Episode III (Revenge of the Sith) poll
New Fubaria
20-05-2005, 09:40
What did you think of Episode III? Rank it, 1-10...
Cathenia
20-05-2005, 09:54
see the George Lucas thread for my explanations...
His Grace, etc etc, the Supreme Lord Chancellor of Cathenia
FairyTInkArisen
20-05-2005, 09:56
i'm going to see it in about 4 hours, i'm all excited
Kellarly
20-05-2005, 09:56
Well, i'm using ESB as a 10 and AOTC as a 1, so a 7 is not a bad score.
I'd give ANH an 8 probably, with ROTJ a 6 (militant teddy bears are wrong), and PM a 3 (mainly because of a double ended light sabre).
Keruvalia
20-05-2005, 10:24
Empire Strikes Back is actually still better.
I thought the movie was good. It tied up all the loose ends fairly well, if not in a bit of a rushed manner. It left some opening which were inconcenquential and could be well filled with fan-fic - though it'd be nice to have seen it in the movie. (Such as Grievous' background and details on his health) He just sorta comes out of nowhere...
It had no surprises in it, which would have pushed it's rating up to a nine or ten. Otherwize it deliveres everything I hoped for. Really really fast.