NationStates Jolt Archive


Killing Thy Neighbor: Hindu-Muslim India

Ogiek
30-11-2004, 02:35
Religious fundamentalism - whether Christian anti-abortion fanatics killing doctors and nurses, or Muslim terrorists blowing up buildings, or Hindu mobs rapping and burning women and children, or the Jewish Gush Emunim stealing land from West Bank Palestinians - may be the gravest threat to world peace and stability today.

Nowhere is that threat more eminent than in India. Although India has more Muslims than any nation in the world, they make up only 15% of the population. In the past few decades India has seen a rise of Hindu-Fascist philosophy that claims only Hindus are true Indians.

Killing Thy Neighbor
Hindus and Muslims go on the worst murder spree in a decade. Is secular India a fast-dying dream?

By ANTHONY SPAETH

When Afsana, an 18-year-old Muslim living on the outskirts of the Gujarati capital of Ahmadabad, heard last Wednesday that a Muslim mob had torched a train, the Sabarmati Express, at Godhra, she was appalled—and very, very frightened. She knew that revenge would be nigh. Her neighborhood, Naroda, is largely Hindu. On the day after the Godhra killings, local Hindu leaders gathered a crowd of 2,000 residents and gave them simple instructions: Muslims had to be destroyed. When part of the mob reached Afsana's house, she fled with her five-year-old brother to a Hindu neighbor's house. From the neighbor's roof, Afsana saw the mob pull her parents from their home, douse them in gasoline and set them alight. Her four sisters were stripped, raped and killed. Along the lanes, other Muslim houses were burning….

http://www.time.com/time/asia/features/india_ayodhya/cover.html

What is really frightening is that India and Pakistan, two countries at risk of slipping into the hands of fundamentalist religious fanatics, have nuclear weapons.
Colodia
30-11-2004, 02:40
My Uncle (by law) seriously is in top power in the Indian Congress. Just thought it'd be a nice thing to add.
Ogiek
30-11-2004, 02:43
My Uncle (by law) seriously is in top power in the Indian Congress. Just thought it'd be a nice thing to add.

Do you have any insights on the rise of fundamentalism in India?
New Foxxinnia
30-11-2004, 02:46
Don't ask. He never has anything insightful to say.
Colodia
30-11-2004, 02:46
Do you have any insights on the rise of fundamentalism in India?
You mean other than the fact that India is going down a slippery slope toward doom and it'll be too late to stop it once the U.S. takes note? Nah.
Colodia
30-11-2004, 02:47
Don't ask. He never has anything insightful to say.
How insightful....ly hurtful...:(
Dempublicents
30-11-2004, 02:47
I find it interesting that you, regardless of having been presented with other evidence, act like this is a one-sided conflict.

Fundamentalists on *both* sides have committed atrocities against peaceful followers of the other religion. *Both* sides are equally wrong in doing so.
Ogiek
30-11-2004, 04:04
I find it interesting that you, regardless of having been presented with other evidence, act like this is a one-sided conflict.

Fundamentalists on *both* sides have committed atrocities against peaceful followers of the other religion. *Both* sides are equally wrong in doing so.

Call me a cynic, but I don't believe you really do find it interesting.

Of course every story has multiple points of view. I am chosing to look at a nation of over 800 million Hindus and 125 million Muslims, in possession of nuclear weapons, with one of its most powerful political parties (until recently the ruling party) a fundamentalist religious party, with ties to hate groups that claim that only Hindus are true Indians entitled to rights and protections as Indians.

Imagine, not a Christian political party, but rather a radical, extreme Chrsitian party coming to power in the U.S. with the avowed philosophy that only Christians are true Americans. Would that not merit discussion?

I think the disturbing rise of Hindu fundamentalism is a topic worthy of debate.

(by the way, did you even bother to read the article?)
Dempublicents
30-11-2004, 17:27
Call me a cynic, but I don't believe you really do find it interesting.

Of course every story has multiple points of view. I am chosing to look at a nation of over 800 million Hindus and 125 million Muslims, in possession of nuclear weapons, with one of its most powerful political parties (until recently the ruling party) a fundamentalist religious party, with ties to hate groups that claim that only Hindus are true Indians entitled to rights and protections as Indians.

Imagine, not a Christian political party, but rather a radical, extreme Chrsitian party coming to power in the U.S. with the avowed philosophy that only Christians are true Americans. Would that not merit discussion?

I think the disturbing rise of Hindu fundamentalism is a topic worthy of debate.

(by the way, did you even bother to read the article?)

Of course it merits discussion. But, much like many people in the US when referring to fundamentalists of the Christian or Muslim variety, your phrasing suggests that (a) Most or even all Hindus are acting this way and (b) it is a one-sided conflict. Both are untrue.