NationStates Jolt Archive


Total Freedom of Speech

Whittier-
24-07-2004, 19:22
New I created for those who want total freedom of speech.
You can say anything you want there even if the majority is offended
and all debate is truly open and free and not dependent on whether other people like that you are debating it.
http://s4.invisionfree.com/NationalGovernments/index.php
Sydenia
24-07-2004, 19:51
Not to be mean, but there are a few things to point out. First of all, whomever owns the server that resides on controls what you can and cannot say there, as they are a private enterprise and not affected by the first ammendment.

Likewise whomever owns the server gets their bandwith from a larger company, probably an ISP. They have their own sets of rules which the owner of the server must follow, which in turn is passed down to anyone using that site.

Even if the person who runs the server support the idea of total free speech, of being allowed to say something that would be considered grossly offensive, it's extremely unlikely both the owner and the ISP/bandwith provider would both be fine with it.

In short, if any person complains about the content, your site would be closed. Just fair warning.
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 20:36
Not to be mean, but there are a few things to point out. First of all, whomever owns the server that resides on controls what you can and cannot say there, as they are a private enterprise and not affected by the first ammendment.

Likewise whomever owns the server gets their bandwith from a larger company, probably an ISP. They have their own sets of rules which the owner of the server must follow, which in turn is passed down to anyone using that site.

Even if the person who runs the server support the idea of total free speech, of being allowed to say something that would be considered grossly offensive, it's extremely unlikely both the owner and the ISP/bandwith provider would both be fine with it.

In short, if any person complains about the content, your site would be closed. Just fair warning.
Hah, unlikely.
GMC Military Arms
24-07-2004, 21:08
Just to run your own site terms and conditions back to you...


3.1 Prohibited Content:
You may not post, upload, link to, or email any Content that contains, promotes, gives instruction about, or provides prohibited Content. As the creator of a board, you are responsible for ensuring that no prohibited Content exists on your board and that no part of your board violates the Terms of Service. Prohibited Content includes any Content that breaks any local, state, county, national or international law. Prohibited Content also includes: (a) Content that infringes upon any rights [ex. MP3s and ROMs] (including, but not limited to, copyrights and trademarks); (b) Abusive, threatening, defamatory, racist, or obscene; (c) Viruses or any other harmful computer software; (d) False Information or libel; (e) Spam, chain letters, or Pyramid schemes; (f) Gambling or Illicit drugs; (g) Terrorism; (h) Hacking or cheating for internet/online games; (i) Warez, Roms, CD-Keys, Cracks, Passwords, or Serial Numbers; (j) Pornography, nudity, or sexual material of any kind; (k) Excessive profanity; (l) Invasive of privacy or impersonation of any person/entity; and (m) Hacking materials or information.

3.2 Limited Content:
(a) All Prohibited Content is not allowed; and (b) The format, number, and size of uploaded files and posts may be limited.

3.3 Content Screening:
InvisionFree does not preview any Content transmitted but reserves the right to check any board for prohibited content. InvisionFree has the right to access any board and its related Content and delete, edit, or restrict access to any Content. You agree that InvisionFree may disclose any Content to: (a) Fulfill what is required by law or is needed to comply with legal processes; (b) To prove a violation of these terms; or (c) To protect the rights (including copyrights), property, or personal safety of anyone. You understand and agree that any Content posted on InvisionFree is the responsibility of the person who posted the Content and the board creator. You agree that InvisionFree is not responsible for and does not control or endorse Content posted to the Service or available through the Service. You agree that you will bear any and all risk of reliance on the accuracy, validity or legitimacy of Content viewed on InvisionFree. InvisionFree is not responsible for any problems that may occur from reading, distributing, acting on, or using Content posted on InvisionFree.

3.4 Rights to Posted Content:
Any content uploaded or posted to InvisionFree may be published by InvisionFree. You grant InvisionFree the right to publish and store the Content.

Woo! Unfree speech and they claim publishing rights on stuff you post!
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 21:20
Abusive, threatening, defamatory, racist, or obscene
Viruses or any other harmful computer software;
Spam, chain letters, or Pyramid schemes;
Gambling or Illicit drugs;
Terrorism; (lots of anti bushies would be upset cause they support that one)
Hacking or cheating for internet/online games
Warez, Roms, CD-Keys, Cracks, Passwords, or Serial Numbers;Pornography, nudity, or sexual material of any kindInvasive of privacy or impersonation of any person/entity;
Hacking materials or information.
overly excessive profanity

course these are banned cause they violate the laws of the US of A.
Sydenia
24-07-2004, 21:21
Yeah, as was posted above they have their own sets of rules. And believe it or not, they'll almost always close a site that is complained about. Unless you're paying for their service, they have absolutely no reason to keep up a site or forum that offends visitors or breaks their ToS.

Now if you pay for your hosting, then they will be more likely to talk the matter over with you. They'd likely ask that you remove the content, and give a deadline for which to do so. Free hosts can't be bothered with it so they just close the site without a word of mention.

But, it's entirely your choice. Just sharing experience from someone who has been there.
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 21:24
Woo! Unfree speech and they claim publishing rights on stuff you post!

And this is different from the unfree speech and claimed publishing rights of the Nation States servers how exactly?
Chess Squares
24-07-2004, 21:24
cuz we all know anyone anti-bush is a terrorist


idiot
Conceptualists
24-07-2004, 22:47
course these are banned cause they violate the laws of the US of A

Even these?


Spam, chain letters,
Gambling
Terrorism; (lots of anti bushies would be upset cause they support that one)[not that this is evil, just had to add a :rolleyes:-concept]
cheating for internet/online games
Pornography, nudity, or sexual material of any kind.overly excessive profanity

These are banned in the US??
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:14
Even these?


These are banned in the US??
yes
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:17
yes

Images of nudity are banned in the USA?
Better call the cops and get them to clear out the art galleries then.
Conceptualists
24-07-2004, 23:21
yes
Why do I get so many spam from companies based in America then?

Why are chain letters constantly filling up American inboxs?

Why does Vegas exist?

Did the legitslature actually pass legitslation banning the cheating whilst playing internet games?

Why do Playboy et al sell so well, overtly, in the US?
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:35
"sexual material of any kind" is banned in the US?

Let me just check again - what do the letters "US" stand for in this discussion? - because it sure as hell isn't "United States (of America)".
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:37
Its all those religious fanatics fault.
But while that stuff is illegal, there is no way those laws can be enforced.

Example, the US Supreme overturned the laws banning porn, but municipal govenrments enforce them anyway.
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:38
Did the legitslature actually pass legitslation banning the cheating whilst playing internet games?

Apparently there was just one incident too many of Godmodding in International Incidents...
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:39
Its all those religious fanatics fault.
But while that stuff is illegal, there is no way those laws can be enforced.

Example, the US Supreme overturned the laws banning porn, but municipal govenrments enforce them anyway.


So you continue to claim that "sexual material of any kind" is banned in the USA?
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:40
So you continue to claim that "sexual material of any kind" is banned in the USA?
yes, at the local level. There's not supposed to be, but there is.
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:43
There's not supposed to be, but there is.

So, it is illegal to buy a book such as "Joy of Sex" in the USA?

There's not supposed to be, but there is.

So those 'laws' which make it illegal are not in fact 'laws', ergo it is not illegal?
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:44
So, it is illegal to buy a book such as "Joy of Sex" in the USA?
If it contains nude photos. Nudity is considered evil in america, by people with mental malfunctions.
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:46
If it contains nude photos.

It doesn't contain nude photos (unlike say, a college-level medical textbook). It is however "sexual material", so is it illegal, or are you still talking nonsense?
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:46
So, it is illegal to buy a book such as "Joy of Sex" in the USA?



So those 'laws' which make it illegal are not in fact 'laws', ergo it is not illegal?
those laws are on the books and are being enforced, but they are unconstitutional.
American city councils don't care about political or civil rights, only what's best for the rich and powerful.
That's why when you see the court's overturning some law, its usually a law passed by a county or city government. Cause the cities are the worst offenders against liberty.
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:47
It doesn't contain nude photos (unlike say, a college-level medical textbook). It is however "sexual material", so is it illegal, or are you still talking nonsense?
no, its not illegal for adults, but it is for people under 19.
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:49
those laws are on the books and are being enforced, but they are unconstitutional.

Therefore those "laws" are not laws, and so much of the material that you assert to be illegal is not in fact illegal.
Whittier-
24-07-2004, 23:50
Therefore those "laws" are not laws, and so much of the material that you assert to be illegal is not in fact illegal.
say that in english. I don't speak confabulese.
:cool:
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:50
no, its not illegal for adults, but it is for people under 19.

Which is a very different thing from what you originally claimed - that "sexual material of any kind" was banned in the US.




If you're going to keep on at this trolling or playing devil's advocate, a little bit of consistency in your position would make you appear somewhat more convincing.
Revolutionsz
24-07-2004, 23:52
In short, if any person complains about the content, your site would be closed. Just fair warning.
There is always a crybaby...
Bodies Without Organs
24-07-2004, 23:53
say that in english. I don't speak confabulese.
:cool:

The codes banning 'sexual material' are not laws, because they are unconstitional.

If they are not laws, then 'sexual material' is not illegal.

Ergo, 'sexual material' is not illegal.



***
Edit:

"A child of five would understand this."
"Send someone to fetch a child of five."
- Marx
Revolutionsz
24-07-2004, 23:56
course these are banned cause they violate the laws of the US of A.so what if the server is located outside the USA...How are they going to enforce local laws...without shuting down the Internet..
West Moon
25-07-2004, 00:00
The codes banning 'sexual material' are not laws, because they are unconstitional.

If they are not laws, then 'sexual material' is not illegal.

Ergo, 'sexual material' is not illegal.



***
Edit:

"A child of five would understand this."
"Send someone to fetch a child of five."
- Marx

They are however, enforced to the maximum.
West Moon
25-07-2004, 00:01
Where did I say I agreed with the laws?
West Moon
25-07-2004, 00:03
Which is a very different thing from what you originally claimed - that "sexual material of any kind" was banned in the US.




If you're going to keep on at this trolling or playing devil's advocate, a little bit of consistency in your position would make you appear somewhat more convincing.
though it is legal for people over 18, you are still not allowed to look at the library, in your front lawn, on the bus, or at any museum or restaurant. only inside your house.
Bodies Without Organs
25-07-2004, 00:04
They are however, enforced to the maximum.

They may well be, but that doesn't mean they are illegal.
Bodies Without Organs
25-07-2004, 00:05
though it is legal for people over 18, you are still not allowed to look at the library, in your front lawn, on the bus, or at any museum or restaurant. only inside your house.

Do restaurants in the US often contain "sexual material of any kind"?
West Moon
25-07-2004, 00:07
Do restaurants in the US often contain "sexual material of any kind"?
no. course not. I was just saying it was illegal to take porn into one and into the rest of the stuff mentioned.
It is also illegal to look at it in a public park.
Bodies Without Organs
25-07-2004, 00:17
no. course not. I was just saying it was illegal to take porn into one and into the rest of the stuff mentioned.

How is one meant to get porn into your house if one is not allowed to take it across the front lawn? (or is the pathway not considered to be part of the lawn?)
Revolutionsz
25-07-2004, 00:20
course these are banned cause they violate the laws of the US of A.and what if the server is located outside the USA...How are they going to enforce local laws...without shutting down the Internet..
Whittier-
25-07-2004, 00:20
How is one meant to get porn into your house if one is not allowed to take it across the front lawn? (or is the pathway not considered to be part of the lawn?)
good question.
You could always hide it in your bookbag or in a brown paper bag. :D
Whittier-
25-07-2004, 00:21
and what if the server is located outside the USA...How are they going to enforce local laws...without shutting down the Internet..
easy shut down the internet and demand that everyone else pay them to use it.
:D :D
Revolutionsz
25-07-2004, 00:24
easy shut down the internet and demand that everyone else pay them to use it.
:D :D
Information..Wants to be Free...*sings the 'come together' tune*