Quickly now: Disobedience in mythology, folklore, and faerie tales
Fnordish Infamy
15-01-2005, 12:05
I need examples of disobedience in blah blah see post title. I've already got a few collected (Adam & Eve, Jack & the Beanstalk, Pandora, Prometheus, Orpheus, etc.), and I would love if someone could suggest some less obvious ones, or ones that I may have overlooked.
Goed Twee
15-01-2005, 13:03
Dian Cecht and Miach, to some degree.
Bodies Without Organs
15-01-2005, 13:08
I need examples of disobedience in blah blah see post title. I've already got a few collected (Adam & Eve, Jack & the Beanstalk, Pandora, Prometheus, Orpheus, etc.), and I would love if someone could suggest some less obvious ones, or ones that I may have overlooked.
The big obvious one is the devil saying NON SERVIAM to God, which I guess qualifies as mythology as it is a story that has grown in parallel to the Bible, despite not being in it.
Lacadaemon
15-01-2005, 13:18
There is an obscure greek myth -mentioned in the Illiad i think - where the gods rebel against Zeus. Thetis brings one of the hecatonchires to defend him and quash the rebellion. (Possibly Im sketchy on the details).
Slender Goddess
15-01-2005, 13:19
the boy who cried wolf
peter cottentail
Fnordish Infamy
15-01-2005, 13:53
Thank you, thank you.
The Elder Malaclypse
15-01-2005, 14:00
The big obvious one is the devil saying NON SERVIAM to God, which I guess qualifies as mythology as it is a story that has grown in parallel to the Bible, despite not being in it.
Ah yes, classic stuff
Patra Caesar
15-01-2005, 14:43
"Don't talk to strangers little red riding hood."
It's amazing how this one has morphed, it used to be that there was no wood cutter to chop up the wolf and it was used as a moral lesson to teach young ladies not to trust men (because male + female = sex, which is BAD BAD BAD!). ;)
Showers and Food
15-01-2005, 14:51
there are so many
there's an old arabic story my mom used to tell me of noel and how she went with her friends to pick fruit and her mother told her to be back home or go to her friends house before the sun goes down and how she didn't listen and stayed out that night to play in the woods and how the big bad wolf came and got her and told her she was a bad girl for not listening to her mother and he would give her one chance. the true story was that she lost that chance and was eaten by the wolf. but my mom always changed it and made it a happy ending.
i can't think of any more right now, but there are a lot!
good luck
Super-power
15-01-2005, 14:58
Prometheus giving fire to man - he disobeyed the Greek Gods
Honey Badgers
15-01-2005, 15:19
All the stories in Arabian Nights where the boy is supposed NOT to go in through one particular door... which of course he does... This happens to princesses in Western fairytales, too, Bluebeard's wife, for instance. But she was saved by her disobedience, unlike the others.
And little Red Ridinghood didn't stay on the path, either.
Fnordish Infamy
15-01-2005, 15:20
Why do you want to know?
I'm writing a paper.
Armed Bookworms
15-01-2005, 15:51
There's always the Lilith mythos. Hmmm, 's all I've got.
Nationalist Valhalla
15-01-2005, 16:08
the prodigal son is a rather different take on disobedience
Nationalist Valhalla
15-01-2005, 16:13
There's always the Lilith mythos. Hmmm, 's all I've got.
well the fall of satan would be in the same judeo christian vein, lots wife getting turned into a pillar of salt too.
Pantylvania
15-01-2005, 19:33
Loki, but murder is a bit more extreme than mere disobedience