationStates Jolt Archive


A Plan for Oil Security in N. America

Lotus Puppy
12-11-2005, 02:28
A lot of oil in the US passes through the Gulf Coast. It's cheap and easy with its central location and many waterways. But as we learned painfully from the shocks of Katrina and Rita, the US oil supply is vulnerable, and it has global ramifications. However, if oil companies are willing to make the investment, I believe that the oil supply can have a backup plan if we can allow oil to enter through the St. Lawrence Seaway.
My idea is for a joint Canadian-US project to build an offshore oil terminal on or near the Gulf of St. Lawrence. From there, there will be two ways oil gets to market. The first is that it will be sent by pipeline to East Coast refineries, and used by local markets. The second is that small barges will take the oil down the river and to refineries in Canada, the Midwest, and possibly Upstate NY. Icebreakers would keep the St. Lawrence seaway ice-free in the winter.
Would this be expensive? The initial investment would be great, of course, but in the oil business, nothing's cheap. However, once refining and distribution is shifted more towards the North of the country, oil firms would have to rely less on the volatile South. How does that sound?
Marrakech II
12-11-2005, 02:41
snip...


Alternatives are always a good idea. Would also make for a shorter trip to the UK/Europe. For military purposes it would be smart also.
Lotus Puppy
12-11-2005, 03:15
Alternatives are always a good idea. Would also make for a shorter trip to the UK/Europe. For military purposes it would be smart also.
This would help compliment alternative energy. The Great Lakes region is one of the fastest growing wind power regions in the world.
Celtlund
12-11-2005, 03:27
Storms in the North Atlantic in the winter are not exactly ship friendly. Wouldn't it be easier to open up domestic oil drilling and quit relying on imported oil? We could even build nuclear power plants :eek: on the US-Canadian border as a joint venture to supply electricity to both countries.
Lotus Puppy
12-11-2005, 03:39
Storms in the North Atlantic in the winter are not exactly ship friendly. Wouldn't it be easier to open up domestic oil drilling and quit relying on imported oil? We could even build nuclear power plants :eek: on the US-Canadian border as a joint venture to supply electricity to both countries.
Those are all options. But domestic oil reserves go only so far, and that may even need its own refineries. Besides, I want to shift some production from the Gulf Coast, too.
BTW, large oil tankers would need 100ft swells to be damaged. Besides, once they are in the sheltered waters of the St. Lawrence, they would be fine. The real worry, IMO, should be the effect of lake effect snow on small barges.