NationStates Jolt Archive

Who's better? Who or Trek?

Who! :D

To be fair though, you can't really say as there have been 4 seasons of Enterprise and they've only shown the first episode of the new Doctor Who.

To be fair though, you can't really say as there have been 4 seasons of Enterprise and they've only shown the first episode of the new Doctor Who.

Yeh.. but still... *votes Who* :p

Who! :D

To be fair though, you can't really say as there have been 4 seasons of Enterprise and they've only shown the first episode of the new Doctor Who.

Did i only put the new who? I meant all - Vote man( or woman....or transgendered species from blogsville)!!

Both, why limit myself?

Both, why limit myself?

You're with me brother!! ;) that was my fave answer too.

Did i only put the new who? I meant all - Vote man( or woman....or transgendered species from blogsville)!!
Ah!
In which case, Who everytime baby! It's got to have done something right, 42 years and counting! :D

I'd had very, very high hopes for Enterprise. However, as with EVERY Star Trek since TOS, they keep going with scripts that are mediocre at best and banal at the worst.

I'd *much* rather watch Blake's 7 than Enterprise. The show is nearly 30 years old, and the special effects are woeful. It's alien landscapes are a tour of every rock quarry in England. But the stories are actually *stories*.

The problem with Enterprise, DS:9, Voyager and even a third to a half of TNG is that the fan fiction was better than the actual episodes. :(

Ah!
In which case, Who everytime baby! It's got to have done something right, 42 years and counting! :D

Aye, my sentiments and counting. Incidently...42 is the answer to the ultimate question of life the universe and everything - did you know that? ;)

Aye, my sentiments and counting. Incidently...42 is the answer to the ultimate question of life the universe and everything - did you know that? ;)
As it happens I did, so yay! :D

(everyones gotta love Hitchhikers!)

I'd *much* rather watch Blake's 7 than Enterprise. The show is nearly 30 years old, and the special effects are woeful. It's alien landscapes are a tour of every rock quarry in England. But the stories are actually *stories*. (

Now, now, let us not forget the brief tours of industrial facilities that are stangely reminiscent of late seventies/early eighties educational science programs for schools...

As it happens I did, so yay! :D

(everyones gotta love Hitchhikers!)

Wow, a hitchhikers fan!! So what was it you thought of the new series of who again?

Enterprise is the worst Star Trek. Hardly fair.

Enterprise is the worst Star Trek. Hardly fair.

All star treks then?

I voted for both but only because new Dr Who isn't showing here yet. I don't mind Enterprise, but the show isn't as good as I had hoped. I just hope the Dr is as Brilliant as ever...

Now, now, let us not forget the brief tours of industrial facilities that are stangely reminiscent of late seventies/early eighties educational science programs for schools...

Granted, but even *that* didn't harm the stories. Even the repeat use of scenes with different lighting. Even the fact that the Liberator was just three microphones taped together and moved on fishing line... the *show* is still better than Voyager!

The scripts of that one show were better than all the 'Treks in the last 10 years combined.

The first three seasons of Babylon 5 are better than all of Doctor Who, and better than most of Star Trek (well, I did like the old Star Trek).

The first three seasons of Babylon 5 are better than all of Doctor Who, and better than most of Star Trek (well, I did like the old Star Trek).

I'm sorry to disagree - erm no i'm not - Babylon 5 was the, and I mean *THE* worst sci-fi program ever to come across to Britain - even Flash Gordon, Blake 7 and James Bond made better sci-fi's than that crap!!