NationStates Jolt Archive


Beijing removes Hong Kong autonomy

_Taiwan
07-04-2004, 11:38
http://www.reuters.com/locales/newsArticle.jsp;:407397df:f269f58ba98aef?type=worldNews&locale=en_IN&storyID=4769872

HONG KONG (Reuters) - Thousands of Hong Kong democracy activists are expected to protest this Sunday against Beijing's decision to assume full control of the city's political process as a newspaper warned of popular discontent spilling onto the streets.

"We expect some 10,000 people when we march to Beijing's representative office. We want the government to begin public consultations on democratic reforms at once," said a spokeswoman of the Civil Human Rights Front.

The group organised a massive anti-government protest last July, which shocked the Chinese leadership.

Sunday's planned showdown comes after China's parliament on Tuesday passed interpretations of clauses in Hong Kong's constitution on how its leaders and lawmakers may be chosen.

The move effectively rules out any real say for Hong Kong people, who were promised a high degree of autonomy when the former British colony returned to Chinese rule in 1997.

About 60 percent of Hong Kong people want to directly elect their leader and lawmakers by as soon as 2007, but that prospect is now next to nil, political commentators say.

The interpretations mean that in one stroke, Beijing now has the right to veto any proposed electoral change and will even have the authority to decide if political changes are needed -- which means it can delay political reform for as long as it likes.


HARDLY A STIR IN MARKETS?

Despite its unpopularity, the move has left hardly any impression on markets in this financial hub.

"If there is no violence, the markets should be fine and impact will be minimal," said one money market dealer.

Kingston Lin, associate director at Prudential Brokerage said: "There's no impact on the financial markets. In fact, the ruling helps cool off quarrels and stabilises Hong Kong, which in turn will have less effect on the city's economy."

ING Financial Markets told its clients in a note: "Political noise may rise with Beijing taking full control over Hong Kong's political reforms but it is unlikely to undermine strong economic fundamentals, because the strong economy will overshadow any political uncertainties."

But some people involved in long-term investments and strategic planning were more circumspect.

"How China has interpreted the law is now beside the point, the fact that it has done it is horrifying to me," said a fund manager with a European investment house.

"The real threat is it can do it again and anytime it wants. That means there is no longer 'one country, two systems'," she railed, referring to the promise of wide-ranging freedoms that China gave Hong Kong when it took it back.

"Hong Kong bills itself as a free trade port, what if it starts raising taxes? Why should I choose to do business here? If there is violence, it'll be worse. There are too many risks. If things are so complicated, why should we choose to do business here, why not move straight to the mainland?"

Newspapers were mixed about Beijing's move. While mainland Chinese newspapers described the interpretation as necessary and timely, several Hong Kong newspapers decried the move.

In an editorial titled "Dark day for Hong Kong", the Standard newspaper likened Beijing to a bully and warned that people may be forced to vent their democratic aspirations in other ways.

"It is likely the feelings will spill onto the streets because there is no other way to express them," it said.

--------------------------------------

Well, as an expat HKer who can't do a thing, get out there and protest!
Detsl-stan
07-04-2004, 11:47
Taiwan,

Methinks the thread title is misleading. China is not TAKING AWAY any of HK's existing rights, but, rather, appears to FREEZE any moves towards greater democracy in HK.
Vitania
07-04-2004, 11:49
Booooo!
Sdaeriji
07-04-2004, 11:52
China hinted at doing something along these lines in 1997 when they took back the colony from Britain. They hold the right to do so if they choose. It is their territory.
_Taiwan
07-04-2004, 11:53
Taiwan,

Methinks the thread title is misleading. China is not TAKING AWAY any of HK's existing rights, but, rather, appears to FREEZE any moves towards greater democracy in HK.

Not now, but in another few years that will begin to happen.
Detsl-stan
07-04-2004, 12:07
Detsl-stan
07-04-2004, 12:37
suggest -Taiwan,

Methinks the thread title is misleading. China is not TAKING AWAY any of HK's existing rights, but, rather, appears to FREEZE any moves towards greater democracy in HK.

Not now, but in another few years that will begin to happen.

I think you're laying it on a little too thick :wink:
Liberalisation (however halting) on the mainland (unusually honest response to SARS, toleration of citizen initiatives (albeit nationalistic ones - like the petition drive to deny the Japanese a high-speed rail contract)) and Beijing's desire to woo _Taiwan :D suggest to me that the gov't would not risk actually rolling back HK's rights.
The Fivefold Star
07-04-2004, 12:50
If things are so complicated, why should we choose to do business here, why not move straight to the mainland?
Did this quote jump out at anyone else?
_Taiwan
08-04-2004, 03:08
Shenzhen is cheaper too.
Collaboration
08-04-2004, 03:17
Huh? They were moving toward greater autonomy? Than what? There were darned autonomous to start with, I think.
Stephistan
08-04-2004, 03:18
Taiwan,

Methinks the thread title is misleading. China is not TAKING AWAY any of HK's existing rights, but, rather, appears to FREEZE any moves towards greater democracy in HK.

It doesn't matter what the opinion is.. the PRC own Hong Kong and have so since the 99 year lease was up.. what they do is a sovereign issue. Sure they said they wouldn't interfere for 50 years.. but lets face it lots of countries break deals and treaties every day. It's an internal issue not an international one. Hell, if it was an international one the Americans would be in a lot of crap for all the treaties they've pulled out of. Hong Kong belongs to the PRC.. end of story.
Xiang Gang
08-04-2004, 10:45
China must not violate the Sino-UK Joint Declaration. The UK, after all, didn't violate it. I feel that the people of Hong Kong have been too long thrown around like a ping pong ball - they need listened to. I think that now, they are starting to be.