NationStates Jolt Archive


Why is it still socially acceptable to smoke cigars but not cigarettes

BLARGistania
31-10-2005, 02:48
Just wondering.

The idea of a cigar is almost sonomous with high class and luxurious living. On the other hand smoking ciggs is seen as dirty and disgusting, even though the smell of the cigar lasts longer on clothing and breath and is worse.
Potaria
31-10-2005, 02:50
It's a class thing.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 02:51
Depends the type of cigarettes. Cigars are assoicated with high class exclusive men. Cigarettes are more gender and class mutual, until you get into specifics. For example, I smoke Peter Stuyvesant's and look all together cool. Where as a person smoking White Oxe rollies looks like an ex-con.
BLARGistania
31-10-2005, 02:54
Its just a wierd class distinction thing to me. I don't see the point of smoking cigars, except for victory on certain things - like graduation. Normall, I will smoke Camel Filters or Nat Sherman New York Cuts (very classy ciggs).

I just see the stigmata of "oooohhhhh ewwww. . .. smoker." When I light up a cigg but no one questions a cigar at all.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 02:56
Its just a wierd class distinction thing to me. I don't see the point of smoking cigars, except for victory on certain things - like graduation. Normall, I will smoke Camel Filters or Nat Sherman New York Cuts (very classy ciggs).

I just see the stigmata of "oooohhhhh ewwww. . .. smoker." When I light up a cigg but no one questions a cigar at all.
True. Considering cigars are dirtier (at least to me) and are effectively a dozen cigarettes strapped together.

I think it comes down to price and pop culture. Make anything delcared in popculture and charge a fortune for it and becomes glamourus in the eyes of the general public. Like caviar.
Potaria
31-10-2005, 02:57
I think it comes down to price and pop culture. Make anything delcared in popculture and charge a fortune for it and becomes glamourus in the eyes of the general public. Like caviar.

Blech. I can't see how anybody eats that shit.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 03:00
Blech. I can't see how anybody eats that shit.
I know. I have some cans sitting in my firdge if anyone wants to look pretentious and don't mine eating what bares a stunnign resemblence to cockroach turds in brine.
[NS]Simonist
31-10-2005, 03:02
In my circle, the most elitist thing you can smoke is a Lucky Strike. Or these really sweet clove cigs that are imported from France, but they don't count. Why is it that the "trashy" cigarettes are revered?
'Cause that's what the cool kids smoke. Suck down some cancer and don't freakin' argue.

Besides, cigars smell like butt. I can deal with kissing a cigarette smoker, and don't even think twice about the smell of pot....but when my boyfriend smokes cigars, he maintains a WIDE personal space, because he knows the consequences.

Edit: I smoke Turkish Gold or Royal (Camel) if not LS
Kreitzmoorland
31-10-2005, 03:07
Cigars come across as an indulgant, and very occasional pleasure, which isn't as frowned upon. If you're smoking cigarettes its seen as more of a permanant, habitual flaw in you charachter.
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 03:11
If you're smoking cigarettes its seen as more of a permanant, habitual flaw in you charachter.
Next thing you're gonna tell me is that beastiality is a character flaw and pedophilia is morally wrong.
















Why's everyone looking at me like that?
Zanato
31-10-2005, 03:13
Cigars come across as an indulgant, and very occasional pleasure, which isn't as frowned upon. If you're smoking cigarettes its seen as more of a permanant, habitual flaw in you charachter.

Exactly.
Republicstan
31-10-2005, 03:17
Cigars come across as an indulgant, and very occasional pleasure, which isn't as frowned upon. If you're smoking cigarettes its seen as more of a permanant, habitual flaw in you charachter.
Agree totally. You're smoking cigarettes cause you're addicted, and people shouldn't be addicted to stuff. On the other hand, you're smoking a cigar because you want to, but you don't have to.
I don't agree with it (addictions come in all shapes and sizes), but I think that's answers the original question.

Of course, it's also a class thing. Definitely.
Kreitzmoorland
31-10-2005, 03:25
Why's everyone looking at me like that?Because you are breathtakingly gorgeous, that's why.
[NS]Simonist
31-10-2005, 03:25
Agree totally. You're smoking cigarettes cause you're addicted, and people shouldn't be addicted to stuff. On the other hand, you're smoking a cigar because you want to, but you don't have to.
That's ridiculous. I do cocaine because I'm addicted. I blow more than my yearly income on booze, hookers and gambling because I'm addicted. I shot a man in the face for a hit of meth because I'm addicted. I smoke a cigarette because I've had a bad day and it's been four or five since I've last had one, and damn it I like the buzz.

Note: all but first and last sentences are abso-friggin-lutely fictionalized to prove a point. The rest (ie the first and last sentence) are the truth to sweeten the deal.
Kreitzmoorland
31-10-2005, 03:28
Simonist']That's ridiculous. I do cocaine because I'm addicted. I blow more than my yearly income on booze, hookers and gambling because I'm addicted. I shot a man in the face for a hit of meth because I'm addicted. I smoke a cigarette because I've had a bad day and it's been four or five since I've last had one, and damn it I like the buzz.

Note: all but first and last sentences are abso-friggin-lutely fictionalized to prove a point. The rest (ie the first and last sentence) are the truth to sweeten the deal.Be that as it may, that's what people are thinking when they frown at you and your cigarette. I Agree though, addctions happen in all shapes and sizes. Cigarettes are just a common and deadly example.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 03:29
Agree totally. You're smoking cigarettes cause you're addicted, and people shouldn't be addicted to stuff. On the other hand, you're smoking a cigar because you want to, but you don't have to.
I don't agree with it (addictions come in all shapes and sizes), but I think that's answers the original question.

Of course, it's also a class thing. Definitely.
I'm not addicted to cigarettes. I only smoke on weekends and only if I'm going out and drinking. So why is my occasional indulgence any different?
The Thames River
31-10-2005, 03:30
Because they're cool, duh!
[NS]Simonist
31-10-2005, 03:34
I'm not addicted to cigarettes. I only smoke on weekends and only if I'm going out and drinking. So why is my occasional indulgence any different?
I'm in a very similar boat (I don't drink, so it's only a few nights a week when I feel like smoking), though I usually smoke three to five a night (roughly a four to five hour period), and I can't think of very many people at all who don't still make comments about addiction.

I think it's that tidbit about cigarettes and cocaine being equally as hard to quit. Is that even true? 'Cause I've quit coke before and lived through it, I don't imagine cigarettes could be that hard.
Kreitzmoorland
31-10-2005, 03:35
I'm not addicted to cigarettes. I only smoke on weekends and only if I'm going out and drinking. So why is my occasional indulgence any different?
Clearly, its not. But people like to judge people operating off ready-to-apply stereotype. Thus, you are out of luck.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 03:38
Simonist']I'm in a very similar boat (I don't drink, so it's only a few nights a week when I feel like smoking), though I usually smoke three to five a night (roughly a four to five hour period), and I can't think of very many people at all who don't still make comments about addiction.

I think it's that tidbit about cigarettes and cocaine being equally as hard to quit. Is that even true? 'Cause I've quit coke before and lived through it, I don't imagine cigarettes could be that hard.
You know what? it's about time smoker's took a stand. We're one of the few groups it's ok to pick on. I almost always avoid smokeing around other people, unless they're smoking too. I don't smoke in places where it could harm others. So why should I have to put up with these waves of social self rightousness! We may not be a perfect lobby group, but neither is the SUV Owners Club and politicians learn not to mess with them.

Plus we can so get backing from the tobacco lobbies :D.
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 03:38
Because you are breathtakingly gorgeous, that's why.
haha :fluffle:

anyway, cigarettes are cheap and relatively similar across all levels of quality (atleast as far as the major brands go). Cigars, for good ones, are expensive and therefore seen as something reserved for important occasions (first child, wedding, graduation, etc.) It really just comes down to cigarettes being more wide spread
[NS]Simonist
31-10-2005, 03:42
You know what? it's about time smoker's took a stand. We're one of the few groups it's ok to pick on. I almost always avoid smokeing around other people, unless they're smoking too. I don't smoke in places where it could harm others. So why should I have to put up with these waves of social self rightousness! We may not be a perfect lobby group, but neither is the SUV Owners Club and politicians learn not to mess with them.

Plus we can so get backing from the tobacco lobbies :D.
Let's raise a big, smokey militia. Who's gonna see it coming? NOBODY! I mean, except everybody here. But I'll coerce them into shutting up if need be.

We'll take the legislators by storm! And with all the smoking some of the ranks will surely be engaging in, they won't even see it coming! It'll be like guerilla warfare, tobacco-style. Yeeeah.
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 03:48
Simonist']Let's raise a big, smokey militia. Who's gonna see it coming? NOBODY! I mean, except everybody here. But I'll coerce them into shutting up if need be.

We'll take the legislators by storm! And with all the smoking some of the ranks will surely be engaging in, they won't even see it coming! It'll be like guerilla warfare, tobacco-style. Yeeeah.
I can see the charge now...


"CHARGE"
*group runs for 20 seconds, slows down, stops, begins hacking, lights up*
*cloud of smoke blows over non-smokers virgin lungs, general hacking ensues*
[NS]Simonist
31-10-2005, 03:56
I can see the charge now...


"CHARGE"
*group runs for 20 seconds, slows down, stops, begins hacking, lights up*
*cloud of smoke blows over non-smokers virgin lungs, general hacking ensues*
Sounds like a victory to me.

I'm out, I've got somebody to meet. Crap, now I'm going to be wanting a cigarette all freakin' night.

You guys.....so bad for me....... :rolleyes:
H N Fiddlebottoms VIII
31-10-2005, 03:57
Simonist']Sounds like a victory to me.

I'm out, I've got somebody to meet. Crap, now I'm going to be wanting a cigarette all freakin' night.

You guys.....so bad for me....... :rolleyes:
NS is one of the leading causes of death among people whose cause of death was NS.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 03:58
I can see the charge now...


"CHARGE"
*group runs for 20 seconds, slows down, stops, begins hacking, lights up*
*cloud of smoke blows over non-smokers virgin lungs, general hacking ensues*
Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice. I was reading some stuff on smoking today and discover that apparently 50% of the smoke stays in your lungs. Seems reasonable. Many a time I've inhaled, started to do something else and when I got to exhale, nothing comes out...

Back to the point. We'd be a lean, mean fighting machine... except for stopping every five minutes for a smoke break...
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 04:06
Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice. I was reading some stuff on smoking today and discover that apparently 50% of the smoke stays in your lungs. Seems reasonable. Many a time I've inhaled, started to do something else and when I got to exhale, nothing comes out...

Back to the point. We'd be a lean, mean fighting machine... except for stopping every five minutes for a smoke break...
look at it this way...the smoke just kills the weak lung cells so the strong ones can thrive and reproduce. It's basic evolution;)

maybe we could charge reverse relay style? Instead of passing a baton on to the next runner, you pass a cig on to the guy who just finished running?
The Parthians
31-10-2005, 05:03
Blech. I can't see how anybody eats that shit.

I have some now and then. I've had Iranian Osetra caviar, and liked it very much, then again, I like salty things a lot. I've never had Beluga caviar before though, its just insanely expensive.

Now, about cigarettes, I notice that smoking extraordinarily expensive brands of cigarettes tends to make people seem less pissy about what your doing. I smoke Dunhills, and nobody seems to mind it.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 05:08
look at it this way...the smoke just kills the weak lung cells so the strong ones can thrive and reproduce. It's basic evolution;)

maybe we could charge reverse relay style? Instead of passing a baton on to the next runner, you pass a cig on to the guy who just finished running?
Works for me.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 05:11
I have some now and then. I've had Iranian Osetra caviar, and liked it very much, then again, I like salty things a lot. I've never had Beluga caviar before though, its just insanely expensive.

Now, about cigarettes, I notice that smoking extraordinarily expensive brands of cigarettes tends to make people seem less pissy about what your doing. I smoke Dunhills, and nobody seems to mind it.
I do! My roomate used to smoke those and stink out the house with the smell of burning tyres. Noone wants be reminded their inhaling tar.

Seriously though, it's worth the extra money to enjoy the improved "flavour".
Marrakech II
31-10-2005, 05:14
I smoke cigars and think that there is a difference from the cigarette smokers. It still is a status symbol in my eyes. Where I usually smoke is in a cigar lounge in a nice restuarant in the business section of the city. The reason there is becuase of the contacts that you meet. I took it up along with a business associate to make new business friends. It has worked out well and have learned alot about cigars and whats the good ones vs the cheapo's. When in a cigar lounge I find people are alot more friendly and open. I think its like sharing a hobby with others. Makes for good talk and sometimes opens the door for a business contact. So I continue to go down there 1-2 a week. By the way I do agree with the strong smell. But a good cigar wont destroy your clothes like a cheap one.
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 05:20
I smoke cigars and think that there is a difference from the cigarette smokers. It still is a status symbol in my eyes. Where I usually smoke is in a cigar lounge in a nice restuarant in the business section of the city. The reason there is becuase of the contacts that you meet. I took it up along with a business associate to make new business friends. It has worked out well and have learned alot about cigars and whats the good ones vs the cheapo's. When in a cigar lounge I find people are alot more friendly and open. I think its like sharing a hobby with others. Makes for good talk and sometimes opens the door for a business contact. So I continue to go down there 1-2 a week. By the way I do agree with the strong smell. But a good cigar wont destroy your clothes like a cheap one.
On the other hand it's amazing the fully random (and sometimes benificial) contacts you can make having a cigarette, anywhere.

To be quite honest, I've never smoked a cigar and don't plan to. My body has enough to deals with when It's run by a man with a lust for martinis and is both a member a minority share holder in the Wine Society of Australia (insane supply of wine and all).
Perkeleenmaa
31-10-2005, 05:33
Because cigarettes smell of shit, while cigars don't. Seriously, cigarettes are made out of tobacco that would never be used for cigars.

Also, mentally ill people smoke cigarettes, because they are more prone to addiction. Cigars aren't typically an addiction for anyone.

(Just Google it:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20051024/hl_nm/smoking_worsens_alcohol_related_mental_de_dc
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 05:41
I smoke cigars and think that there is a difference from the cigarette smokers. It still is a status symbol in my eyes. Where I usually smoke is in a cigar lounge in a nice restuarant in the business section of the city. The reason there is becuase of the contacts that you meet. I took it up along with a business associate to make new business friends. It has worked out well and have learned alot about cigars and whats the good ones vs the cheapo's. When in a cigar lounge I find people are alot more friendly and open. I think its like sharing a hobby with others. Makes for good talk and sometimes opens the door for a business contact. So I continue to go down there 1-2 a week. By the way I do agree with the strong smell. But a good cigar wont destroy your clothes like a cheap one.
I actually wrote a sociology paper on the social benefits of smoking in high school. No matter what you smoke, you will make friends. You share something already, so what is to stop you from talking? Plus, those 5-7 minute cig breaks are a great time to discuss anything. Esp. where I am, there is alot of potential that all of these random people could end up being important down the road
Rotovia-
31-10-2005, 05:42
Because cigarettes smell of shit, while cigars don't. Seriously, cigarettes are made out of tobacco that would never be used for cigars.

Also, mentally ill people smoke cigarettes, because they are more prone to addiction. Cigars aren't typically an addiction for anyone.

(Just Google it:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20051024/hl_nm/smoking_worsens_alcohol_related_mental_de_dc
1) I refuse to use Google as my source of information. No rational person would use it.
2) Cigars create more smoke, ergo, more smell. Cigarettes stink, cigars stink worse.
3) I don't know what budget cigarettes you're buying, but that's not the case. If you compare a cheap cigarette with an expencive cigar, of course there's a quality difference. The same as if you compared and expencive cigarette with a cheap cigar.
4) Uh huh. When you grow up and stop resorting to childess retorts you can come back and play with the big kids.
5) The only reason there are more people addicted to cigarettes then cigars is because more people smoke them more of the time. When was the last time you heard of someones smoking a box of cigars a day?
6) Not typically, however if consumed to the same level as cigarettes typically are by addicts then they stand a higher chance of causing addiction and may cause more damage then cigarettes of similar tar and nicotine ratios.
Vaitupu
31-10-2005, 05:48
Because cigarettes smell of shit, while cigars don't. Seriously, cigarettes are made out of tobacco that would never be used for cigars.

Also, mentally ill people smoke cigarettes, because they are more prone to addiction. Cigars aren't typically an addiction for anyone.

(Just Google it:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20051024/hl_nm/smoking_worsens_alcohol_related_mental_de_dc
ha...just look at Freud. The man constantly smoked cigars (the irony of him having a theory so full of phallic symbols is amazing). Nicotine is addictive no matter what. the way it is rolled means nothing. Most people smoke Marbs. That doesn't mean salems are less addictive, just less popular.
Callisdrun
31-10-2005, 06:30
They both smell horrible. I've met more people addicted to cigarettes than to cigars, though (I've never met anyone who smoked cigars without there being some special occasion). Of course, I know that some people do smoke cigars out of addiction, just not as many. Both trigger an allergic reaction for me (I don't mean like, just caughing, I mean like my throat gets enflamed to the point I can barely breath/talk and life just generally sucks), so unfortunately it often seems like a personal affront against me (even though, obviously it's not).

Also, there must be some big geographical different, because the only kind of friends you would make by smoking at my high school were people who were also into marijuana, cocaine, meth, etc. So when I see someone light up, I think "drug addict." From the circle I hung out with, you might have been ostracized for starting. It's like, irrationally a sign of weakness to me. I guess it's just the way I've been socialized. Of course, I do live in CA, which is the most anti-smoking part of the US. I really don't understand why anybody starts smoking anymore, we all know how bad it is for us. Whatever, people have a right to destroy their own bodies, as long as they're not harming me.

I don't know what all this about "nice cigarettes" is, they all smell the same to me.
Qxuvia
31-10-2005, 07:12
It all basically comes down to how smoking a cigar is protrayed in the media and, as someone mentioned earlier, pop culture. Smoking a cigar is still seen as a sort of status symbol. It's almost like we (men) are expected to at least be able to smoke a cigar, maybe it's a testament to our masculinity (I am purposely going to avoid the whole Clinton thing). I've been an athlete my whole life and because I know what smoking does to my body I have never been tempted to smoke cigarettes, cigars are another matter. I have managed to convince myself that even one cigarette would negatively affect my athletic performance, but a cigar doesn't "seem" as bad.

To me the real question is "what is the difference between someone who smokes a cigar and someone who smokes a pipe?" What I mean by that is what is the difference in the connotation. Personally I like the smell of pipe smoke, but that may be because every time I went to visit one of my uncles he had a pipe going. In the order of what I personally am more likely to smoke (if I was going to) would be a pipe, then a cigar, and if I had to a cigarette.
Delator
31-10-2005, 08:37
It's a class thing in my mind...and I think George Carlin summed it up quite well.

Haven't we had about enough of this cigar smoking shit in this country? When is this going to end? When is this shit going to go away? When are these fat, arrogant, overpaid, overfed, over privileged, overindulged white collar business criminal asshole cocksuckers gonna put out their cigars and move on to their next abomination? White pussy businessmen sucking on a big brown dick! That's all it is, that's all it ever was, a big brown dick. Sigmund Freud said sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. Oh yeah, well, sometimes it's a big brown dick! With a fat, arrogant, white collar business criminal asshole sucking on the wet end of it. But, hey, the news is not all bad for me, you want to know the good part? Cancer of the mouth! Good, fuck 'em, it makes me happy, it's an attractive disease, goes great with a CELL PHONE! So, light up, suspender man, and suck that smoke deep into your empty suit and blow it out your ass, you fuckin' cocksucker!

:p
Mooseica
31-10-2005, 08:47
Because cigars look cool - come on, d'you think sergeant Johnson (Halo) would be anywhere near as cool as he is if he smoked cigarettes?! Be serious :p ;)
Callisdrun
31-10-2005, 10:45
What's odd, is that I hate the smell of cigarettes while they're being smoked (obviously associate it with barely being able to breath due to an allergic reaction), I actually kinda like the way a car smells if cigarettes were smoked in it quite a while ago. I guess it reminds me of how the company trucks at my dad's old work smelled when i was a little kid.
Cannot think of a name
31-10-2005, 11:45
It's clear that a great many of you have never lit up a cigar around people before. Even the cigarette smokers wheel around and start going "Who fuckin' lit a cigar up?" Accepted my ass.

I smoke Schiemlpenicks which are the size of cigarettes and even the most desperate cigarette mooch will turn the little bastards down.

I've started to call cigars my 'don't bother me' sticks, becuase when I smoke them, I smoke alone.

Accepted. I'd have to take up camel spitting if they where...