NationStates Jolt Archive


Best Woman Singer in a Rock Band/Group...

Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 03:39
There are so many women singers that I adore out there, such as Amy Lee of Evanescence, and even classics such as Pat Benatar (I'm 19, but I love the 80's). I love Avril Lavigne as well, but most don't consider her rock.

There are a lot of people out there who don't believe that women can truly sing 'rock' music, so I wanna get everyone elses' opinions.
Sdaeriji
20-12-2004, 03:42
Janis Joplin, Joan Jett, Grace Slick, Pat Benatar, Kim Gordon....
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 03:46
Janis Joplin, Joan Jett, Grace Slick, Pat Benatar, Kim Gordon....

All amazing choices. :p
Sarzonia
20-12-2004, 03:47
Stevie Nicks, Christine McVie, Ann Wilson, Sheryl Crow
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 03:53
Stevie Nicks, Christine McVie, Ann Wilson, Sheryl Crow

I wouldn't expect anyone else to get here first and mention Stevie Nicks. :)
You rock Sarzonia, hardcore.
Sarzonia
20-12-2004, 03:55
Well, I couldn't disappoint, could I? ;)

Thanks... you do too! :D

Oh, and before I forget :fluffle:
Angry Fruit Salad
20-12-2004, 03:59
Well, you've already mentioned our beloved Amy Lee, so I've got nothin.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 04:03
Well, you've already mentioned our beloved Amy Lee, so I've got nothin.


In my opinion, she is definitely one of the few people who can pull off the opera-like voice, mixed with the 'goth-like' rock music. Lacuna Coil also deserves an honorable mention.
New Kanteletar
20-12-2004, 04:04
Anneke Van Giersbergen from The Gathering, and Heather Findlay from Mostly Autumn
Legburnjuice
20-12-2004, 04:07
I like Stevie Nicks, Chrissy Hynde, Fiona Apple, Jasmine Rodgers, Poe... I could think of more, had I the gumption.
Saipea
20-12-2004, 04:08
Madddonnnnnaaaaa!
Dostanuot Loj
20-12-2004, 04:08
Shirley Manson from Garbage, I have to say.
Ogiek
20-12-2004, 04:09
No votes for Tori?
Sdaeriji
20-12-2004, 04:11
In my opinion, she is definitely one of the few people who can pull off the opera-like voice, mixed with the 'goth-like' rock music. Lacuna Coil also deserves an honorable mention.

Cristina Scabbia.
Whatever thou wants
20-12-2004, 04:21
I'm not good with names...

Stevie Nicks
Everyone in Heart
The singer from 10000 Maniacs
There are many more that come to mind but I can't for the life of me remember what thier names are...

It's amazing that I can even remember all my passwords without tatooing them onto myself... lol
Dakini
20-12-2004, 04:30
PJ Harvey, Ani Difranco (well, she's folk, but still kicks ass), Janis Joplin, Beth Gibbons (portishead), Janis Ian...

also, the girl who does the little bits in cradle of filth songs... i find it a nice contrast to the rest of their music.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 04:35
Shirley Manson from Garbage, I have to say.


Garbage is one of my all-time favorite bands. I can't believe I forgot to mention them in my first post....

*goes and cries in the corner*
Stroudiztan
20-12-2004, 04:37
Natalie Merchant.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 04:37
PJ Harvey, Ani Difranco (well, she's folk, but still kicks ass), Janis Joplin, Beth Gibbons (portishead), Janis Ian...

also, the girl who does the little bits in cradle of filth songs... i find it a nice contrast to the rest of their music.


My brother listens to Cradle of Filth (unfortunately), but when I heard that girl start singing, I was shocked. She has a great voice.


OH! And the lead singer of One True Thing, Melanie Wills. I doubt anyone in America has heard of them. I believe it is a British Band, if not, someone correct me. Only reason I say that is because the cd isnt available here, and my friend in the military mailed it to me from Britain.
Malkyer
20-12-2004, 04:37
Tarja Turunmen-Nightwish
Cristina Scabbia-Lacuna Coil

I know I didn't get the Nightwish chick's last name right.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 04:39
Cristina Scabbia.


Yes, thats it. Thanks :p Definitely a great singer.
UpwardThrust
20-12-2004, 04:41
Shirley Manson from Garbage, I have to say.
I second that

Adding Gwen Stifani (sp)


Morgan Lee Lander from kittie
Snowboarding Maniacs
20-12-2004, 04:41
Amy Lee, of course. I love her. And the singer from Otep (I don't know her name) is incredible. And moving to ska, I love the singer from Save Ferris too. And moving more toward punk/pop, my absolute favorite, Gwen Stefani. SHe's my #1 favorite celebrity. Totally hot, amazing voice, great personality from everything I've seen, and one hell of a sense of style.

Edit: You beat me to Gwen!!! :mad:
Zion-Y
20-12-2004, 04:43
Stevie Nicks, Joan Jett, Sarah McLaughlin
UpwardThrust
20-12-2004, 04:49
Amy Lee, of course. I love her. And the singer from Otep (I don't know her name) is incredible. And moving to ska, I love the singer from Save Ferris too. And moving more toward punk/pop, my absolute favorite, Gwen Stefani. SHe's my #1 favorite celebrity. Totally hot, amazing voice, great personality from everything I've seen, and one hell of a sense of style.

Edit: You beat me to Gwen!!! :mad:
;) lol
Incertonia
20-12-2004, 05:17
I'm not good with names...

Stevie Nicks
Everyone in Heart Ann and Nancy Wilson
The singer from 10000 Maniacs Natalie Merchant
There are many more that come to mind but I can't for the life of me remember what thier names are...

It's amazing that I can even remember all my passwords without tatooing them onto myself... lol
They're not exactly rock, but I'll add Koko Taylor, Melissa Etheridge, Aretha, and if there's a prettier voice out there than Alison Krauss, I'll eat my hat.
Vittos Ordination
20-12-2004, 05:27
Neko Case
Sarzonia
20-12-2004, 06:14
They're not exactly rock, but I'll add Koko Taylor, Melissa Etheridge, Aretha, and if there's a prettier voice out there than Alison Krauss, I'll eat my hat.Melissa Etheridge is rock IMO.

Aretha has an awesome set of pipes. She's one of the greatest singers period.

Alison Krauss does have a great voice.
BLARGistania
20-12-2004, 06:22
The female vocalist of Arcade Fire, Rilo Kiley, and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs (all seperate women), oh and also On! Air! Library!
Slender Goddess
20-12-2004, 06:32
Diana Krall
Dianna Washington
Phebe Snow
Sarah Vaughn
Billy Holiday
Janis Joplin
Slender Goddess
20-12-2004, 06:34
Diana Krall
Dianna Washington
Phebe Snow
Sarah Vaughn
Billy Holiday
Janis Joplin

OOPS! I didn't read the rock part until too late.

Oh well, they are my favorite singers, though.
Ernst_Rohm
20-12-2004, 06:40
shiralee from chalice(au) who use to be in a region with me, before everyone but me died of inactivity.
Goed Twee
20-12-2004, 08:10
Ayumi Hamasaki :D
Lascivious Maximus
20-12-2004, 08:34
hmm, assuming we can indeed list solo artists, and Ive included some non-rock artists just because I think in a vocalist thread they need to be stated!!...

in no particular order:

Susan Tedeschi
Gwen Stefani
Tori Amos
Stevie Nicks
Monique Powell
Etta James
Lee Ann Womack
Lauryn Hill
Sheryl Crow
Freddie Mercury (well, he was a queen! had to put that in for laughs, he does rule though)
and of course, I couldnt live with myself if I didn't mention Edith Piaf -what a voice!!

just some great voices off the top of my head, rock or not. :)
Chaosmanglemaimdeathia
20-12-2004, 08:40
Tarja, from Nightwish.

If you disagree, you're simply incorrect.
Chaosmanglemaimdeathia
20-12-2004, 08:41
Tarja Turunmen-Nightwish
Cristina Scabbia-Lacuna Coil

I know I didn't get the Nightwish chick's last name right.

You're great.

P.S. it's Turunen by the way.
Druthulhu
20-12-2004, 08:42
Annie Danielewski!!!
Violets and Kitties
20-12-2004, 09:18
Katherine Blake (of Miranda Sex Garden)

others:
Jessicka Fodera, Tina Root, Kate Bush (does she count as rock?), Tori Amos
Ge-Ren
20-12-2004, 09:36
Ronnie Spector didn't get a mention, but I'd throw her in. Did anyone mention Grace Slick?

I'd also add Dionne Farris. Her work after she left Arrested Development is rock. That and it rocks. :)


Ge-Ren
Roach Cliffs
20-12-2004, 18:06
Sal,

From Artificial Joy Club. Too bad they broke up... :(
Sarzonia
20-12-2004, 19:42
Ronnie Spector didn't get a mention, but I'd throw her in. Did anyone mention Grace Slick?Sdaeriji did.
Siljhouettes
20-12-2004, 20:03
There are so many women singers that I adore out there, such as Amy Lee of Evanescence, and even classics such as Pat Benatar (I'm 19, but I love the 80's).
I think that the best is Anneke van Geirsbergen, who is the singer in The Gathering. If you like Evanescence, check out Lacuna Coil. They're like Evanecence, but better and more original.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 20:04
The female vocalist of Arcade Fire, Rilo Kiley, and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs (all seperate women), oh and also On! Air! Library!


The Yeah Yeah Yeah's are amazing...

One more band, not sure if anyone has heard of 'em, but Auf Der Maur. The singer is one of the best singers I've every heard in my life.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 20:07
I couldnt live with myself if I didn't mention Edith Piaf -what a voice!!


I heard her music in my French class, and I was amazed.... La Vie En Rose, I think that's the title, is a really good song. I'm in America too, so her work definitely isn't noticed... :(
Lascivious Maximus
20-12-2004, 20:10
I heard her music in my French class, and I was amazed.... La Vie En Rose, I think that's the title, is a really good song. I'm in America too, so her work definitely isn't noticed... :(
Yeah, her voice is amazing, Susan Tedeschi too, but shes a blues/rock singer.

Really good power vocals though, Im surprised no one else has mentioned her, since she even fits in to the rock category. :confused:
Legless Pirates
20-12-2004, 20:11
The chick from Walls of Jericho (hardcorepunk).
Korarchaeota
20-12-2004, 20:22
Yeah, her voice is amazing, Susan Tedeschi too, but shes a blues/rock singer.

Really good power vocals though, Im surprised no one else has mentioned her, since she even fits in to the rock category. :confused:


you beat me to it. she's amazing. she can go from gritty to beautiful in a matter of seconds. i'd give my right arm to sing like that.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 21:50
The chick from Walls of Jericho (hardcorepunk).

Is it the screamo kind of hardcore punk?
Legless Pirates
20-12-2004, 21:53
Is it the screamo kind of hardcore punk?
screamo?
Not sure what you mean, but I think so.
Lascivious Maximus
20-12-2004, 21:56
you beat me to it. she's amazing. she can go from gritty to beautiful in a matter of seconds. i'd give my right arm to sing like that.

Im so surprised that she hasnt made it bigger, she has so much talent!!

Youre one of the first people that even knows who she is I think, so I congratulate your excellent taste. :)
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 22:06
screamo?
Not sure what you mean, but I think so.

Lots of screaming, but very emotional lyrics.
Legless Pirates
20-12-2004, 22:06
Lots of screaming, but very emotional lyrics.
you mean EMO?
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 22:08
you mean EMO?


Yes, but its coined differently around here. Screamo is the new term :p .
Legless Pirates
20-12-2004, 22:11
Yes, but its coined differently around here. Screamo is the new term :p .
:D

Okay. Lots of screaming. Not sure about the lyrics being overly dramatic. But if you talk to a fan and ask if it's emo, you'll get in a fight.
Euroslavia
20-12-2004, 22:15
:D

Okay. Lots of screaming. Not sure about the lyrics being overly dramatic. But if you talk to a fan and ask if it's emo, you'll get in a fight.

Sweet. I'll remember that, hehe. Thanks for the pointers. I'll definitely have to download some of their stuff. I love emo/screamo.
Cajema
20-12-2004, 23:22
There are so many women singers that I adore out there, such as Amy Lee of Evanescence, and even classics such as Pat Benatar (I'm 19, but I love the 80's). I love Avril Lavigne as well, but most don't consider her rock.

There are a lot of people out there who don't believe that women can truly sing 'rock' music, so I wanna get everyone elses' opinions.


Best Female Rock Singer? That's Easy, Ann Wilson from "HEART" :D
Personal responsibilit
20-12-2004, 23:23
I'd have to say Joan Jet and Lita Ford, though Anne Wilson deserves honorable mention...
Legless Pirates
20-12-2004, 23:26
Best Female Rock Singer? That's Easy, Ann Wilson from "HEART" :D
She's great