NS Parliament Debate thread: Income tax
VOTE ON THE OTHER THREAD! IT'S HERE: http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=430969
Pure Metal
09-07-2005, 19:32
progressive tax = wealth redistribution = good imho.
so as an MP i voted yay :)
Crap. I forgot to make the vote count viewable. COuld you revote on my new thread, PM? Link coming for the new thread.
Pure Metal
09-07-2005, 19:36
Crap. I forgot to make the vote count viewable. COuld you revote on my new thread, PM? Link coming for the new thread.
no problem
http://forums.jolt.co.uk/showthread.php?t=430969 is the link to the new thread.
Subterranean_Mole_Men
09-07-2005, 19:38
theres no government like no government! Down with your taxes!
Everyone, VOTE ON THE OTHER ONE! I'm going to get the mods to lock this one.
Neo-Anarchists
09-07-2005, 19:42
Seeing as this thread no longer appears to be being used for official debate for MPs, may I butt in to ask a question?
Why is it that if your progressive-income-tax proposal gets voted down, it immediatly reverts to a flat income tax system? I don't believe we have an official income tax system as of yet, and I would think some people from the NSCLs might suppport the 'Fair Tax' idea with only taxes for consumption. It's not quite a binary system, so I can't understand why you are making it revert to another option as though it were one.
Seeing as this thread no longer appears to be being used for official debate for MPs, may I butt in to ask a question?
Why is it that if your progressive-income-tax proposal gets voted down, it immediatly reverts to a flat income tax system? I don't believe we have an official income tax system as of yet, and I would think some people from the NSCLs might suppport the 'Fair Tax' idea with only taxes for consumption. It's not quite a binary system, so I can't understand why you are making it revert to another option as though it were one.
Sure. I just think it's stupid when people vote against a proposal in the proposal stage because they disagree with it. We should still debate the issue; so I give some incentive for the people most likely to disagree. I'm welcome to comments and suggestions, however.