NationStates Jolt Archive


Yay segregation?

Anarchic Conceptions
07-03-2005, 22:20
Source (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/4326007.stm)

Cannot help but find this slightly ironic.

Although, this I find odd

Mr Phillips suggested some black boys were hampered by a lack of self-esteem and positive role models, as well as an attitude that being clever was not cool.

Meh, I grew up with being clever not being cool and with low self-esteem. So I still learned, largely kept quite and myself to myself and created a slightly pessimistic, cynical world view. Maybe I'm being flippant, but I still don't get how segregated schools will help counter the low self-esteem and poor role models (admittedly, it is a subjective term) as well as the 'cool to be stupid' attitude.

Admittedly, I kinda see the point about the lack of positive role models for black school children, all they have is the guy off the Halifax ads.

This may be a difficult question. But I am sure NS general forum can find an acceptable solution that will achieve consensus and go on to become the world standard.

So, what do you think.
Neo-Anarchists
07-03-2005, 22:23
This may be a difficult question. But I am sure NS general forum can find an acceptable solution that will achieve consensus and go on to become the world standard.
Because everybody know we're all rational and polite here on NS, and concede when we've been proved wrong!
;)
Talondar
07-03-2005, 22:57
Mr. Phillips needs to get away from the idea that self-esteem is needed to learn. I've seen studies show that male, black students in the US have the highest self-esteem of all the student groups, and they're still performing horribly academically.
Anarchic Conceptions
07-03-2005, 22:59
Mr. Phillips needs to get away from the idea that self-esteem is needed to learn. I've seen studies show that male, black students in the US have the highest self-esteem of all the student groups, and they're still performing horribly academically.

Interesting.