NationStates Jolt Archive


Something different to debate?

Daistallia 2104
22-10-2004, 16:52
Too often the same debate topics are re-hashed here repeatedly (the weekly US draft debate being a recent example).

What are some good debate topics that aren't seen often here?

I looked here (http://www.debatabase.org/alphaindex.asp) and found a few suggestions:
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
Should blood sports be banned?
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Should NATO be disbanded?
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?

Please add some suggestions.
Preebles
22-10-2004, 16:55
Hmmm... How about

Is stem cell research ethical? Is it still ethical if the embryos are cloned?
Is euthanasia (passive or active) ever ethical?

All I can think of are these med-student type ones. :p
Chess Squares
22-10-2004, 16:57
ooh ooh should some one who works 8 hours a day 6 days a week make 10 times more than some one else who works 8 hours a day 6 days a week in a different job
Torching Witches
22-10-2004, 16:59
Should quiz contestants be briefed with potential questions to make the programme more interesting?

Should we see more ethnic minorities in Lego?

Can children's TV ever surpass the heady days of Postman Pat or Jamie and His Magic Torch?
DeaconDave
22-10-2004, 17:02
ooh ooh should some one who works 8 hours a day 6 days a week make 10 times more than some one else who works 8 hours a day 6 days a week in a different job

Well, yes, of course. It all depends on the job.
Kanabia
22-10-2004, 17:03
Should we see more ethnic minorities in Lego?


...you're a genius. That gave me the best image.

The Ghetto Lego set!!!!

Complete with Gangsta Rappers, East European Prostitutes, etc, etc...

Man. I'd buy that. Just imagine what the characters would look like. Hehe.

Or maybe a third world country set, where the characters are twice as thin as any other?
DaJonesians
22-10-2004, 17:17
regarding kids tv shows, how can you miss out classics like Thomas the Tank Engine, and Tugs.
Then the cartoons, my favourites were Transformers and X-men
Utracia
22-10-2004, 17:18
A limit to the number of times you can appear on "Jeapardy"?

Can the New England Patriots be stopped?
Torching Witches
22-10-2004, 17:18
regarding kids tv shows, how can you miss out classics like Thomas the Tank Engine, and Tugs.
Then the cartoons, my favourites were Transformers and X-men

True, but the question kinda sounds less snappy if i list them all, doesn't it?
Nebbyland
22-10-2004, 17:46
All opinion and I can discuss any of them but these are my one word answers.

Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
YES
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
NO
Should blood sports be banned?
YES
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
NO
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
YES
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
YES
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
YES
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
YES
Should Scotland become an independent state?
NO
Should NATO be disbanded?
NO
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
NO
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?
YES
Planta Genestae
22-10-2004, 17:52
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
Should blood sports be banned?
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Should NATO be disbanded?
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?

-No,
-No,
-Absolutely,
-Not necessarily,
-Yes it should as soon as possible,
-No, but can you name another way,
-Maybe,
-Maybe,
-Maybe
-No,
-Yes,
-No, that is an absurd suggestion

Happy?
Utracia
22-10-2004, 17:55
What exactly is defined as a "blood sport"?
The Black Forrest
22-10-2004, 18:20
What exactly is defined as a "blood sport"?

He probably means ultimate fighting where you basically beat the other person into submission.

You probably could call boxing and hocky as well ;)
Marxlan
22-10-2004, 18:20
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
YES

Uhh.... yes nuclear power is the best way to meet energy needs, or yes alternative energy sources provide a viable alternatibe?
Or are you saying yes to both?
The Black Forrest
22-10-2004, 18:22
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
Yes
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
No
Should blood sports be banned?
No
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Depends.
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
NO!
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
No. Fusion!
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Yes.
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Yes.
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Yes! Kilts rule! ;)
Should NATO be disbanded?
No
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
Depends.
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?
God no!

Please add some suggestions.
Who is the greator evil and why?
Hitler
Stalin
Bush Jr.
Sadaam
Bin Laden
Barney.

;)
Daistallia 2104
22-10-2004, 18:28
:) Some of you seem to have been confused by this. My apologies if I was unclear. Please don't try to debate all these at once - I just want a list of debate topics of interest that might be thrown out every few days to mix up0 the rounds of atheists vs theists, Kerry vs Bush, draft vs none, etc. that seem to be rehashed every week.

Nuclear power is under way as we speak.
Los Banditos
22-10-2004, 18:37
Threads that are not political are always refreshing. A thread on why baseball is the worst sport ever would be nice.
Ice Hockey Players
22-10-2004, 18:49
I am surprised that no one has voted "yes" for outlawing arranged marriages. This is a despicable, abhorrent practice designed to turn young people into mere proxies of their parents, pawns if you will for parents who marry their kids off for their own interests, not their kids'. Also, a lot of young children are forced into these marriages at an age at which they cannot possibly consent to be married. It's as if we can't trust people to make their own decisions...say what you will about the divorce rate or declining birth rates; divorce and fewer children are a choice. Letting people out of bad marriages full of adultery or abuse is a far better option than forcing them to stay for the benefit of the kids or their religion. Kids will be far better off with divorced parents who are happy and can care for them without living in constant fear than they will with an abusive, alcoholic parent who sleeps around. As for religion, let's be honest - if there is a supernatural power, don't you think it has better things to do than micromanage people's lives?
Ashmoria
22-10-2004, 19:17
...you're a genius. That gave me the best image.

The Ghetto Lego set!!!!

Complete with Gangsta Rappers, East European Prostitutes, etc, etc...

Man. I'd buy that. Just imagine what the characters would look like. Hehe.

Or maybe a third world country set, where the characters are twice as thin as any other?

does this mean you dont have HOMIES in australia?

http://www.strawberrycentral.com/en/_admin/images/medium/series5med.jpg

they are very popular here in new mexico. they cover ALL the different types of people one might find in the bario from priests to gangbangers
Cisalpia
22-10-2004, 19:38
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
No
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
Can we get a woman's opinion?
Should blood sports be banned?
Yes
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Yes
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
No
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
Probably not for the nukes, let's go alternative.
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Vote!
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Vote!
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Vote!
Should NATO be disbanded?
NO
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
If the children are adults, then they have the right. If they are not, then their legal guardian controls this.
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?
Yes
Terra - Domina
22-10-2004, 19:42
I am surprised that no one has voted "yes" for outlawing arranged marriages. This is a despicable, abhorrent practice designed to turn young people into mere proxies of their parents, pawns if you will for parents who marry their kids off for their own interests, not their kids'. Also, a lot of young children are forced into these marriages at an age at which they cannot possibly consent to be married. It's as if we can't trust people to make their own decisions...say what you will about the divorce rate or declining birth rates; divorce and fewer children are a choice. Letting people out of bad marriages full of adultery or abuse is a far better option than forcing them to stay for the benefit of the kids or their religion. Kids will be far better off with divorced parents who are happy and can care for them without living in constant fear than they will with an abusive, alcoholic parent who sleeps around. As for religion, let's be honest - if there is a supernatural power, don't you think it has better things to do than micromanage people's lives?

meh, if its consentual
BastardSword
22-10-2004, 20:03
I am surprised that no one has voted "yes" for outlawing arranged marriages. This is a despicable, abhorrent practice designed to turn young people into mere proxies of their parents, pawns if you will for parents who marry their kids off for their own interests, not their kids'. Also, a lot of young children are forced into these marriages at an age at which they cannot possibly consent to be married. It's as if we can't trust people to make their own decisions...say what you will about the divorce rate or declining birth rates; divorce and fewer children are a choice. Letting people out of bad marriages full of adultery or abuse is a far better option than forcing them to stay for the benefit of the kids or their religion. Kids will be far better off with divorced parents who are happy and can care for them without living in constant fear than they will with an abusive, alcoholic parent who sleeps around. As for religion, let's be honest - if there is a supernatural power, don't you think it has better things to do than micromanage people's lives?

I think that arranged marriages sounds like legal marriages.
So the vast majority played it off as anarchy fluff.

Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
No
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
No, while I'm not for them I can't take away the right.
Should blood sports be banned?
Only if really dangerous.
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Sometimes based on can we prove who has the rights.
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
hmm,
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
YES, but only Nuclear fusion. I don't like Nuclear fission.
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
YES
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
YES
Should Scotland become an independent state?
No, not at this time.
Should NATO be disbanded?
NO
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
NO
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?
YES
Ice Hockey Players
23-10-2004, 00:05
I think that arranged marriages sounds like legal marriages.
So the vast majority played it off as anarchy fluff.

Not sure what that means, but I have always heard arranged marriage in some sort of religious context. Back when Europe was ruled by the Catholic Church (indirectly, really, but you understand what I mean) arranged marriages were commonplace. Arranged marriage today is largely in tribal African societies, the Muslim world, and India, where religion is predominant. The common theme in these arranged marriages is the idea that they must do it and cannot get out. There is no consent issue for the people to be married. Sure, if a parent picks out a spouse for their kid and the kid is cool with it, there's no reason that can't be accepted. But if a parent picks out a spouse for the kid and the kid says no, the answer must be no.
New Granada
23-10-2004, 00:13
Arranged marriages *already are* outlawed in the united states.

There exists no legal means for parents to force their children to marry against their will. It is a cultural affair, any participant in an 'arranged marriage' has no legal compulsion to consent to the marriage.
Unfree People
23-10-2004, 00:13
I am surprised that no one has voted "yes" for outlawing arranged marriages. This is a despicable, abhorrent practice designed to turn young people into mere proxies of their parents, pawns if you will for parents who marry their kids off for their own interests, not their kids'. Also, a lot of young children are forced into these marriages at an age at which they cannot possibly consent to be married. It's as if we can't trust people to make their own decisions...say what you will about the divorce rate or declining birth rates; divorce and fewer children are a choice. Letting people out of bad marriages full of adultery or abuse is a far better option than forcing them to stay for the benefit of the kids or their religion. Kids will be far better off with divorced parents who are happy and can care for them without living in constant fear than they will with an abusive, alcoholic parent who sleeps around. As for religion, let's be honest - if there is a supernatural power, don't you think it has better things to do than micromanage people's lives?:o You are my new hero. Totally agree 100%.

they are very popular here in new mexico. they cover ALL the different types of people one might find in the bario from priests to gangbangersThey are? :o I've totally never heard of/seen them. And yes, I'm from NM...

meh, if its consentualThe terms "arranged marriage" and "consent" are mutually exclusive.
Equus
23-10-2004, 00:14
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
YES
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
YES
Should Scotland become an independent state?
No, not at this time.


Well then, should Quebec become an independent state?
Chess Squares
23-10-2004, 00:16
Well, yes, of course. It all depends on the job.
what jobs
Jello Biafra
23-10-2004, 12:00
Why isn't Ralph Nader president?
Why isn't Pat Buchanan president?
Which came first - the chicken or the egg?
Are cats or dogs better?
Is astrology accurate?
Jello Biafra
23-10-2004, 12:01
How many licks does it take to get to the center of a Tootsie Pop?
Lunatic Goofballs
23-10-2004, 12:28
Why aren't there more open vats of oatmeal, pudding and/or ketchup to push people into?
Kanabia
23-10-2004, 13:32
does this mean you dont have HOMIES in australia?

http://www.strawberrycentral.com/en/_admin/images/medium/series5med.jpg

they are very popular here in new mexico. they cover ALL the different types of people one might find in the bario from priests to gangbangers

*Looks in disbelief at the screen*

Holy shit...

I'm looking for that on Ebay!!!! :D
Daistallia 2104
23-10-2004, 16:39
Threads that are not political are always refreshing. A thread on why baseball is the worst sport ever would be nice.

Exactly, unfortunately that particular one has more or less been done several times recently (generally as an adjunct the recent spate of "American Football sucks!" threads.
Ashmoria
23-10-2004, 17:43
*Looks in disbelief at the screen*

Holy shit...

I'm looking for that on Ebay!!!! :D

they are little plastic piece of crap figures

take a look, if you want some, ill send a few to you.

unfree, maybe you dont go to enough convenience stores. i see them all the time. look for them, they are a hoot.
Ashmoria
23-10-2004, 17:47
Daistallia 2104, you have a good list of topics there

start posting them one by one. one or 2 per day

we NEED something to debate besides gay marriage and why bush sucks.
Onion Pirates
23-10-2004, 18:56
Is it possible that Serbians are not really evil, and we have just been brainwashed?

Which politicians benefit most from high oil prices?

What happened to small businesses in the last four years?

Who really killed Dr. King?

What kind of megaintelligence agency could we trust?

Anybody here ever heard of "false consciousness"? Read Karl Marx, and then look at Panhandlia's posts.

What do Brittany Spears and Las Vegas have to do with capitalism and democracy? Why does the third world see this all as one vast "western culture"?

Why do guys lust after sluts but want to marry a virgin?

When is the cure worse than the disease?

What big news stories are overhyped garbage? (i.e.- Scott Peterson, Martha Stewart, who the hell cares?)

Why don't we just buy all our medicine from Canada?

How do you know when someone has been snooping in your internet files?

Who are the real unsung heroes?

Why have looks become more important than brains?

Watch Jay Leno's "Jaywalking" interviews with average Americans and ask yourself: How can we claim to be #1?

Why do you hate Max and/or Jennifer Government?????
Daistallia 2104
23-10-2004, 18:59
Daistallia 2104, you have a good list of topics there

start posting them one by one. one or 2 per day

we NEED something to debate besides gay marriage and why bush sucks.

You're telling me! :D
Daistallia 2104
23-10-2004, 19:02
Is it possible that Serbians are not really evil, and we have just been brainwashed?

What happened to small businesses in the last four years?

Why do guys lust after sluts but want to marry a virgin?

When is the cure worse than the disease?

What big news stories are overhyped garbage? (i.e.- Scott Peterson, Martha Stewart, who the hell cares?)

Who are the real unsung heroes?

Why have looks become more important than brains?

Why do you hate Max and/or Jennifer Government?????

Some good suggestions. Thanks. :D
New Granada
23-10-2004, 19:36
Is it possible that Serbians are not really evil, and we have just been brainwashed? no

Which politicians benefit most from high oil prices? politicians who are in with the oil tycoons

What happened to small businesses in the last four years? walmart, corporat etax breaks

Who really killed Dr. King?george w bush

What kind of megaintelligence agency could we trust? one that wasnt allowed to arrest people, snoop or use weapons

Anybody here ever heard of "false consciousness"? Read Karl Marx, and then look at Panhandlia's posts. ...

What do Brittany Spears and Las Vegas have to do with capitalism and democracy? Why does the third world see this all as one vast "western culture"? because america doesnt put pressure on other countries to grant democratic freedoms, only to buy our trash

Why do guys lust after sluts but want to marry a virgin? because god hates women*

When is the cure worse than the disease? when the cure is george bush and the disease is peace and prosperity

What big news stories are overhyped garbage? (i.e.- Scott Peterson, Martha Stewart, who the hell cares?) all news stories on TV are overhyped garbage

Why don't we just buy all our medicine from Canada? evil government of the US

How do you know when someone has been snooping in your internet files? who can say, really

Who are the real unsung heroes? people who blackmail local politicians, people who ruin the lives of politicians

Why have looks become more important than brains? degenerate american culture

Watch Jay Leno's "Jaywalking" interviews with average Americans and ask yourself: How can we claim to be #1? we are only lying to ourselves

Why do you hate Max and/or Jennifer Government?????because he didnt make my nation the king nation


*"Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law. And if they will learn any thing, let them ask their husbands at home: for it is a shame for women to speak in the church." (I Corinthians 14:34-35)
Roach-Busters
23-10-2004, 19:41
Too often the same debate topics are re-hashed here repeatedly (the weekly US draft debate being a recent example).

What are some good debate topics that aren't seen often here?

I looked here (http://www.debatabase.org/alphaindex.asp) and found a few suggestions:
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
Should blood sports be banned?
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Should NATO be disbanded?
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?

Please add some suggestions.

No
Maybe
Maybe
?
?
Don't know
Maybe
Maybe
Maybe
Absolutely
Sure
(shudder) Ugh, God, no!
Utracia
24-10-2004, 14:16
Too often the same debate topics are re-hashed here repeatedly (the weekly US draft debate being a recent example).

What are some good debate topics that aren't seen often here?

I looked here (http://www.debatabase.org/alphaindex.asp) and found a few suggestions:
Is it ever acceptable to pay a bribe?
Should arranged marriages be outlawed?
Should blood sports be banned?
Should cultural treasures be returned to their country of origin?
Should the "double jeopardy" rule be scrapped?
Is nuclear power the best way to meet the ever-increasing energy needs of the planet, or do alternative energy sources provide a viable alternative?
Should Kosovo become an independent state?
Should Kurdistan become an independent state?
Should Scotland become an independent state?
Should NATO be disbanded?
Do children have the right to know their biological parents?
Should the United Nations have its own permanent standing army?

Please add some suggestions.

No.
Yes. Marriage should always be about choice between two people.
No, if you mean things like hockey and American football. These aren't bullfighting.
Yes.
No.
Get more nuclear power and research other possibilities too.
Internal affair.
Internal affair.
Scotland wants to be independant? Why?
No.
Yes, once the child becomes an adult.
Why does the UN need an army? If something happens in the world countries will unite to deal with it. Besides the European Union could form an impressive army if need be.