NationStates Jolt Archive


A bit of insight into why soldiers see themselves as "a band of brothers."

Eutrusca
20-05-2005, 16:02
NOTE: This article got to me ... big time.


Troops Back From Iraq Relate To Vets (http://www.military.com/NewsContent/0,13319,FL_relate_051905,00.html?ESRC=eb.nl)

Associated Press
May 19, 2005

MINNEAPOLIS - When Josh Krook came home from Iraq, he had to contend with a struggling marriage and was haunted by memories of people dying in a war zone.

To make it through, Krook turned to his father, Allen, who had gone through the same thing more than 35 years ago after serving in Army intelligence in Vietnam.

"You relate with someone else who's been through it, and you can cling together," said Josh, who served with an armored cavalry unit.

Many soldiers returning from Iraq are finding common ground with a father who served in Vietnam, say veterans officials and psychologists who work with returning soldiers. And that shared experience is helping them adjust to life after the war.

"You share something, so you're more at ease talking about stuff," said Dave Whaley, president of Ohio's chapter of Vietnam Veterans of America. Whaley was a Marine; his son, David, served two tours in Iraq and one in Afghanistan.

It's the post-Sept. 11 context of troops overseas that has made it easier for Vietnam veterans to open up, said Keith Armstrong, who teaches social work at the University of California in San Francisco and is co-writing a guidebook for returning soldiers.

"They're able to use that experience of war to really connect with their kids," he said.

The Krooks' relationship wasn't always close. Allen talks of breaking a lot of promises to his son. His son talks of a childhood made rough by his father's anger - something both of them now attribute to post-traumatic stress disorder.

The relationship began to improve in 2001, when Josh was finishing infantry training in Fort Benning, Georgia, right after the Sept. 11 attacks. With planes grounded, Allen - who suffers from chronic neck and back pain - boarded a bus and rode 26 hours to see his son graduate.

"That pretty much just ripped my heart right out of my chest when I saw that," Josh recalled. "He couldn't move for three days afterward, but he sure showed up."

When Josh came home after a year in Iraq, it was to a marriage that was already in trouble. The talks with his father became more frequent, and when it became clear the marriage couldn't last, he moved from Colorado to Minnesota and stayed with Allen and his wife.

Josh has some good memories of Iraq - hugs from children, for example. But he also saw things that still bother him, such as the last moments of a young girl who died when the car she was riding in failed to stop at an Army checkpoint. Josh was among the soldiers ordered to fire on the car.

His father listened to those stories. But Allen also let Josh in on some of his own painful memories, such as the day he called in an air strike to destroy an ammunition cache in a village. The strike went too far, Allen remembers.

"All that was left was a burning hole, bodies, women and children," Allen said. "They wiped out everything."

For the first time, Josh said, he understood why his father had a hard time after Vietnam.

Aimee Osborne and her father, Mark Adamski, are typical of family members drawn closer by military service. They say it started as soon as Osborne joined the Army.

Before she left for basic training, Osborne's father gave her a medal with the picture of St. George, the patron saint of soldiers. Osborne, who served in Kuwait after Sept. 11, still keeps the medal in a box along with pictures from Kuwait and her first pair of army boots.

When she finished basic training, her dad started telling her about his experiences in Vietnam. And one day, he showed her his boot box.

"He opened up this box of all these medals," she said. "It was looking at my dad in a whole new light. Now that I have my own box, I understand it even more."
Carnivorous Lickers
20-05-2005, 16:11
Memorial Day is right around the corner. Its a good time for the rest of us to appreciate things like this.
Verghastinsel
20-05-2005, 16:14
O, we take him from the city or the plough,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
And we drill him, and we dress him up so neat,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
We teach him to uphold his manly brow,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
And how to walk, and where to put his feet.
Ta-ran-ta-ran-ta-ra
It doesn't matter who he was before,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
Or what his parents favor'd for his name;
Ta-ran-ta-ra
Once he's pocketed the shilling,
And a uniform he's filling,
We'll call him Tommy Atkins, all the same.
O!
Tommy, Tommy Atkins,
You're a "good un," heart and hand;
You're a credit to your calling,
And to all your native land;
May your luck be never failing,
May your love be ever true!
God bless you, Tommy Atkins,
Here's your Country's love to you!

In time of peace he hears the bugle call
Ta-ran-ta-ra
And in Barracks, from "Revally" to "Lights Out!"
Ta-ran-ta-ra
If "Sentry go" and "Pipeclay" ever pall,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
There's always plenty more of work about.
Ta-ran-ta-ran-ta-ra
As happy as a school boy, and as gay;
Then back he goes to duty,
All for Country, Home and Beauty
And the noble sum of half a crown a day.
O!
Tommy, Tommy Atkins,
You're a good un, heart and hand;
You're a credit to your calling,
And to all your native land;
May your luck be never failing,
May your love be ever true!
God bless you, Tommy Atkins,
Here's your Country's love to you!

In wartime then, it's "Tommy to the Front!"
Ta-ran-ta-ra
And we ship him off, in "Troopers" to the fray,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
We sit at home while Tommy bears the brunt,
Ta-ran-ta-ra
A fighting for his country - and his pay.
Ta-ran-ta-ran-ta-ra
And weather he's on India's coral strand,
Or pouring out his blood in the Soudan,
To keep our flag a-flying,
He's a doing, and a dying,
Ev'ry inch of him a soldier and a man.
O!
Tommy, Tommy Atkins,
You're a "good un," heart and hand;
You're a credit to your calling,
And to all your native land;
May your luck be never failing,
May your love be ever true!
God bless you, Tommy Atkins,
Here's your Country's love to you!
Eutrusca
20-05-2005, 16:43
[ clip ]

And weather he's on India's coral strand,
Or pouring out his blood in the Soudan,
To keep our flag a-flying,
He's a doing, and a dying,
Ev'ry inch of him a soldier and a man.
O!
Tommy, Tommy Atkins,
You're a "good un," heart and hand;
You're a credit to your calling,
And to all your native land;
May your luck be never failing,
May your love be ever true!
God bless you, Tommy Atkins,
Here's your Country's love to you!
I like that.

And don't forget the verse ( at least I think it was from the same tune ) which resonates with a lot of Vietnam veterans:

For it's Tommy this and Tommy that,
and "Chuck 'im out, the brute!"
But it's "Savior of 'is Country"
When the guns begin to shoot.

I am overjoyed that the young soldiers coming home from Iraq don't have to endure what we did when we returned from the 'Nam.
Carnivorous Lickers
20-05-2005, 16:49
I am overjoyed that the young soldiers coming home from Iraq don't have to endure what we did when we returned from the 'Nam.


I'm trying to find out info on bases in NJ on returning troops. I have my son starting in cub scouts. After an idea from a previous thread you made, I was thinking it might be good for scouts and returning soldiers if we could organize and go in uniform to welcome them home.
I thought you might have an idea of where I could start. If not, I might just start calling the bases and see if they give out that info.

I guess soldiers expect some family and friends there on their return. Others may not have people there waiting for them. They could probably all use a pack of cub/boy scouts in uniform,with the US and BSA flags cheering and clapping. I also think its a good example for the scouts.l
Verghastinsel
20-05-2005, 17:00
For it's Tommy this and Tommy that,
and "Chuck 'im out, the brute!"
But it's "Savior of 'is Country"
When the guns begin to shoot.

No shit, Cap'n Horn. If the Royal Marines are due to be sent anywhere, pubs in Portsmouth put away the pint glasses bring out the plastic cups.
Matchopolis
20-05-2005, 17:16
go in uniform to welcome them home.
I thought you might have an idea of where I could start. If not, I might just start calling the bases and see if they give out that info.

1-888-859-0352, you'll have to run through a numeric rat maze of pushing numbers but they'll put you in touch with a local Family Assistance Center.

In Arkansas at least, the FAC is Naitonal Guard personnel who assist soldiers and FRGs (Family Readiness Group). FRGs are ran by the deployed soldier's wives. These are the folks to deal with. The higher up the chain of command you go the less cooperative they are. More worried about promotions and pencil pushing. Deal with a local unit and move up from there.

I'm assuming they'll have a similar structure to the Arkansas National Guard (2nd largest in the nation)
Texpunditistan
20-05-2005, 17:21
One thing I'll never understand are those that look at the very people who guarantee their freedom like vermin. :(
Carnivorous Lickers
20-05-2005, 17:38
One thing I'll never understand are those that look at the very people who guarantee their freedom like vermin. :(


Not me. If I disagree with a military action, its with the ones making the decisions and the policies at the top.
Not the man in the ground in the fray. They deserve our support and respect.
Carnivorous Lickers
20-05-2005, 17:39
1-888-859-0352, you'll have to run through a numeric rat maze of pushing numbers but they'll put you in touch with a local Family Assistance Center.

In Arkansas at least, the FAC is Naitonal Guard personnel who assist soldiers and FRGs (Family Readiness Group). FRGs are ran by the deployed soldier's wives. These are the folks to deal with. The higher up the chain of command you go the less cooperative they are. More worried about promotions and pencil pushing. Deal with a local unit and move up from there.

I'm assuming they'll have a similar structure to the Arkansas National Guard (2nd largest in the nation)


I'm going to give this a shot. New Jersey has many bases and I was hoping to simplify.
Thanks for the info !
Cordiality
20-05-2005, 17:51
About the "band of brothers" thing...

That's what always annoys me about seeing war movies with other people, the best example being the Lord of the Rings. When we see Aragorn and Legolas hug after a big battle, you practically have to wade through a sea of gay jokes to hear the dialogue.

What nobody seems to understand is those connections made by soldiers fighting is so much more than any friendships made at home or at school. If only all of us could find friendships that strong (though hopefully not to have to put our lives at risk to find it).
Carnivorous Lickers
20-05-2005, 17:54
About the "band of brothers" thing...

That's what always annoys me about seeing war movies with other people, the best example being the Lord of the Rings. When we see Aragorn and Legolas hug after a big battle, you practically have to wade through a sea of gay jokes to hear the dialogue.

What nobody seems to understand is those connections made by soldiers fighting is so much more than any friendships made at home or at school. If only all of us could find friendships that strong (though hopefully not to have to put our lives at risk to find it).


You appreciate a bond more when its forged under harsh adversity. Something a lot of us can take for granted as we dont spend a lot of time in real harm's way.
It doesnt have as much value to us because we can take it for granted.
Eutrusca
21-05-2005, 01:12
You appreciate a bond more when its forged under harsh adversity. Something a lot of us can take for granted as we dont spend a lot of time in real harm's way.
It doesnt have as much value to us because we can take it for granted.
You come to appreciate the little things: hot showers, hot meals, hot women ... um ... I mean clean sheets ... um ... that didn't come out quite right! Heh!
Syniks
21-05-2005, 01:25
It's a sobering thing to know that the guy next to you would likely die for you (in either the abstract "take one for the cause" or specifically "get down you fool" - gaak)

The Elephent is big and hairy. Once you've seen him up close nobody else but your compatriots (on both sides of the battle lines) can fully relate. :(
Falhaar
21-05-2005, 04:23
I'll never understand why those returning from nam' were treated so badly. They gave everything for their country, but when they returned all they got was a slap in the face. A deeply shameful event.

hot women ... um ... I mean clean sheets ... um ... that didn't come out quite right! Heh! You really are a dirty old man, aren't you? :p
Northern Fox
21-05-2005, 04:55
I am overjoyed that the young soldiers coming home from Iraq don't have to endure what we did when we returned from the 'Nam.

We children of Vietnam vets will never allow our armed forces to be stabbed in the back like that again.
Syniks
21-05-2005, 21:03
We children of Vietnam vets will never allow our armed forces to be stabbed in the back like that again.Sadly, there are probably as many, if not more, children of VietNam "protesters" as there are children of Vets. And those red-diaper babies DO treat current Vets every bit as badly as their Fathers were treated. Fortunately, they tend to hang out in identifiable groups at things like the WTO riots so they are fairly easy to avoid.