NationStates Jolt Archive


Something we can ALL get behind? Hope for African destitutes.

Eutrusca
27-04-2005, 17:40
NOTE: When you read this, please note that the necessary increase in AID funding has not yet been passed by the US Congress. May I humbly suggest that if you are a US citizen, you drop a note to your representative and another to your Senator and let them know you support this? Africa is humanity's original home and it breaks my heart that there are malnourished children whose only desire is to be able to attend 8th grade.


In Ethiopian Hills, Five Years to Create Something Out of Nothing (http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/27/opinion/27wed3.html?th&emc=th)
By HELENE COOPER

Published: April 27, 2005
ORARO, Ethiopia

For seventh graders here, class is held under the shade of a ficus tree because there are only six rooms in the village school. On a recent day, students sat and listened as a visitor from Addis Ababa, hundreds of miles away, asked which of them expected to go on to the eighth grade.

Twenty-nine hands went up - the entire class. Their Addis Ababa visitor, Hailay Teklehaimanot, looked at them with frustration. "How will you get there?" he asked gently.

Seventh grade is the highest class offered at the Koraro Primary School, and the nearest eighth grade is nearly 20 miles away. That's a good six-hour walk because the village has no car.

For a while, no one answered, and most students looked down at the dirt. Then Kahsay Gebneslasie, 14, spoke up. "We heard maybe they might open an eighth grade here," he said. The school's principal, Gidey Haileslassie, was standing nearby and gave a barely perceptible shake of his head.

A year ago, Koraro villagers scraped together the money to pay for a seventh-grade teacher, then put the class under the tree since there was no room in the school. Paying for an eighth grade is beyond the village's means at this point.

If the rich world is actually going to deliver on its promise to halve global poverty by 2015, then it has to start somewhere. It may as well be here in this village, deep in Ethiopia's northern Tigray Province, where food is scarce and water even scarcer, but 14-year-olds still cling to the hope that they will be able to go to eighth grade.

Koraro, which was recently chosen to be a United Nations test case in the fight against poverty, is where the rubber meets the road. It is one of the poorest and most isolated villages in the poorest and most isolated province of one of the world's poorest and most isolated countries.

If poverty can be whipped here in Koraro, it can be whipped anywhere.

The place has nothing. Some 5,000 villagers live their short lives - life expectancy here is about 40 years - out here in the red dust and rocks, eking out a subsistence living. There is no topsoil and the land is eroded, so farming is an uphill battle.

Half of Koraro's children - and there are some 1,500 of them - are underweight and malnourished. Only 34 families out of 1,500 have access to clean drinking water. The rest walk four miles round-trip to haul buckets of dirty water, and the water-borne illnesses they carry, into their homes for drinking, cooking and washing up. There's no electricity, no doctor, no industry, no market, nothing.

But Koraro is drop-dead beautiful, with jagged red cliffs that look like skyscrapers towering over wide expanses of drylands. The centuries-old churches, most carved deep into the cliffs, testify to how long villagers have been here, in one of the world's oldest cultures. Indeed, while it would appear easy for Koraro residents to decamp to a more hospitable site closer to the regional capital, Mekele, most of the villagers refuse to leave.

Zafu Tsegabu, who is 18, watched with her 2-month-old daughter as her husband moved to a bigger town about 25 miles away, and refused to join him. "This is my home here," she said simply.

As soon as the people here were told that they had been singled out to be one of the United Nations' test villages on poverty reduction, they organized themselves into committees to figure out how to get the job done. There's a water committee and a school committee, an energy committee and a health committee. The United Nations plan, spearheaded by the economist Jeffrey Sachs, calls for the participation of foreign donors, the Ethiopian government and the village of Koraro.

Since Koraro has no money to offer, the villagers are supplying the labor and local materials. On a recent day, some 1,500 villagers - just about every able-bodied man, woman and teenager, were hacking rocks out of the earth and moving them into piles. The rocks will eventually be transferred to the site where they hope to build a village clinic.

Mr. Sachs's proposal allots Koraro $250,000 a year for the next five years to turn itself around. The government of Ethiopia will kick in technical expertise, including help to build a proper road to link Koraro with the rest of the world.

The list of what the money will buy is as basic as it comes: five metal doors for the clinic, one diesel generator to provide occasional electricity to the village, three windows for the school, one grinding mill so villagers can turn their cereal crops into food, and a village truck that could serve a variety of needs.

But there is no eighth grade on the list. There are too many other basic necessities that have to come first.

Still, Koraro, if it works, can become a model for scaling up this type of development for villagers all over Africa - provided the rich world makes good on its promise to donate 0.7 percent of G.D.P. to foreign aid. The Group of 7 summit meeting in July, when leaders of rich countries will get together in Scotland, will probably provide critical answers to that question.

Britain, Germany and France have all provided timetables to ramp up their aid money to 0.7 percent by 2015. But the United States has yet to do the same.

In the meantime, the people in Koraro continue to hope and make plans. In the twilight of her life at age 30, Kidan Hagos, a mother of seven, leaned against a shady tree as she took a break from hacking rocks for the new clinic. Her youngest child, Haregeweini, 9 months old, was propped against her, nursing. Mrs. Hagos, for her part, took a moment to dream big.

Asked what she would ask for if she could have anything in the world, she spent a good three minutes carefully considering her answer.

"A food market close by," she said, "and a well with good water."
Ecopoeia
27-04-2005, 17:54
Thanks, Eutrusca. Is the bill likely to pass? I heard not...
Damascue
27-04-2005, 18:03
I also heard that it wasn't likely to pass. Which angers me. I've already written to my congressmen a few times; I'm definitely going to be writing for this.

Its things like this that strengthen my resolve to join the Peace Corps after graduation from University.
Neo-Fars
27-04-2005, 18:03
This is one reason I love genetically engineered crops. They can help out lands like Ethiopia with poor farming land because the new strains can survive in those conditions and significantly increase wields.

So, in addition to aid, we should try to see to the advancement of agricultural science.
Ecopoeia
27-04-2005, 18:08
This is one reason I love genetically engineered crops. They can help out lands like Ethiopia with poor farming land because the new strains can survive in those conditions and significantly increase wields.

So, in addition to aid, we should try to see to the advancement of agricultural science.
In one sense, I agree. Of course, the ownership of the patents, etc are another issue...
Neo-Fars
27-04-2005, 18:21
Patents aren't an issue. The people like Norman Borlaug behind Modern Agriculture don't patent their plants. Infact, he tried having seeds of new kinds of wheat sent to Kenya, but Greenpeace came along and convinced the Kenyan government it was poison.

So really, stupidity is the only real obstacle.
Eutrusca
27-04-2005, 19:39
I also heard that it wasn't likely to pass. Which angers me. I've already written to my congressmen a few times; I'm definitely going to be writing for this.

Its things like this that strengthen my resolve to join the Peace Corps after graduation from University.
A noble goal, and one at which I'm sure you'll do well. I salute you! :)
Eutrusca
27-04-2005, 19:42
This is one reason I love genetically engineered crops. They can help out lands like Ethiopia with poor farming land because the new strains can survive in those conditions and significantly increase wields.

So, in addition to aid, we should try to see to the advancement of agricultural science.
I agree, as long as there are adequate safeguards. Genetic material is constantly being exchanged between species in the open environment. This can be a major problem when bio-engineered plants and animals can exchange genetic material freely.
Eutrusca
27-04-2005, 19:44
Patents aren't an issue. The people like Norman Borlaug behind Modern Agriculture don't patent their plants. Infact, he tried having seeds of new kinds of wheat sent to Kenya, but Greenpeace came along and convinced the Kenyan government it was poison.

So really, stupidity is the only real obstacle.
I agree that calling it "poison" was a bit extreme, but we do not yet have a good grip on the ultimate impact of bio-engineered plants on the environment at large. I urge caution.
Bolol
27-04-2005, 19:46
My friends and I in Amnesty International work heavily in increasing aid in Africa, we're also currently working on the Darfur situation.

Unfortunately...it sometimes seems that no one care about suffering and genocide anymore...
Tiauha
27-04-2005, 19:50
I agree that calling it "poison" was a bit extreme, but we do not yet have a good grip on the ultimate impact of bio-engineered plants on the environment at large. I urge caution.

Of course, but don't we eat some GM foods without evewn realising, I'll find my bio notes, my bag is somewhere in my room...
Tiauha
27-04-2005, 19:53
Did it seem stupid to you when they refused donations for the tsumami appeals, cos they had already got enough? Do they not have any common sense to put it to work somewhere else? Would most people complain if it was going to other needy people albeit in a different place? And those that would, well...
Domici
27-04-2005, 20:10
This is one reason I love genetically engineered crops. They can help out lands like Ethiopia with poor farming land because the new strains can survive in those conditions and significantly increase wields.

So, in addition to aid, we should try to see to the advancement of agricultural science.

The problem is that many GM crops are considered proprietory, i.e. the company that made the seed keeps a license on it the way Microsoft does on what is most likely your operating system (sorry if you're a Linux user, I'm just playing the odds). If we do introduce GM crops to lands like these we're likely to demand payment from every crop yield they ever produce. That's not terribly helpful a poverty stricken country.

They'd do better by setting up a grid of trees to help maintain a topsoil layer so that natural crops can be grown.
Domici
27-04-2005, 20:13
I agree that calling it "poison" was a bit extreme, but we do not yet have a good grip on the ultimate impact of bio-engineered plants on the environment at large. I urge caution.

I don't know if it's extreme. We've got strains of corn that grow their own pesticide. That's fine if you're only growing it to brew ethanol, but if you're planning to eat it I'd be careful.

Sure they say that the pesticide is harmless to humans, but that's what they said about D.D.T. When you're dealing with anything that has the suffix "-icide" on it you'd do well to assume that it's poison until you learn otherwise.
Ecopoeia
28-04-2005, 01:44
Did it seem stupid to you when they refused donations for the tsumami appeals, cos they had already got enough? Do they not have any common sense to put it to work somewhere else? Would most people complain if it was going to other needy people albeit in a different place? And those that would, well...
Who exactly is 'they'? I think the point was that the donations were turned down in order that they may be used elsewhere.

Bolol, you work for Amnesty?
Tiauha
14-05-2005, 23:27
Who exactly is 'they'? I think the point was that the donations were turned down in order that they may be used elsewhere.


'they' are the charities that were collecting tsunami donations. Soz, I should have made that clearer. But the thing is that people won't do sensible things like that, they'll just keep their money. The donations were turned down cos they already had enough to do what they could do with the amount of people/resources they had.
Perezuela
14-05-2005, 23:53
Last time I went home, we took a drive out to the mideast (Somalia, Kenya, Ethiopia) and it really effected me. When you look at what the first world has and what they COULD give to the third world, it's only a meager crum. The world is trying but without effort. The duty is up to the whole world although the US has to step up. If they insist on playing the role of enforcing justice in the world, the AIDS epidemic should be the top priority.
Bitchkitten
14-05-2005, 23:58
I write my represetatives so often they don't even bother sending me form letters anymore. They just wish I'd go away.
Cannot think of a name
15-05-2005, 00:17
I have two concerns in this. The first is that there is work to be done at home (http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Third_World_US/SI_Kozol_StLouis.html). While I do not believe that it's a one or the other proposition, they are similar and what do we say when we are willing to help people in sililar situations but not those in our own backyard. More complex than I'm painting it, but still...

The other is what strings (http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=20050530&s=kaplan) are going to be attached? I would hate to help people out only to feed them to a new lion.

Do not mistake this for being dismissive about giving aid, but from my sig, "Like an old junk pusher once told me; Watch whose money you take." (W.S. Burroughs). And it's because 'beggars can't be choosers' that we have to be the diligant ones to make sure 'helping' isn't 'buying.'
Incenjucarania
15-05-2005, 00:34
I am now a fan of Brazil. Taking a stand against stupidity. Gotta love it.