Enrir
03-02-2007, 17:33
I don't know if this has ever been done on this forum, but I want to simultainiously propose two drafts at the same time, one to repeal a current resolution, and the second to replace that resolution. I'm just testing the waters, looking for some thoughts on here.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion"
RECOGNIZING that some past resolutions have been made outdated by current events.
RECOGNIZING that all governments have a duty and right to protect their civilian populations.
RECOGNIZING that all people are entitled to receive a fair trial once arrested.
RECOGNIZING that some instances of person-to-person communications may contain a nation’s only chance to prevent terrorist attacks or other mass-casualty events, and that there may not be proper time to seek judiciary approval to intercept said communications.
The N.S.U.N. shall do the following:
-1- REPEAL completely N.S.U.N. resolution #10, “Stop Privacy Intrusion”, in favor of a replacement resolution that would allow nations to intercept communication without prior judiciary approval in emergency situations.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Stop Privacy Intrusion II
ALARMED by an apparent increase in the amount of privacy intrusion around the globe, we propose the following:
-1- Each UN member shall be strongly encouraged to pass legislation to state that all personal communication, including, but not limited to: face-to-face conversations, mail, telephone, radio, LAN and Internet shall NOT be intercepted by the government, unless there is serious evidence of a planned or committed crime.
-a- This evidence shall be reviewed and approved by the Judiciary before eavesdropping, phone tapping, network traffic monitoring, and other kinds of interception of communications is allowed.
-2- All member nations shall have the right to include a clause to allow for emergency interception of person-to-person communications without prior judiciary approval, and that information gained through those interceptions may be used to make arrests, so long as the following also occur:
-a- all arrested persons shall have the right to legal consol, the right to a fair trial, and the right to be shown all evidence against them prior to the trial.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion"
RECOGNIZING that some past resolutions have been made outdated by current events.
RECOGNIZING that all governments have a duty and right to protect their civilian populations.
RECOGNIZING that all people are entitled to receive a fair trial once arrested.
RECOGNIZING that some instances of person-to-person communications may contain a nation’s only chance to prevent terrorist attacks or other mass-casualty events, and that there may not be proper time to seek judiciary approval to intercept said communications.
The N.S.U.N. shall do the following:
-1- REPEAL completely N.S.U.N. resolution #10, “Stop Privacy Intrusion”, in favor of a replacement resolution that would allow nations to intercept communication without prior judiciary approval in emergency situations.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Stop Privacy Intrusion II
ALARMED by an apparent increase in the amount of privacy intrusion around the globe, we propose the following:
-1- Each UN member shall be strongly encouraged to pass legislation to state that all personal communication, including, but not limited to: face-to-face conversations, mail, telephone, radio, LAN and Internet shall NOT be intercepted by the government, unless there is serious evidence of a planned or committed crime.
-a- This evidence shall be reviewed and approved by the Judiciary before eavesdropping, phone tapping, network traffic monitoring, and other kinds of interception of communications is allowed.
-2- All member nations shall have the right to include a clause to allow for emergency interception of person-to-person communications without prior judiciary approval, and that information gained through those interceptions may be used to make arrests, so long as the following also occur:
-a- all arrested persons shall have the right to legal consol, the right to a fair trial, and the right to be shown all evidence against them prior to the trial.