NationStates Jolt Archive


Self-Righteous Debating Tactics

Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:08
I am relatively new to this forum and have been excited in watching all the debates on various issues. I highly respect everyone's opinion. But, I noticed something over the last week that kinda made me sad. Most debates seem to start off okay, but almost inevitably descend rapidly into personal insults and a "am not, are too" format. Many people believe that if you don't come to their side of the table, then you are uneducated, uninformed, or just plain stupid.

What ever happened to arguing a point simply on its merit? And more importantly, what ever happened to simply being able to admit if you were wrong?

OF COURSE, there are exceptions to this issue. OF COURSE many people here are excellent debaters. But, if you agree with me on this issue, or even if you don't, what can we do to make it better?
Joey P
26-08-2004, 17:10
Dude, just shut up. You clearly don't know what you're talking about.

seriously, though. just ignore the idiots, or have fun flaming away at them.
Faithfull-freedom
26-08-2004, 17:11
I promise to never tell a lie.






















damn that was a lie!
Anjamin
26-08-2004, 17:15
this is inevitably how internet debates go sometimes. its easy for some people to hide behind their computers and attack someone they disagree with. there's no way half this stuff would be said if we were all sitting in the same room having these very same arguments.

pig fucker.
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:17
I knew I was right. I know and see all.

Assholes.
New Lektavia
26-08-2004, 17:17
Whne placed behind a computer, any man can become a 9 foot tall bronze plated god. It just takes a quick mind and a sharp wit to outsmart them at every turn.
Of course, being totally and utterly sarcastic also helps...
Anjamin
26-08-2004, 17:19
Whne placed behind a computer, any man can become a 9 foot tall bronze plated god. It just takes a quick mind and a sharp wit to outsmart them at every turn.
Of course, being totally and utterly sarcastic also helps...

dude. i AM a 9 foot all bronze-plated god. stupid mortal.
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:20
Good point. It's just so :headbang: sometimes to see people sticking to an obviously innacurate position just because it's the one they started with.

You know, eventually someone will come on here and tell us we're all self-righteous assholes who think we know better than everyone.

IF THAT MEANS YOU: We don't know better. Just more. heh heh
Faithfull-freedom
26-08-2004, 17:22
"this is inevitably how internet debates go sometimes. its easy for some people to hide behind their computers and attack someone they disagree with. there's no way half this stuff would be said if we were all sitting in the same room having these very same arguments. Pig fucker"

hehe, exactly. I would not speak politics or religion with anyone in person unless they struck up the conversation and I found it to be worthy of possibly causing some hard feelings between us. I hate it when people (friends and family and strangers) that all they can talk about is stupid ass politics and religions. These are the two things I just find to be better left to specific forums or events, they are to devisive and opinionated for anyone to change thier minds. There is to much emotion in these subjects for anyone to actually come across another with any less bias than the person they are arguing with, plus nobody learns anything other than how much they despise ever being a friend or talking to that person. Some things really are better left unsaid, especially in person. Dog Dicker!
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:23
Well, 9 foot tall immortal bronze-plated God's are always wrong. I know that because I am a 9 foot tall bronze-plated Deity. and we are always right. Everyone knows that Deities are better than Gods.
Terra - Domina
26-08-2004, 17:23
You are all ignorant

lol @ internet debating
:D
Joey P
26-08-2004, 17:24
dude. i AM a 9 foot all bronze-plated god. stupid mortal.
Fuck you all! I'm 10 feet tall and bullet-proof
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:27
True. We are all ignorant.

Fuck-knuckle.
Superpower07
26-08-2004, 17:28
Well, 9 foot tall immortal bronze-plated God's are always wrong. I know that because I am a 9 foot tall bronze-plated Deity. and we are always right. Everyone knows that Deities are better than Gods.

Well I'm a 9 foot tall immortal platinum-plated God!!! j/k


Anyway, I agree that we have become self-righteous recently
Skepticism
26-08-2004, 17:28
Whne placed behind a computer, any man can become a 9 foot tall bronze plated god. It just takes a quick mind and a sharp wit to outsmart them at every turn.
Of course, being totally and utterly sarcastic also helps...

As one who has been in that position, all the sharp wit, smarts, sarcasm, and links to accepted facts are not going to budge a lot of these sort of people.

Just ignore them, or keep on lambasting them so everyone else can see what an idiot they are.
Faithfull-freedom
26-08-2004, 17:31
"Fuck-knuckle."

LMAO! Now thats a good one. Im going to use that someday on someone, watch it or speak to the Fuck knuckle!
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:32
Well I'm a 9 foot tall immortal platinum-plated God!!! j/k


Anyway, I agree that we have become self-righteous recently

Well, Platinum is far too expensive a metal to be plated with, so you are obviously an elitist. You just don't understand real life.
Terra - Domina
26-08-2004, 17:32
True. We are all ignorant.

Fuck-knuckle.

aint it some sort of bliss

;)

ass face
Anjamin
26-08-2004, 17:33
what this all boils down to is that i am awesome. and i win forever.
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:33
"Fuck-knuckle."

LMAO! Now thats a good one. Im going to use that someday on someone, watch it or speak to the Fuck knuckle!


I got tons of 'em...but as I said, I'm new to this forum and don't know how many I could post before getting booted...shitbird.
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:36
aint it some sort of bliss

;)

ass face

It sure is blissfull...

ass-pirate.
Terra - Domina
26-08-2004, 17:42
It sure is blissfull...

ass-pirate.

fish ****
New Lektavia
26-08-2004, 17:43
As one who has been in that position, all the sharp wit, smarts, sarcasm, and links to accepted facts are not going to budge a lot of these sort of people.

Just ignore them, or keep on lambasting them so everyone else can see what an idiot they are.

If all else fails, call them 9 foot tallo bronze plated deities with a confused sexuality, that normally makes em so angry they just stop talking to you.

Like the ass-pirate comment actually....
The Shawlands
26-08-2004, 17:44
fish ****

Jizz magnet. :p
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 17:44
Now, now...we've got to add some substance to our posts before we come right out with the names...

dickbump.
Terra - Domina
26-08-2004, 17:46
Now, now...we've got to add some substance to our posts before we come right out with the names...

dickbump.

oh, sorry, i thought this was just some sort of archaic vocational assult

puke fucker
New Lektavia
26-08-2004, 17:46
Hmm, i have a feeling this is going to get much worse before it gets any better...

You're all anal shrews
Dacowookies
26-08-2004, 17:49
it's usually a sign that the argument is won when the insults start, or ther're just fuckwits
Dacowookies
26-08-2004, 17:51
arse jockeys
New Lektavia
26-08-2004, 18:12
it's usually a sign that the argument is won when the insults start, or ther're just fuckwits

Insults are just a royalty for the loser of an arguement

Pussy Lickers
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 18:17
Insults are just a royalty for the loser of an arguement

Pussy Lickers

You call that an insult? I CALL IT A BADGE OF HONOR!

indeed....I am what you accuse.

nut-sweat.
Crabcake Baba Ganoush
26-08-2004, 18:43
I especially hate it when people drag in the following words and other words of their type.

Civilized (Sense of the high and mighty I’m better than you, might as well lick the shit off my boots mentality)
Evil (Usually reflects destructive personal bias)
Barbaric (Sense of the high and mighty I’m better than you, might as well lick the shit off my boots mentality)
Moral (Relative)
Immoral (Relative)
Furby (Just horridly disturbing)
Intolerant (usually hypocritical)
Homophobe (Offensive to people with real phobias)
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 19:04
Oh, there are many more...

stupid, delusional, fascist, neocon, uber conservative, ultra left, backwards, idiotic, blah, blah, blah, blah
Cogitation
26-08-2004, 19:31
While swearing in jest is not a violation of Jolt forum rules (and as far as I know, the same applies to NationStates), this is nevertheless carrying things a bit far. So, if you'd kindly stop and get back on-topic*, I'd appreciate it. Thank you.

* Specifically, the topic about how debates degenerate into flamewars.

--The Modified Democratic States of Cogitation
"Think about it for a moment."
NationStates Game Moderator
Chess Squares
26-08-2004, 19:33
this topic is FUBARd
Keljamistan
26-08-2004, 19:42
Yeah, it shouldn't have descended this far.

Anyone care to get back on topic? Why can't people just discuss?