NationStates Jolt Archive


What 20 nations do you consider most powerful?

UnitedSovietRepublic
21-01-2004, 02:09
What 20 nations here do you consider most powerful?
Isles of Wohlstand
21-01-2004, 03:12
Let me think, ahhh yes, here:

1)Isles of Wohlstand
2)Wohlstandi Isles
3)Small bodies of land sorrounded by water of Wohlstand
4)Isolated areas of Wohlstand...
and the list goes on

OOCly: I only say this as to not exclude anyone who might get angry at me.
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 03:14
Depends on what level of technology you possess and the skill of the RPer...
Ruhr
21-01-2004, 03:17
Me.
Me.
Me.
Me.
Menelmacar.
Melkor.
Me.
Me.
What is left of SATO
Me.
Me.
Me.
Me.
Members of the BDI.
Me.
Me.

Oh, did I mention, Ruhr?
Kaukolastan
21-01-2004, 03:38
Well, as far as I've seen by claims of power, the most powerful countries were created today, have 200 allies (all created today), and will kill us all if we don't join their region.
Automagfreek
21-01-2004, 03:39
Well, as far as I've seen by claims of power, the most powerful countries were created today, have 200 allies (all created today), and will kill us all if we don't join their region.

Word.
The Evil Overlord
21-01-2004, 03:53
First tell us what your definition of "power" is. Military strength (and how is that defined? The most conquests? The largest military force?), economic might, political influence, population density, some combination of all of the above?

Somebody once posted a "Power" calculator that used a wide variety of factors to determine a nation's power ranking. A lot of people argued with the author since it had the appearance of a bias toward UN activity, and the thread eventually died out.

So tell us what you mean by "power".


TEO
Liverpool England
21-01-2004, 05:07
Well, as far as I've seen by claims of power, the most powerful countries were created today, have 200 allies (all created today), and will kill us all if we don't join their region.

Word.
Yeah.
Liverpool England
21-01-2004, 05:07
Well, as far as I've seen by claims of power, the most powerful countries were created today, have 200 allies (all created today), and will kill us all if we don't join their region.

Word.

Yeah.
Foe Hammer
21-01-2004, 05:17
1. Scolopendra
2. Angelus
3. Slag
4. Menelmacar
5. Western Asia
6. Karmabaijan
7. Foe Hammer (Military-power wise)
8. Katganistan
And I dunno who else...
Drizzts Army
21-01-2004, 05:20
1.Xanthal
2.Soviet Hagreed
3.Iuthia
4.Anti-Terror Army
5.Rave Shentavo
6.Dontgoonearth

Thats what I think so far
Liverpool England
21-01-2004, 05:21
1. 3 billion pop nations - WITHOUT the pop bug.
2. 2 billion pop nations - WITHOUT the pop bug, 3b nations WITH the pop bug.
3. 2b nations with the bug
Liverpool England
21-01-2004, 05:22
1.Xanthal
2.Soviet Hagreed
3.Iuthia
4.Anti-Terror Army
5.Rave Shentavo
6.Dontgoonearth

Thats what I think so far

YOU. ARE. SO. DAMN. WRONG.
Sakkra
21-01-2004, 05:24
*points to the Triumvirate, and then to Arda nations*

That about covers it.
Sketch
21-01-2004, 05:26
I would tentaively place myself somewhere around 15th.......a nice, conservative estimate.
Xanthal
21-01-2004, 05:27
I may be as high as 7 or 8 but I'm definately not 1. There's at least a good half dozen space nations that could kick my ass in a fight. I won't bother factoring in modern nations, since that's a whole different wavelength.
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 05:29
I'm around 200-300, because of my low profile and distance from the main populated systems...
Isles of Wohlstand
21-01-2004, 05:31
Same here, I have 2 billion pop(non-pop bug), frightening economy, but I am just looked over, and widely not paid attention to.
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 05:36
Same here, I have 2 billion pop(non-pop bug), frightening economy, but I am just looked over, and widely not paid attention to.

Were you resurrected?
Western Asia
21-01-2004, 05:38
I rate myself in the top 50, maybe top 40...not much better.
Copiosa Scotia
21-01-2004, 05:51
1. 3 billion pop nations - WITHOUT the pop bug.

There are none.

In no particular order, based on a combination of material power, name recognition, RP talent, and tactical skill:
Tahar Joblis
Menelmacar
Melkor Unchained
Santa Barbara
Ilek-Vaad
Scolopendra
New York and New Jersey
United Indiastan
Arani
The Silver Turtle
Western Asia
Sketch
Nianacio
Edolia
Ma-tek
Sentient Peoples
The Brotherhood of Nod
Milantos
Kalessin
Iesus Christi
Isles of Wohlstand
21-01-2004, 05:53
Yes, ex-December nation, ressurected. My nation had an error happen around the end of February
Karzakistan
21-01-2004, 06:15
Karzakistan is the most spiritually powerful nation in the world, as only the people of the holy nation of Karzakistan are in touch with the great Karzak. The people of our allied nation of The Holy Imperium if Evil Oranges may not measure up in numbers or technology but make up for it with their fantaic dedication.
Rhinara
21-01-2004, 06:18
A future tech nation with over 2 billion without the bug. But alas, I don't have enough time to get my name out on this forum. Oh well.
California and Alaska
21-01-2004, 06:29
Wow.... and nothing about California and Alaska?
New York and Jersey
21-01-2004, 06:30
C&A you rarely RP :-P Few remember you.
Santa Barbara
21-01-2004, 06:32
Meeeeeeee. :P
Klonor
21-01-2004, 06:34
I think some people are forgetting my huge fleet of multi-km uber-battleships
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 06:34
I think some people are forgetting my huge fleet of multi-km uber-battleships

Which I probably have more of...
New York and Jersey
21-01-2004, 06:34
I think some people are forgetting my huge fleet of multi-km uber-battleships

No we just dont care,because people with smaller ships can hand you your ass anyway. :roll:
Klonor
21-01-2004, 06:39
Um, I was kinda joking around. I only have about 10 uber-huge ships, and they work more as command ships than combat ships. The rest of my ships are more realistic. Well, not realistic since they've all got FTL and laser weapons and gadgets that take up half a page with techno-babble
Rhinara
21-01-2004, 06:44
Hmm, I still haven't had the opportunity to reveal my fleet. But then I am a super stealth nation, so I guess there are some advantages to that.
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 06:47
Meh most of those so called super powers would be dead in a split second by my forces!
Drizzts Army
21-01-2004, 06:47
1.Xanthal
2.Soviet Hagreed
3.Iuthia
4.Anti-Terror Army
5.Rave Shentavo
6.Dontgoonearth

Thats what I think so far

YOU. ARE. SO. DAMN. WRONG.

Or maybe I haven't been around or even seen the ones you call powerful,remember this is my opinion,not a fact.So don't take it like I wrote a diplomatic bbok for people to know really who are strong nations.That what people always do they ignore that its a opoion and they think its a fact whats wrong with you people.:igh:
New York and Jersey
21-01-2004, 06:49
Meh most of those so called super powers would be dead in a split second by my forces!


Why?Would you bombard each of us with pictures of your forces and zero RP skill?
21-01-2004, 06:57
Meh most of those so called super powers would be dead in a split second by my forces!


Why?Would you bombard each of us with pictures of your forces and zero RP skill?

No, we would write half a full page of excellent RP, and RF would post a picture of a T-80 tank and say "I took your capital comrade. GLORY TO THE SOVIET PEOPLE." Then he would post a picture of a sickle and hammer. :roll: :roll:
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:08
You never read my posts properly then do you? Im actually largely respected for my pictures and i do put thought and proper RPing. But of course since im known for my pics you have to so quickly assume i have no skill.

But whats funny is dickheads like the lot of you when RPing me can easily place their forces in Western Europe or Asia even though you may have no political presense there. Then idiots like you claim im a war mongerer but whats funny is get get attacked 5 times more than i attack.

ALSO HOW CAN I RP IF YOU FOOLS HAVE NO MAPS! I CAN NOT DEPLOY MY TROOPS PROPERLY!
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:10
Meh most of those so called super powers would be dead in a split second by my forces!


Why?Would you bombard each of us with pictures of your forces and zero RP skill?

So Placing Forces in Western Europe without any allies there makes you such a great war RPer?
New York and Jersey
21-01-2004, 07:13
Geee....you invade other countries people dont control(Baltic States), and you think countries near you wouldnt ask for help?Just like you took liberties with Eastern Euorpean countries, people said two can play at that game and do the same(Of course your lack of commonsense would mean that you fail to see this simple thing). Your also an idiot, if you think people respect you with the pictures you post.
Reploid Productions
21-01-2004, 07:15
Whoa, let's not let this degenerate in a flamefest, alright?

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod
21-01-2004, 07:16
You never read my posts properly then do you? Im actually largely respected for my pictures and i do put thought and proper RPing. But of course since im known for my pics you have to so quickly assume i have no skill.

But whats funny is dickheads like the lot of you when RPing me can easily place their forces in Western Europe or Asia even though you may have no political presense there. Then idiots like you claim im a war mongerer but whats funny is get get attacked 5 times more than i attack.

ALSO HOW CAN I RP IF YOU FOOLS HAVE NO MAPS! I CAN NOT DEPLOY MY TROOPS PROPERLY!

OOC: Since that was semi-directed towards me,

1) I have been reading your posts, for a long time
2) If you properly RPed along time ago, wouldn't the older nations remember it?
3) The reason my forces are in Western Europe is because my country is in Western Europe.
4) Look at a map of Italy
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:30
Pictures create atmosphere but idiots like you don't know that right New York? I make huge posts and i get attacked by god modders more than anyone else which makes my RP's never work! The only successful ones are against GDODAD. RF is known very well for the wars against GDODAD and people also confirm RF and its allies has won the war.

I may have attacked the baltics like hmmm.... when i was a feeble 100 million population nation! Now its much differen't because you let wars like those ones in the deep past influence your stupid thinking. It was also a time when we havn't made rules in RPing and i was new to Nation States RPing.

for WaterTes

1)Well goodie
2)Because most Old nation i Rped with don't exsist But im know for WW3 and WW4.
3)That wasn't directed to you fool
4) Read number 3
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 07:31
CAN YOU GUYS STOP ARGUING!?!
Reploid Productions
21-01-2004, 07:33
Okay, cool it, guys. Do I need to send you to opposite corners for a time out? Watertest, Russian Forces, New York and Jersey- cool it. This thread was about opinions on the most powerful nations, not critiqueing and pestering people for their RP styles.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 07:35
Okay, cool it, guys. Do I need to send you to opposite corners for a time out? Watertest, Russian Forces, New York and Jersey- cool it. This thread was about opinions on the most powerful nations, not critiqueing and pestering people for their RP styles.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod

Its okay now, since RF created a thread about it somewhere...
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:35
Im just getting sick of this crap. People should look at things before they can judge.
Kanuckistan
21-01-2004, 07:36
Back at the subject at hand, I'd say I'm up there on the power scale, atleast in space. One of the largest countries, frightening econ with one of the highest per capita spending rates on defence, most of which has been poured into the High Navy(space), leaving my army small for my size and somewhat underfunded in many respects, tho my holdings are a maze of defencive fortifications, and most people belong to citizen militas, so it balances out for the most part(especially when trying to level the modern-future tech gap).
New York and Jersey
21-01-2004, 07:36
Okay, cool it, guys. Do I need to send you to opposite corners for a time out? Watertest, Russian Forces, New York and Jersey- cool it. This thread was about opinions on the most powerful nations, not critiqueing and pestering people for their RP styles.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod

*raises arms up* I stopped, I havent posted again...I could have but didnt. I'm not even angry, more amused.
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:43
Okay, cool it, guys. Do I need to send you to opposite corners for a time out? Watertest, Russian Forces, New York and Jersey- cool it. This thread was about opinions on the most powerful nations, not critiqueing and pestering people for their RP styles.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod

*raises arms up* I stopped, I havent posted again...I could have but didnt. I'm not even angry, more amused.

im amused at your ignorance.
21-01-2004, 07:46
I may be as high as 7 or 8 but I'm definately not 1. There's at least a good half dozen space nations that could kick my ass in a fight. I won't bother factoring in modern nations, since that's a whole different wavelength.

You aren't even top 100 you god modding sack of crap
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 07:46
Okay, cool it, guys. Do I need to send you to opposite corners for a time out? Watertest, Russian Forces, New York and Jersey- cool it. This thread was about opinions on the most powerful nations, not critiqueing and pestering people for their RP styles.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod

*raises arms up* I stopped, I havent posted again...I could have but didnt. I'm not even angry, more amused.

im amused at your ignorance.

And I at yours...
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:47
You don't even know me as much as the other fool.
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 07:47
You don't even know me as much as the other fool.

I can see from your "language" that your the fool...
Russian Forces
21-01-2004, 07:48
I can see from your quick judgement that you're a fool.
Reploid Productions
21-01-2004, 07:49
im amused at your ignorance.

Russian, knock it off, I'm serious. It looks as though the other two have dropped it, now how about you do likewise rather than push it?

I don't want to end up orangetexting and forumbanning people for a few days because they don't know when to quit.

And Eizen, you better watch it on the flaming, too, unless you want to get slapped with a forumban.

Five- don't feed the fire any further, please.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 07:50
im amused at your ignorance.

Russian, knock it off, I'm serious. It looks as though the other two have dropped it, now how about you do likewise rather than push it?

I don't want to end up orangetexting and forumbanning people for a few days because they don't know when to quit.

And Eizen, you better watch it on the flaming, too, unless you want to get slapped with a forumban.

Five- don't feed the fire any further, please.

~Evil Empress Rep Prod the Ninja Mod

Sure Reploid... :roll:
SilveryMinnow
21-01-2004, 07:59
Kewl... When you big guys start swinging, can I sell tickets to the fight?
Khrrck
21-01-2004, 08:01
Back to the topic, methinks?

I'm certainly not very powerful, but I might have the most dangerous citizens...
21-01-2004, 08:02
And now, the list of countries that scare the bejeezus out of me, in no paticular order.

Ahem.

Melkor Unchained
Iesus Christi
Vegana
New York and Jersey
a certain random female who has asked to be removed
Treznor
Lavenrunz
Santa Barbera
United Indiastan (nothing like a little self-promotion ;))
Scolopendra
The Most Glorious Hack
Zero-One
Menelmacar
RepProd (stay tuned for our bad-ass RP, coming soon!)
Kalessin (most of the time ;))
Raem
Tsaraine
Karmabaijan (even though we havn't RP'd much, if ever, together)
Tor Yvresse (in spite of grammer as bad as mine :p)
The C'tan
And Sakkra too!
And a cast of thousands who I can't really recall. You all make this game worth wasting so much damn time on! Cheers.

-Indy, the resident Cap'n Canuck.
Five Civilized Nations
21-01-2004, 08:02
Kewl... When you big guys start swinging, can I sell tickets to the fight?

sure...
Sakkra
21-01-2004, 08:05
Hey! I'm not up there! I'LL EAT YOUR BRAINS!
21-01-2004, 08:07
Hey! I'm not up there! I'LL EAT YOUR BRAINS!

Well, i thought this migh haev covered my ass...

And a cast of thousands who I can't really recall.

But, well, add Sakkra to the list too! :p
SilveryMinnow
21-01-2004, 08:08
The Republic of SilveryMinnow regards nations with the much dreaded "Cats on their flags," to be much avoided. We also do not care for nations with the word "Sushi, or Bait," on their flag or motto.
Sakkra
21-01-2004, 08:10
The neurovores are called off. Thank you for your vote!

[send fruitbasket]
Reploid Productions
21-01-2004, 08:16
Yay! I'm scary! *preens* :lol:
Vrak
21-01-2004, 12:27
Very hard to say the top 20, or even the top 100.

I mean, there are nations such as The Grendels, Praetor, Mallberta, Vegana, Western Might, Angelus, Pantera, etc...that are overlooked here. And who would really want to mess with The Evil Overlord? He'll beat you over the head with a physics book or a copy of "The Art of War" or something.

Without trying to define what is a "superpower", I'd say that any nation over a billion pop with a frightening economy (that has been sustained for quite some time) would give any rational person pause.

It also comes down to which nations don't ignore eachother. Most everyone has (or should) a list of nations that they keep track of.

My 10 won worth.
The Trojan Empire
21-01-2004, 12:41
1.) Troy
*skip*
100,000.) Menelmacar
100,001.) Reploid Productions

duh...
The Evil Overlord
21-01-2004, 12:41
And who would really want to mess with The Evil Overlord? He'll beat you over the head with a physics book or a copy of "The Art of War" or something.


In the shadows of the dimly-lit Palace, a dark figure stirred on a massive throne. A magnificently-gloved hand reached out ot the master control console and pressed the button marked, "Amused".

<OOC>
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

I don't care who you are. That's funny!


TEO
Automagfreek
21-01-2004, 16:59
Here's my list (in no order except for #1)

1. Pantera
2. Steel Butterfly
3. The Brotherhood of Nod
4. Melkor Unchained
5. Mallbeta
6. Menelmacar
7. Aequatio
8. Garrison II
9. Sketch
10. Praetor
11. Barbarosea
12. Sniper Country
13. Neo-Wu
14. Scolopendra
15. The Silver Turtle
16. Ravenspire
17. The Lowland Clans
18. Iesus Christi
19. Diminix
20. New Genoa
Melkor Unchained
21-01-2004, 19:17
And who would really want to mess with The Evil Overlord? He'll beat you over the head with a physics book or a copy of "The Art of War" or something.


In the shadows of the dimly-lit Palace, a dark figure stirred on a massive throne. A magnificently-gloved hand reached out ot the master control console and pressed the button marked, "Amused".

<OOC>
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

I don't care who you are. That's funny!


TEO

ooc: hey now.. I read the Art of War too. And a lot of The Prince before I lost it. I tried reading On War by Baron von Clausewitz [sp?] but found it incredibly obtuse and nearly impossible to understand. I'd have to read a paragraph about 6 times for it to make any sense. It was nuts.
Credonia
21-01-2004, 19:19
im powerful ;-) and can exert uch influence on the world
Audioslavia
21-01-2004, 19:49
if Audioslavians werent so apathetic i'd say we would be the most powerful nation on earth...

but we arent, so...

meh
Garrison II
21-01-2004, 21:32
Here's my list (in no order except for #1)

1. Pantera
2. Steel Butterfly
3. The Brotherhood of Nod
4. Melkor Unchained
5. Mallbeta
6. Menelmacar
7. Aequatio
8. Garrison II
9. Sketch
10. Praetor
11. Barbarosea
12. Sniper Country
13. Neo-Wu
14. Scolopendra
15. The Silver Turtle
16. Ravenspire
17. The Lowland Clans
18. Iesus Christi
19. Diminix
20. New Genoa

Thank you.
Dregruk
21-01-2004, 21:47
*Ahem*

Aren't I somewhat... powerful?

And anyone you don't like it gets a jab in his eye...
21-01-2004, 22:19
Excuse me, 1.8 billion, All-Consuming Economy(on the rise), Massive military spending, and if I do say so myself, not a bad RPer? Maybe not top 20, but perhaps an honorable mention? Larger than Diminix, larger than Reploid Productions even, just a few hundred million below Melkor, I think that's not bad, huh? By the way, I believe the list should consist of the RPing public, due to the fact that if they don't RP, their power pretty much means nothing. Some people I think should definitely be on the list:

Garrison II
Melkor Unchained
Menelmecar(Forgive me if it's spelled wrong)

They're pretty powerful I think.
The Zoogie People
21-01-2004, 22:30
I rate myself somewhere in the 70-80,000's :P

I haven't heard much, but I do know Autogramfreek has one heck of a reputation around here.
The Zoogie People
21-01-2004, 22:30
I rate myself somewhere in the 70-80,000's :P

I haven't heard much, but I do know Autogramfreek has one heck of a reputation around here.
21-01-2004, 23:23
OOC: I'm not sure how powerful I am.
Wombat News
22-01-2004, 00:10
Sheesh - not a wombat in sight!!

"Note to self - must try harder!"

WN
Automagfreek
22-01-2004, 00:52
I haven't heard much, but I do know Automagfreek has one heck of a reputation around here.

Depends on who you talk to. :wink: :P
Automagfreek
22-01-2004, 00:52
I haven't heard much, but I do know Automagfreek has one heck of a reputation around here.

Depends on who you talk to. :wink: :P
Obscure Nation
22-01-2004, 01:02
*Thinks about Arda, The Reich, and GDODAD*

Well, that is FAR more then twenty, but that's accurate...

1. GarrisonII
2. Automagfreak
3. TROUSERS
4. I.C.
5. Diminix
6. Maniaca
7. Melkor
8. Willdawg
9. Vazquez
10. Kandarin
Lapse
22-01-2004, 01:12
how about this:
1. [violet]
2. other admin
3. Salusa secondas (tech modling)
4. Senior game mods
5. Game mods
6. Senior forum mods
7. forum mods
8. n00bs
9. semi n00bs
10. serious rpers
11. serious flamers
12. serious spamers
13. generals
14. puppets
Carlemnaria
22-01-2004, 01:19
powerful on what planet and in what way.

off the top of my head i couldn't name 20 nations in the dyson sphere or sector of space or whatever it is of nation states,
although i've probably got more then that in my dossier, whatever
that's supposed to do or accomplish.

i just happen to have a real poor memory for names.

a few nations have representatives who have said cool things or created
pleasing immages in my mind. a few of this few i can recall the names of

there's the coffeeshop/bookstore and that goofy lovelorn squirell.
then there's the folks in my regeon, such as the flaming barrels of pickled fish that are familiar from other places on the net and likewise another nation or two that is.

but i guess that's getting a bit off the question.

power i only reguard as useful or tyrannical or in the totaly nonpolitical sense of generating electrical energy. i really don't see any positive point to it (political power) as an end in and of itself.

=^^=
.../\...
Carlemnaria
22-01-2004, 01:19
powerful on what planet and in what way.

off the top of my head i couldn't name 20 nations in the dyson sphere or sector of space or whatever it is of nation states,
although i've probably got more then that in my dossier, whatever
that's supposed to do or accomplish.

i just happen to have a real poor memory for names.

a few nations have representatives who have said cool things or created
pleasing immages in my mind. a few of this few i can recall the names of

there's the coffeeshop/bookstore and that goofy lovelorn squirell.
then there's the folks in my regeon, such as the flaming barrels of pickled fish that are familiar from other places on the net and likewise another nation or two that is.

but i guess that's getting a bit off the question.

power i only reguard as useful or tyrannical or in the totaly nonpolitical sense of generating electrical energy. i really don't see any positive point to it (political power) as an end in and of itself.

=^^=
.../\...
Garrison II
22-01-2004, 01:37
*Thinks about Arda, The Reich, and GDODAD*

Well, that is FAR more then twenty, but that's accurate...

1. GarrisonII
2. Automagfreak
3. TROUSERS
4. I.C.
5. Diminix
6. Maniaca
7. Melkor
8. Willdawg
9. Vazquez
10. Kandarin

I'm not the most powerful, pretty high up but not the most.
Steel Butterfly
22-01-2004, 02:30
[OOC: These threads are utterly pointless. I could very easily make a case as to why "Steel Butterfly" and the "Steel-Orion Empire" is the strongest nation in NationStates.

My nation is very far future tech. No I do not use this as a GODMOD tactic, but as an RP oppertunity. Some of the things that exist could even be classified as Fantasy, especially some of my recent Genetic Experiments, as well as my ability to travel in an manipulate time.

But before you yell, scream, shout, etc., I must say that I do not RP wars for the above reasons. If I did not use every method that I could in a war, it would be unrealistic. If I did use every method, it would be GODMOD. In fact, I'm doing one now but it is and almost has/had to be a civil war, and at that it's mostly an Action/Plot Oriented RP, not a mindless readout of numbers and stats.

Also, without bragging or whatever, I am an above average RPer, and I'm not going to downplay my ability. I have been doing such for years before NS. Regardless of stats, tactics are what win a true war in NS, and by true war I don't mean a numbers fest that gets the people pissed off at each other and then WMD's start flying around until it all gets ignored. Tactics and creative situations to win, stem directly from OOC RL ability. A nation of 100 million could beat a nation of 1 billion, but no nation of 1 billion would be willing to admit loss on this site to a nation that small it seems.

And that my friends is why NS War has turned to shit. Perhaps 5% of all posters are capable of actually RPing a fair war, and if they happen to lose, admit it realistically without slinging WMDs and ignores around like ping pong balls. NS War is a "my dick is bigger than your's" arguement taken to a new level. Frankly, it is disgusting.]

[/end semi-unfocused rant]
Roseway
22-01-2004, 02:49
Exactly. And what's more, in free-form roleplay not only can a very small nation win against a very large one, but the best writer wins outright. That is the concept of winning here, and not very many people that I've seen have grasped that.
Magnus Valerius
22-01-2004, 02:52
OOC:

Well, I bet I'm powerful... in RPing. I'm probably still getting used to the NS system with ignores and such, but I've been an RPing vet for several years at other games, and have been writing creatively since I can remember (5 years old?)

I'm not trying to brag, but it's true. :)

Other than that, I might rank somewhere in the (x)00's to (x)000's. I'm probably going to win the defensive war I am in at the moment and turn it into an offensive war against my attackers, hehe. You can check out the "600,000 People Executed in Magnus Valerius" thread as an example of my RPing and for the progress of events of the war.
Roseway
22-01-2004, 02:53
I've been creative-writing for about a month. Creative-thinking, however...
Liverpool England
22-01-2004, 02:59
Not surprised that this thread was a flamefest on page 2, these threads should be banned.
Kaukolastan
22-01-2004, 02:59
SB, you've hit the nail on the head. That's why I focus on Co-Op Stories in NS, and if the stuff in them is unrealistic, there's no worry about godmod, because it's story driven and not being used AGAINST someone.

About NS war, since it was brought up...

No nation throws 2000 planes into the air over a battle, much less the 6000+ battles I've seen. No nation sends in 20 Fleets to do battle, or the 1-59245 Armored Divs. Even if they had them, no nation would send that many in, because of sheer logistics.

Being bigger does not equal victory, despite what is commonly proposed. If age and size were all that mattered, why is the USA (small, and YOUNG) dominant on the world scene?

Total War is not EVERY WAR. Seeing fights over 12 hostages turn into a nuke-fest (or whatever WMD is preferred) is stupid as hell. Same for wars of conquest that end in the territory getting vaped. NATIONS DON'T IMMOLATE BECAUSE THEY ARE LOOSING.

On the other hand, just because you can hurl huge lists of stats and data doesn't make you win. Please, make us care with an actual story, not just dull data.

[/Tag-On Rant]

(And, since people are airing their writing creds, I've been creative writing since I was a kid.)
Steel Butterfly
22-01-2004, 03:06
Not surprised that this thread was a flamefest on page 2, these threads should be banned.

Are you willing to make a request to the mods or do you want me to?

That's why I focus on Co-Op Stories in NS, and if the stuff in them is unrealistic, there's no worry about godmod, because it's story driven and not being used AGAINST someone.

I could have said it better myself. That is where all my tech stems from. I don't have threads saying "Hey...look what I invented!", instead I use whatever means necessary to make an entertaining story. Also, you are quite right on NS war.
Garrison II
22-01-2004, 03:18
Our founder is gonna hopefully work on some battle engine for the NM, it'll certainly be intresting if it can work.
Copiosa Scotia
22-01-2004, 04:40
*Thinks about Arda, The Reich, and GDODAD*

Well, that is FAR more then twenty, but that's accurate...

Not all the nations in any of those nations could be called powerful. I mean, is anyone really scared of James Adams?
Anaguum
22-01-2004, 04:52
I could be considered powerful in terms of military size (though certainly not top 20), but since I have no RP skills, I wouldn't really consider my nation to be that powerful.
Nianacio
22-01-2004, 05:01
I'd put myself at the top of the list.
Seriously, several months ago I wouldn't have wanted to go to war with AMF, just because of his reputation (and now we're of different RP groups).
Sketch
22-01-2004, 06:22
*Looks on silently as people talk about how they've built up a rep and/or really good writers/RPers*

*Decides to say something*

Well then, in that case.............I guess I wouldn't even register. I base my assumptions of power mainly upon the game mechanics (ie, UN rankings), and then take into account how people RP. Not much point in acknowledging someone whose uber in every which way when they can't even maintain a steady economy.

Any how, that's just my take on things. Carry on.

*points towards the peanut gallery and glares*

don't even dare utter those two words.......
Aelosia
22-01-2004, 06:40
ooc: hey now.. I read the Art of War too. And a lot of The Prince before I lost it. I tried reading On War by Baron von Clausewitz [sp?] but found it incredibly obtuse and nearly impossible to understand. I'd have to read a paragraph about 6 times for it to make any sense. It was nuts.

OOC: It's funny, I'm doing my thesis about the application of the postulates of the War by Von Clausewitz and Sun Tzu's Art of War within the current politics in the Latin American countries.

Now, for me they are, based in raw power and RP skills, taking into account that I'm almost a n00b dirt bag compared to most people here:

1.- Menelmacar :D
2.- Melkor :(
3.- Scolopendra :wink:
4.- Reploid Productions (although I've seen him/her playing rare times)
5.- Angelus :shock:
6.- The rest of the SATO alliance nations :P
7.- The rest of the ARDA alliance nations :cry:
8.- Automagfreek? (even if sometimes he's too graphic)
9.- sketch (too powerful but a rare view except for tagging)
10.-Pantera (but he's a rare view lately too)

The rest are more and less at the same level of power...
Kaukolastan
22-01-2004, 06:45
Now, for me they are, based in raw power and RP skills, taking into account that I'm almost a n00b dirt bag compared to most people here

I've stolen that quote.

SWIPE!
Anhierarch
22-01-2004, 07:53
Not surprised that this thread was a flamefest on page 2, these threads should be banned.

-agrees-
Aztec National League
22-01-2004, 07:54
We forgot the most powerful

[violet]

In terms of OOC, that is.
Liverpool England
22-01-2004, 11:45
Not surprised that this thread was a flamefest on page 2, these threads should be banned.

Are you willing to make a request to the mods or do you want me to?


Go ahead.