NationStates Jolt Archive

I forgot which group/school does it, but they researched claims made during elections and published what they found. Their research seemed to be neutral....

Anybody remember the site and or who did it?

The Columbia Journalism Review is doing something that sounds like what you're describing. The website is http://campaigndesk.org

http://www.wvsocialsciencesdept.net <--That site is very helpful.