NationStates Jolt Archive


Revised: The Protection of Alien Lifeforms Act

DemonLordEnigma
11-11-2004, 17:43
This is taken from Hollandia mayor's work and revised with several suggestions. The credit is his for the idea, despite his abandonment of it, and the following involves several revisions made by myself and others to make it more viable. Anything in italics is Hollandia's text, without alteration, while the rest is the revisions..

Quite recently, it came to my attention that the world at large is making more and faster advances in the fields of space travel, deep space research, and robotica. I therefore propose to instate a law to protect alien and extra-terrestrial life-forms (meaning any lifeform sentient or otherwise not originating from earth past, present, or future). In the best interest of all nations, religions, and trading ventures, I have made a few simple but significant rules:

1. There will be no permanent cities, colonies, mines, farms, or outposts with exception of small environmently friendly research stations on any planet defined as off limits. Off limits planets are planets where sentient life exists already but is not advanced enough for space travel, any planet where sentient life advanced enough for space travel exists and won't give permission for colonization, or a planet where colonization efforts will prove too disruptive to the local ecosystem.
Too disruptive to the local ecosystem is defined as causing enough of a disruption to cause large portions of the ecosystem to collapse or cause massive changes in how that ecosystem operates. An exception to this is a culture facing imminent extinction that is forced to move to a planet, as long as no other alternatives exist.

2. All manmade objects, not from the alien planet at large, should be totally clean and sanitized so as not to introduce an alien virus, pathogen, fungus, or otherwise into the extra-terrestrial's ecosystem unless introduction of organisms is part of a colonization method that does not violate rule #1. Accidental introduction of harmful organisms to a planet is to be cleaned up by the nation that introduced it or, if said nation lacks the technological capacity or manpower, another nation asked to do so by the contaminator.

3. All Terran scientists, probes, or otherwise should minimize contact with the local enviroment, or any extra-terrestrial civilization past, present, or future unless part of a colonization method that does not violate rule #1 or a cultural exchange between two advanced cultures.

4. Any battles in space shall fall under the same regulations that battles on Earth fall under.

5. Should there be an extra-terrestrial civilization present, first contact should not be made unless the civilization is advanced enough, and the aliens culture, language, customs, and values are studied intensly. Exceptions to this are in cases of advanced and modern nations having already come in contact and modern nations actively seeking to contact more advanced nations. Any advanced nation trading with a modern nation without the modern nation knowing they are advanced is to do their best to disguise their advancement level until such time as the modern nation advances to having the capacity for space travel.

6. For the purposes of this proposal, advanced is defined as having the capacity to travel to the nearest planet in less time than 1 standard Solar month.

How's this version?
Frisbeeteria
11-11-2004, 18:07
Punctuation and capitalisation are a nice touch. Thanks. As for the overall concept, our reaction is the same as the other one ... meh. It's too specific in some ways, too general in others, and not something we really think is necessary.

It's also not practical, especially Clauses 2 and 4. There is no way to perfectly sanitize anything in both directions, and there aren't really any codified rules of warfare.

The Prime Directive is a handy literary device in a fictional universe not unlike this one. It would also not survive contact with the realities of different opinions and governments. It's nice that Kirk and Picard always find races and species that are agreeable to UFP laws, or who can be bottled up in a handy wormhole or nebula if they turn out to be hostile. In the worlds of NationStates, contact usually lasts for more than an hour, and continues to cause problems even after the Enterprise has left orbit. The simplistic socio-political ideals of the 23rd Century just aren't practical here. Sorry.
Adam Island
11-11-2004, 19:07
The proposal makes sense to me. I don't have a problem with it, and it isn't too restrictive but gets rid of the problems of bloody colonization. If I don't hear any objections I agree with, I'll support it.
Tekania
11-11-2004, 19:44
I still do not side with this...

I think non-spacefaring extra-terrestrial civilizations should be considered off limits, untill such a time as they take to the stars... This includes any form of interactive research...

As such, I also do not think space-faring extra-terrestrial civilizations be placed under a different set of protocols as any other space-faring civilization (they should be treated equally).
DemonLordEnigma
11-11-2004, 19:49
With one exception, this pretty much treats both as equal. Though, the exception can also be taken to treat both as equal.
Hollandia mayor
11-11-2004, 20:00
great you worked out most of the glitches one thing i wase thinking about should the alien civilization when their resposible enough be supported
like the vulcan did with earth
Tekania
11-11-2004, 20:45
I'm just not sure about the definition of advanced... At least on the "orbital platforms" position; on the issue of propulsion, yes...

GEDRA mandates that the civilization posses some form of FTL propulsion technology (warp/transwarp/Acubeir, interdimentional, hyperspace, jump, fold, Kraskinov/wormhole in nature, or even eleves powering weird magic crystals)... And orbital platforms are not a qualifier... (as even only rudimentarly advanced civilizations can possess orbital platforms)...
Hollandia mayor
11-11-2004, 22:31
simple any civilization that has the ability to go faster then light or reach a neigbour world
DemonLordEnigma
11-11-2004, 23:40
I'm editting the definition now.