NationStates Jolt Archive


The Rock Ultimate Band

Scudderfux
24-11-2004, 21:24
If i had to create an ultimate band it would be composed of the following:

Lead Vocalist: the late Joe Strummer (The Clash)
Lead Guitar + Backup Vocals: Dan Hawkins (The Darkness)
Rhythm Guitar: Daron Malakian (system of a down)
Bass Guitar: Roger Glover (Deep Purple)
Synths: Nobuo Uematsu (Final Fantasy Composer)
Drums: Miachel Lee (Thin Lizzy)
Joey P
24-11-2004, 21:28
vocals: Marilyn Manson
lead guitar: Steve Vai
rythm guitar: James Hetfield
synth: Trent Reznor
bass: Les Claypool
drums: Ringo Starr (why not)
Scudderfux
24-11-2004, 21:33
Ringo Starr? he sucks lol :p
ProMonkians
24-11-2004, 21:33
Vocals: Morrisey (Morriset, The Smiths)
Lead Guitar: James Dean Bradfield (Manic Street Preachers)
Bass: Manni (The Stone Roses, Primal Scream)
Drums: Keith Moon (The Who)
Keyboards: Mackenzereck. SP? (The Doors)

Probably sound like shite together mind you.
Scudderfux
24-11-2004, 21:34
Probably sound like shite together mind you.
kinda clash of genres
New Obbhlia
24-11-2004, 21:41
Lead vocals: John Marriot (Small Faces)
Lead guitar: Dave Edmunds (Love Sculpture (YES HE HAS MOSTLY DONE ROCKABILLY, but listen to the song Sabre Dance and you will agree))
Bass: Hmmm, I don't know...
Drums: Keith Moon (the Who)
Synth: Ray Manzarek (the Doors)
Hammond organ: That guy from Iron Butterfly, whatever his name is...
Siljhouettes
24-11-2004, 21:41
Lead Vocalist: Annake Van Giersbergen (The Gathering)
Lead Guitar: The Edge (U2)
Rhythm Guitar: Billy Corgan (formerly Smashing Pumpkins)
Bass Guitar: Cliff Burton (late, Metallica)
Drums: Terry Bozzio (formerly Frank Zappa) or Jimmy Chamberlin (formerly Smashing Pumpkins)
Dobbs Town
24-11-2004, 21:42
If i had to create an ultimate band it would be composed of the following:

Lead Vocalist: the late Joe Strummer (The Clash)
Lead Guitar + Backup Vocals: Dan Hawkins (The Darkness)
Rhythm Guitar: Daron Malakian (system of a down)
Bass Guitar: Roger Glover (Deep Purple)
Synths: Nobuo Uematsu (Final Fantasy Composer)
Drums: Miachel Lee (Thin Lizzy)

The problem as I see it is that Joe would always be missing his cues, what with being, uhh dead and all.
Joey P
24-11-2004, 21:43
Yeah, I didn't know we could use dead people!
Scudderfux
24-11-2004, 21:43
The problem as I see it is that Joe would always be missing his cues, what with being, uhh dead and all.
lol yeah but this is an imaginary band...plus Joe Strummer is immortal everyone knows that lol
Dobbs Town
24-11-2004, 21:49
Oh well in that case...

Joey Ramone (vocals)

Johnny Ramone (guitar)

Dee Dee Ramone (bass)

Keith Moon (Drums)

Synths? We don't need no stinkin' synths!
New Obbhlia
24-11-2004, 21:52
Synths? We don't need no stinkin' synths!
Of course we do, and lots of 'em (although I may consider having Manzarek on piano if that is the option)!
Stroudiztan
24-11-2004, 22:04
Oh well in that case...

Joey Ramone (vocals)

Johnny Ramone (guitar)

Dee Dee Ramone (bass)

Keith Moon (Drums)

Synths? We don't need no stinkin' synths!

Great, we'll call them the Ramoons.
Chiva
24-11-2004, 22:05
Drums: keith moon
Bass: Flea
Lead Guitar: Jimmy page or eric clapton
rhythm guitar: me or daron malakion
vocals: tim armstrong
Von Witzleben
24-11-2004, 22:09
Take That. And New Kids on the Block.
Stroudiztan
24-11-2004, 22:15
Vocals by Freddy Mercury
Guitars by Joe Satriani
(upright) Bass by Jesse Flack (of Jim's Big Ego)
keyboards by Chick Corea (of Return to Forever)
Bass by les Claypool
Drums by Brain
SuperGroovedom
24-11-2004, 22:25
Vocals: G G Allen

Okay, so he's technically dead, but christ, just think of the misadventure.

Guitar: Varg Vikernes

A crazy, murdering, pagan racist? Theres bound to be all kinds of hilariousness afoot with Varg running about.

Rythm Guitar: Charles Manson

A crazy, murdering, hippie racist? I hope Charlie can still play.

Bass: Nick Oliveri

Would definately add to the bad craziness needed for the model rockband. Got kicked out of the Dwarves for being too intense. The Dwarves.

Drums: Phil Collins

Would probably die a swift death if forced to associate with these loons, doing the world a great service.

As you can see, I picked most of my guys more so that I could be entertained by all the brain-dead, pyscopathic stuff they'd get involved in. We need someone to top Motley Crue, and I think these freaks could pull it off.
Cassopia
24-11-2004, 22:31
Vocals: Ronnie James Dio (Black Sabbath, Dio).
Guitars: Slash (Velvet Revolver, Guns n' Roses).
R. Guitar: Geezer Butler (Black Sabbath) (I don't care if he was lead guitar).
Bass: Lemmy (Motorhead).
Drums: Riggs (White Zombie).
Scudderfux
24-11-2004, 22:48
Vocals: G G Allen

Okay, so he's technically dead, but christ, just think of the misadventure.

Guitar: Varg Vikernes

A crazy, murdering, pagan racist? Theres bound to be all kinds of hilariousness afoot with Varg running about.

Rythm Guitar: Charles Manson

A crazy, murdering, hippie racist? I hope Charlie can still play.

Bass: Nick Oliveri

Would definately add to the bad craziness needed for the model rockband. Got kicked out of the Dwarves for being too intense. The Dwarves.

Drums: Phil Collins

Would probably die a swift death if forced to associate with these loons, doing the world a great service.

As you can see, I picked most of my guys more so that I could be entertained by all the brain-dead, pyscopathic stuff they'd get involved in. We need someone to top Motley Crue, and I think these freaks could pull it off.

i heard motley crew ordered a pizza by inserting the talkin-end of the phone into a groupie's vagina. That may be just a legend but it wouldn't suprise me if it was true
Bodies Without Organs
24-11-2004, 23:00
Oh well in that case...
...
Keith Moon (Drums)


Keith Ramone, surely? Why break 30 years of tradition now?
Vittos Ordination
24-11-2004, 23:05
Jesus, no one mentioned Dave Grohl on drums? He is definitely the best going today!

As long as we can use dead people also:

Vocalist: Robert Plant
Rhythm: Marc Bolan (T-Rex) He writes the songs, Plant just sings 'em
Lead: Jimi Hendrix, his lead over Bolan's rhythm would be amazing
Bassist: Take your pick, with Bolan there wouldn't need to be a good one.
Drums: John Bonham/Dave Grohl Bonham for shows, Grohl for recording

Now have Rick Rubin help Bolan produce this and you have the greatest album ever.
NuMetal
24-11-2004, 23:13
R. Guitar: Geezer Butler (Black Sabbath) (I don't care if he was lead guitar).



He was bass.....
Bodies Without Organs
24-11-2004, 23:39
As long as we can use dead people also:

Vocalist: Robert Plant
Rhythm: Marc Bolan (T-Rex) He writes the songs, Plant just sings 'em
Lead: Jimi Hendrix, his lead over Bolan's rhythm would be amazing
Bassist: Take your pick, with Bolan there wouldn't need to be a good one.
Drums: John Bonham/Dave Grohl Bonham for shows, Grohl for recording

Now have Rick Rubin help Bolan produce this and you have the greatest album ever.

Hey, you could just go for Hendrix (b+g), Bonham (d) and Bonn Scott (v). You could call them the Vomitsuckers.
Tellenthion
24-11-2004, 23:44
Ok, here goes:

Vocals: Robert Plant
Guitar: Hendrix
Drums: Neil Peart
Bass: Victor Wooten

I doubt they could play together well, but who knows.
Vittos Ordination
24-11-2004, 23:46
Hey, you could just go for Hendrix (b+g), Bonham (d) and Bonn Scott (v). You could call them the Vomitsuckers.

The grin on my face belies my horror at such a comment.

God you sick. :p
Nowakanopolis
24-11-2004, 23:51
Best rock band......

Base:pavement :sniper:
Top layer:gravel :sniper:
Vittos Ordination
24-11-2004, 23:57
Ok, here goes:

Vocals: Robert Plant
Guitar: Hendrix
Drums: Neil Peart
Bass: Victor Wooten

I doubt they could play together well, but who knows.

Wooten is a terrific choice even though he wouldn't fit with those guys.

How about this band:

Vocals: Beck
Rhythm: John Frusciante
Lead: Jeff Beck
Bass: Victor Wooten
Drums: Benjamin Weikel (Modest Mouse)

These guys could make some pretty groovy shit over Wooten's bass and Beck's samples and psych lyrics.
Joey P
25-11-2004, 00:02
Vocals: Ronnie James Dio (Black Sabbath, Dio).
Guitars: Slash (Velvet Revolver, Guns n' Roses).
R. Guitar: Geezer Butler (Black Sabbath) (I don't care if he was lead guitar).
Bass: Lemmy (Motorhead).
Drums: Riggs (White Zombie).
Geezer was actually bass. Tony Iomi (sp?) was lead guitar.
Bodies Without Organs
25-11-2004, 00:12
The grin on my face belies my horror at such a comment.

God you sick. :p

I was actually working on a suicide band, but couldn't find a drummer that enough people would recognise...

On reflection, though, the Hendrix/Bonham/Scott combo would fucking rock.
Vittos Ordination
25-11-2004, 00:16
I was actually working on a suicide band, but couldn't find a drummer that enough people would recognise...

On reflection, though, the Hendrix/Bonham/Scott combo would fucking rock.

Indeed it would.
Rasputin the Thief
25-11-2004, 00:26
pfff!
I can't imagine Lemmy and Cobain playing together with Damon Albarn... but I love the 3 bands (motorhead, nirvana and blur). There is no such thing as an "ultimate rock band"!
Vittos Ordination
25-11-2004, 00:30
pfff!
I can't imagine Lemmy and Cobain playing together with Damon Albarn... but I love the 3 bands (motorhead, nirvana and blur). There is no such thing as an "ultimate rock band"!

Albarn and Cobain were about as self-important as any musicians of the 90's. They would clash mercilessly. Lemmy would hate them both.
Great Overlord Hickman
25-11-2004, 00:35
Guitar - David Gilmour
Bass - Roger Waters
Drums - Nick Mason
Keyboards, synth n stuff - Richard Wright

...Why change the perfect formula? :rolleyes:
Bodies Without Organs
25-11-2004, 00:43
Guitar - David Gilmour
Bass - Roger Waters
Drums - Nick Mason
Keyboards, synth n stuff - Richard Wright

...Why change the perfect formula? :rolleyes:

Possibly because you know it is going to end in tears with them sueing each other?
Joey P
25-11-2004, 00:50
From my buddy Brandon at the other store
lead guitar Jimmi Hendrix
rythm guitar Ritchie Havens
drums Ginger Baker
bass Geddy Lee
vocals Steve Winwood (from traffic)
Keyboards Bruce Hornsby
Indiru
25-11-2004, 00:52
Vocals: Robert Dalton (The Who) OR James Mercer (The Shins)
Lead Guitar: Jimmy Page
Bass: Les Claypool (most well known? Primus?)
Drums: John Bonham (Zeppelin)

BEAT THAT
Bodies Without Organs
25-11-2004, 00:55
Vocals: Robert Dalton (The Who)

BEAT THAT

Roger Daltrey, perhaps?
Indiru
25-11-2004, 00:57
Woah that was weird...I put the name of the kid who sits next to me in math class instead of roger daltrey...TYPO GUYS!
Siljhouettes
25-11-2004, 01:00
Vocals by Freddy Mercury
Guitars by Joe Satriani
(upright) Bass by Jesse Flack (of Jim's Big Ego)
keyboards by Chick Corea (of Return to Forever)
Bass by les Claypool
Drums by Brain
Virtuosos!
Scudderfux
25-11-2004, 01:01
ah but what do u guys think of the rock-star lifestyle...the sex, drugs, fame, big cars, big houses. I mean look at the ammount of rock legends who've died simply because they've snorted too much coke. So what would you do with the rock-star lifestyle, would you use your power for good.. or would you collapse in on yourself in a cloud of cocain and boobs?
Joey P
25-11-2004, 01:02
ah but what do u guys think of the rock-star lifestyle...the sex, drugs, fame, big cars, big houses. I mean look at the ammount of rock legends who've died simply because they've snorted too much coke. So what would you do with the rock-star lifestyle, would you use your power for good.. or would you collapse in on yourself in a cloud of cocain and boobs?
cocaine and boobs.
Indiru
25-11-2004, 01:10
ah but what do u guys think of the rock-star lifestyle...the sex, drugs, fame, big cars, big houses. I mean look at the ammount of rock legends who've died simply because they've snorted too much coke. So what would you do with the rock-star lifestyle, would you use your power for good.. or would you collapse in on yourself in a cloud of cocain and boobs?

Tough choice...

I think I'd use it for the greater good, but that doesn't restrict me from plenty of male strippers.
Vittos Ordination
25-11-2004, 01:17
Cocaine and boobs for sure. Why else be a rockstar?

Now my superpowers, those I use for good. (the cocaine and boobs is just a fringe benefit.
Scudderfux
25-11-2004, 01:53
true but would you really like to end up like ozzy. Sure he's a rock legend but the guy can barely string a sentence together. I think that if you do too much drugs then your bits will stop working and then you won't be able to have sex. i mean that must really suck
Bodies Without Organs
25-11-2004, 01:59
Sure he's a rock legend but the guy can barely string a sentence together.

Bad example: he has always been that way.
Scudderfux
25-11-2004, 02:06
Bad example: he has always been that way.

He has not! If you compare his speech when he was singing War Pigs to when he was singing Gets Me through you'll hear the difference. In war pigs his voice is so clear but on his newer solo stuff like Gets me Through he sounds all muffled and out of tune. It's definitely the drugs that did it. i'm not against soft drugs, i take a few my self occasionally but i could never touch cocain, heroin or any other hard drug
Johnistan
25-11-2004, 22:50
Fuck you guys

Lead Singer: Freddy Mercury
Lead Guitar: Eddie Van Halen
Rythm Guitar/back up vocals: Kurt Cobain
Bass Guitar: Flea
Drums: John Bonham

Thats a whole lotta song writing potential. But I don't think Kurt would get along with the rest of the band, he being too punk and the other's being too mainstream.
Bodies Without Organs
26-11-2004, 02:57
He has not! If you compare his speech when he was singing War Pigs to when he was singing Gets Me through you'll hear the difference. In war pigs his voice is so clear but on his newer solo stuff like Gets me Through he sounds all muffled and out of tune. It's definitely the drugs that did it. i'm not against soft drugs, i take a few my self occasionally but i could never touch cocain, heroin or any other hard drug

I'll allow that his singing voice may have suffered over the years, but his speaking voice remains much the same mumbled troglyditic brummie drawl that it always was.
Bobbers
26-11-2004, 03:25
Kay guys here it is
Vocals: Bono (U2)
Lead Guitar: Jeff Beck
Rhythm Guitar: Keith Richards (The Rolling Stones)
Bass: Geddy Lee (Rush)
Drums: Keith Moon (The Who) or Neil Peart (Rush), Charlie Watts is great too (The Rolling Stones)

That would be the greatest