NationStates Jolt Archive


Watch snake-oil McClellan dodge the question!

Texastambul
06-05-2004, 08:37
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/05/20040505-3.html

Q: Have you been able to find out when the President first learned of allegations of prisoner abuse in Iraq?

McClellan: ... The exact time period I'm not sure of, but it was some time after Secretary Rumsfeld became aware of it because he was the one who informed the President about the situation. [no date given]


Q I'm just wondering, why can't we put even a month on it? The President of the United States can't remember when he first heard that soldiers under his command may have tortured Iraqis? He doesn't remember that?

McClellan: Now, let's separate a couple of things here. [no date given]


Q Just one more on this. The President had to find out the gravity, the graphicness of this from the media, not from his chain of command. Isn't that a failure of the system, that this episode -- which as you've said has had such terrible effects around the world -- he finds out about from the media, and his own chain of command fails him in that way?

McClellan: No, no. Again, let's separate this out. [no straight answer given]


After avoiding things like dates and lack of control, McClellan tells a journalist that she is unAmerican for asking a question!

Q In that connection, has he issued a worldwide alert that all military prisons under U.S. control are not participating in such abuse? And does he know -- how about Guantanamo? Is it clean?

MR. McCLELLAN: Helen, our military adheres to high standards of conduct. And when -- and when there is a bad behavior --

Q We don't need that lecture. We know that. We believe in our country.

MR. McCLELLAN: Well, the way you phrased your question doesn't make it sound like you do --
BLARGistania
06-05-2004, 08:40
Ey! More Bush stuff. WEEEEE!

Anyway, even though I'm a liberal, I have to say, all politicans dodge questions, its like a policy they have. Not just the Bush administration.

But I would like some nice straight answers.
06-05-2004, 08:42
Tex you really shouldnt focue stoo much on the technicalities and cmall stuff.

You can beat em the Clean way.
Texastambul
06-05-2004, 08:46
Tex you really shouldnt focue stoo much on the technicalities and cmall stuff.


In what way is this "small stuff"? He called a journalist unAmerican for asking a quesiton he didn't want to answer!


Q In that connection, has he issued a worldwide alert that all military prisons under U.S. control are not participating in such abuse? And does he know -- how about Guantanamo? Is it clean?

MR. McCLELLAN: Helen, our military adheres to high standards of conduct. And when -- and when there is a bad behavior --

Q We don't need that lecture. We know that. We believe in our country.

MR. McCLELLAN: Well, the way you phrased your question doesn't make it sound like you do
Niccolo Medici
06-05-2004, 10:54
Tex you really shouldnt focue stoo much on the technicalities and cmall stuff.


In what way is this "small stuff"? He called a journalist unAmerican for asking a quesiton he didn't want to answer!

Yeah, but watch Fox News for a day and you'll see people called un-american for just about anything. Bob Novak on CNN's crossfire insinuated a whistleblower on the administration's terrorism policies was racist. Why? Because Condalezza Rice was one of the people he mentioned in his book. Stuff like this really is small in comparison to the venom that gets spewed at people on a daily basis on the networks.
Texastambul
06-05-2004, 11:00
Stuff like this really is small in comparison to the venom that gets spewed at people on a daily basis on the networks.

I don't know...

When pudits spew venom it's their voice speaking, but when the spokesman for the President does it --- that's where I draw the line!
The next step is government censorship folks ~ if this is going to be your last year with free-speech, you might as well use it.
The Atheists Reality
06-05-2004, 11:02
Stuff like this really is small in comparison to the venom that gets spewed at people on a daily basis on the networks.

I don't know...

When pudits spew venom it's their voice speaking, but when the spokesman for the President does it --- that's where I draw the line!
The next step is government censorship folks ~ if this is going to be your last year with free-speech, you might as well use it.

can anyone say, pure, uncut paranoia?
Texastambul
06-05-2004, 11:06
can anyone say, pure, uncut paranoia?

Q We don't need that lecture. We know that. We believe in our country.

MR. McCLELLAN: Well, the way you phrased your question doesn't make it sound like you do


Perhaps I need to be re-educated ?

You can always call the Homeland Security Tip line if you think I'm a terrorist...
Texastambul
06-05-2004, 15:49
But I would like some nice straight answers.

According to McClellon, that makes you unAmerican!
West - Europa
06-05-2004, 18:53
Any American who calls anyone un-American simply for uttering criticism is actually the one really being un-American.

Don't ever expect a straight answer from the White House, certainly not from this administration.

It's also been mentioned on this board a couple of times that journalist who want to remain sure of their privileged place in the White House, will know what questions to avoid.

[I hope this isn't a DP or even a triple post :( ]
Tuesday Heights
06-05-2004, 19:43
There's always men like this out there. Our President is one of them.